Re: Favorite Episode, Final Round
BOBW
BOBW
Favorite Episode, Final Round - BOBW Pt. 1 is the Winner
- Thread starter Spider
- Start date
Re: Favorite Episode, Final Round
"Yesterday's Enterprise"
There was a certain amount of drama to it that the others lacked. Also, cue-for-cue, Dennis McCarthy's[/b] score is perhaps the best I've heard on television.
"Yesterday's Enterprise"
There was a certain amount of drama to it that the others lacked. Also, cue-for-cue, Dennis McCarthy's[/b] score is perhaps the best I've heard on television.
TheLonelySquire
Vice Admiral
Re: Favorite Episode, Final Round
Yesterday's Enterprise and I'll tell you why.
It's one of the only TNG episodse I could literally watch everyday. It ties everything together at the beginning and the end of the episode in Ten Forward. The episode absolutely flies by no matter how many times you've seen it.
Finally, it's an ingeneious storyline that goes forward in another future episode.
BOBW is a great finale no doubt. I just found it a bit disjointed as they tried to wrap up many, many character stories. Plus, although I like Q and his appearance ties the premier episode together with the last, I find his actions slightly not believable. I just don't buy into the fact that the Continuum (sp?) even cares about humanity and that if they did they would put it on trial. But that's just me.
BOBW1- Great episode from beginning to end. No complaints. I just think Yesterday's Enterprise is slightly better. Shelby was smokin hot though.
Yesterday's Enterprise and I'll tell you why.
It's one of the only TNG episodse I could literally watch everyday. It ties everything together at the beginning and the end of the episode in Ten Forward. The episode absolutely flies by no matter how many times you've seen it.
Finally, it's an ingeneious storyline that goes forward in another future episode.
BOBW is a great finale no doubt. I just found it a bit disjointed as they tried to wrap up many, many character stories. Plus, although I like Q and his appearance ties the premier episode together with the last, I find his actions slightly not believable. I just don't buy into the fact that the Continuum (sp?) even cares about humanity and that if they did they would put it on trial. But that's just me.
BOBW1- Great episode from beginning to end. No complaints. I just think Yesterday's Enterprise is slightly better. Shelby was smokin hot though.
TheLonelySquire
Vice Admiral
Re: Favorite Episode, Final Round
You ought to leave it up for another week or two! It's too few respondents so far.
Spider said:
Well, so far, on the first day at least, it looks like my choice isn't going to make it.
As usual, I’ll call this on Sunday morning next weekend. That will be June 3rd. Or I could leave it up longer if there seems to be a real case for it. We shall see what we shall see.
There can be only one
You ought to leave it up for another week or two! It's too few respondents so far.
Re: Favorite Episode, Final Round
^
I can't win, can I?
It doesn't look like a whole lot more folks are going to vote anyway, I'll probably call it tomorrow unless something changes. My favorite amoung these three isn't going to win anyway no matter how long I leave it open.
^
I can't win, can I?
It doesn't look like a whole lot more folks are going to vote anyway, I'll probably call it tomorrow unless something changes. My favorite amoung these three isn't going to win anyway no matter how long I leave it open.
TheLonelySquire
Vice Admiral
Re: Favorite Episode, Final Round
Spider-
I think that although you said you'd call it on June 3rd, you left the door open. Maybe you should leave it up until a more definitive time. Say Wednesday morning 9am your time? This would give people time to decide and vote knowing when the deadline actually is.
Just a thought.
Spider said:
^
I can't win, can I?
It doesn't look like a whole lot more folks are going to vote anyway, I'll probably call it tomorrow unless something changes. My favorite amoung these three isn't going to win anyway no matter how long I leave it open.
Spider-
I think that although you said you'd call it on June 3rd, you left the door open. Maybe you should leave it up until a more definitive time. Say Wednesday morning 9am your time? This would give people time to decide and vote knowing when the deadline actually is.
Just a thought.
Re: Favorite Episode, Final Round
Hm, I kind of agree with Mallory. It was clear from the start that this poll would run till Sunday - and Sunday's over, no matter what time zone anyone might live in.
I think it's kind of falsifying the results if you leave the final round open for any longer than the other rounds. I would have wished for 2 other finalists, so perhaps we should have kept the penultimate vote open for longer than the week it ran... And I guess, everybody has polls one would wish to subtly influence by leaving it open for longer. There are 54 votes, meaning 54 people voted on this poll, that's more than in quite a few of the previous rounds:
round 6 - per today 137 votes - about 45 people participated in the poll
round 5 - per today 225 votes - 45 participants
round 4 - per today 499 votes - about 50 people
round 3 - per today 670 votes - ~ 33
round 2 (a and b) - ~ 40 voters
interestingly, the season polls had a bit more participants (season 4 about 60, season 6 about 50)
I think that those who've been following these polls for the last weeks have cast their vote.
Hm, I kind of agree with Mallory. It was clear from the start that this poll would run till Sunday - and Sunday's over, no matter what time zone anyone might live in.
I think it's kind of falsifying the results if you leave the final round open for any longer than the other rounds. I would have wished for 2 other finalists, so perhaps we should have kept the penultimate vote open for longer than the week it ran... And I guess, everybody has polls one would wish to subtly influence by leaving it open for longer. There are 54 votes, meaning 54 people voted on this poll, that's more than in quite a few of the previous rounds:
round 6 - per today 137 votes - about 45 people participated in the poll
round 5 - per today 225 votes - 45 participants
round 4 - per today 499 votes - about 50 people
round 3 - per today 670 votes - ~ 33
round 2 (a and b) - ~ 40 voters
interestingly, the season polls had a bit more participants (season 4 about 60, season 6 about 50)
I think that those who've been following these polls for the last weeks have cast their vote.
Re: Favorite Episode, Final Round
^
I don't see the results changing either way, but I tend to agree. Most of the folks who have been voting here know we leave them up for seven days. Since it's the same now (as to which place the episodes are in) as it was yesterday, we'll go ahead and call BOBW Pt 1. the winner with Yesterday's Enterprise a close second. (I see only two votes cast since Sunday, one each for BOBW and YE, so it didn't change much of anything.)
I'll unlock this and post some final voting results later tonight when I get home. This is the final count when the poll was closed:
Best of Both Worlds, Pt. 1 wins with 21 votes
Yesterday's Enterprise scores 2nd place with 19 votes
All Good Things is 3rd with 16 votes (one of which was mine
)
^
I don't see the results changing either way, but I tend to agree. Most of the folks who have been voting here know we leave them up for seven days. Since it's the same now (as to which place the episodes are in) as it was yesterday, we'll go ahead and call BOBW Pt 1. the winner with Yesterday's Enterprise a close second. (I see only two votes cast since Sunday, one each for BOBW and YE, so it didn't change much of anything.)
I'll unlock this and post some final voting results later tonight when I get home. This is the final count when the poll was closed:
Best of Both Worlds, Pt. 1 wins with 21 votes
Yesterday's Enterprise scores 2nd place with 19 votes
All Good Things is 3rd with 16 votes (one of which was mine
)Similar threads
