• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Episode-a-week: The Naked Now

I've always "fan-wanked" it that the Enterprise had such new systems it served as a "training ground" for several engineers for future/in production Galaxy-Class ships or other ships with the newest technology (perhaps in the Nebula-Class ships as well.)

Picard relates a story to us in "The Next Phase" that suggests he brought Geordi on-board because he was impressed with Geordi's technical prowess. So he may have recruited Geordi to serve as helmsman for a year until the "training period" was over for the other engineers and to give time for Geordi to make it to his next promotion from Lieutenant J.G. to a full Lieutenant.

The episode has some charm to it and enjoyable but also part of the fun of seeing characters acting out of character is knowing what they're like IN character. So this episode was too early to have grasp of everyone to know how "out of character" they were being under the polywater intoxication/Psi 2000 "virus."

And, yeah, this is the first episode to make people really hate Wesley. I think he got better in the second season and beyond but in the first season he was just annoyingly insufferable. The CE in the episode, while unaffected by the polywater intoxication, says it would take "weeks of laying out new circuits" to turn in the tractor beam into a repulsor beam and waves the notion away when Wesley suggests just "doing it in your head." He continues to do so while drunk and changes the dynamics of the tractor beam in seconds. (And, with all respect to Wil Wheaton at his age and at this point in the series, the places he punches on the console makes no sense.) Not to mention the fact that making a repulsor beam is hardly a new idea (done in TOS) and you'd think would simply be a normal part of the tractor beam's function. Hell, isn't pushing shit out of the way with low-level tractor beams essentially what part of the deflector system does?!

But, the episode does have some charms to it particularly the interaction between Tasha and Data and the interaction between Picard and Crusher. But it still has a bit of the "finding its footing" feel to it also bogged down by the use of a Phase II script.

And, I still don't get what that "horking up a tonsil stone" noise is all about with Picard. I mean what the fuck?! Was Crusher checking him for a hernia or something?

If I remember right, Gene wrote a scene in engineering just to get the set built.

Yeah, he did that for EaF so that the set could be built as part of start-up costs of the series. Had it not been then they would have had to wait for the second season's start-up costs, so Gene wrote in the scene in Engineering for an excuse to build the set. They didn't want a CE to prevent too much similarity to TOS and along with the idea the ship was advanced enough to not need too much of an engineering staff. Obviously this changed by the second season where it was maybe realized Geordi could be given more to do, Wesley was more suited at the helm in (a junior officer position) and that the Engineering department certainly had its place in the story lines.

Of course, had engineering not been built (which really wasn't much, just a extension off the corridor sets) for the pilot it would have been built for the second season which means it may have been a much more dynamic set. Of course they would mean no 10-Forward set or that would have been pushed to Season 3.
 
And, I still don't get what that "horking up a tonsil stone" noise is all about with Picard. I mean what the fuck?! Was Crusher checking him for a hernia or something?

I don't see what's so hard to get about that. Crusher was getting all hot and bothered, and he made that noise as a way to break her train of thought and get her out of horny-mode.
 
And, I still don't get what that "horking up a tonsil stone" noise is all about with Picard. I mean what the fuck?! Was Crusher checking him for a hernia or something?

I don't see what's so hard to get about that. Crusher was getting all hot and bothered, and he made that noise as a way to break her train of thought and get her out of horny-mode.

I do wonder what Dr. Crusher's hands are dong below the frame at the moment. However, it wouldn't explain how Picard caught the water virus, because his uniform doesn't seem to allow for the entry of a hand for skin-to-skin contact there.

Seriously, I just assume he caught it off camera. The Conn officer who comes down with it earlier is also not shown contracting it on screen.

The bigger question is how it continued to be transmitted even after they knew what it was. They may have thought they had the cure, but that's no excuse for such stupidity. Everybody on the ship should have been wearing gloves, and probably some kind of head and face covering. At the very least, they should have been careful about what/whom they touched. Riker carrying Troi and then touching Dr. Crusher's neck was especially brainless.
 
But it still has a bit of the "finding its footing" feel to it also bogged down by the use of a Phase II script.

Star Trek: The Next Generation only used two scripts from that aborted series, as far as I know -- "The Child" and "Devil's Due." "The Naked Now" was an original (as original as a silly sequel to "The Naked Time" could be).
 
I expect some Wesley hate in this thread.

There is hate, there is revolting, there is repulsive (I made it into a repulser beam!) and their is just flat out weird.

For example, take this exchange.

Picard through Wesley's Device: Take the helm Mr. Crusher. Set a course for 380, Warp 6.
LaForge: That's the Captain's voice.
Wesley: It's pieced together from words he's used over the intercom. With this, I can pretend he's ordering me to take the Enterprise anywhere.

Ok, ok. Wesley records Picard's voice from the intercom speaker without really telling anyone and pieces the voices together to make a voice simulator so that Wesley can pretend Picard is giving him orders. This sounds less like his dream of serving on the bridge and more like a weird fetish Wesley has. Of all the things he could do in his spare time when not creating nano robots, it's pretending Picard is ordering him around. What the heck?
 
I expect some Wesley hate in this thread.

There is hate, there is revolting, there is repulsive (I made it into a repulser beam!) and their is just flat out weird.

For example, take this exchange.

Picard through Wesley's Device: Take the helm Mr. Crusher. Set a course for 380, Warp 6.
LaForge: That's the Captain's voice.
Wesley: It's pieced together from words he's used over the intercom. With this, I can pretend he's ordering me to take the Enterprise anywhere.

Ok, ok. Wesley records Picard's voice from the intercom speaker without really telling anyone and pieces the voices together to make a voice simulator so that Wesley can pretend Picard is giving him orders. This sounds less like his dream of serving on the bridge and more like a weird fetish Wesley has. Of all the things he could do in his spare time when not creating nano robots, it's pretending Picard is ordering him around. What the heck?

It's even odder that the ComSystem is so easily fooled by this recording that Wesley is able to use it fake an order from the captain, placing Wesley in command. You'd think the computer wouldn't be fooled by such shenanigans.

So basically in this episode Wesley was our Kevin Riley, pissing everyone off and making the situation worse.
 
It's even odder that the ComSystem is so easily fooled by this recording that Wesley is able to use it fake an order from the captain, placing Wesley in command. You'd think the computer wouldn't be fooled by such shenanigans.

You expect a 1987 TV show to present a realistic depiction of how a 24th century computer would defend against such shenanigans and how an ingenious 24th century hacker would overcome the defenses?
 
It's even odder that the ComSystem is so easily fooled by this recording that Wesley is able to use it fake an order from the captain, placing Wesley in command. You'd think the computer wouldn't be fooled by such shenanigans.

You expect a 1987 TV show to present a realistic depiction of how a 24th century computer would defend against such shenanigans and how an ingenious 24th century hacker would overcome the defenses?

I'd say it would be fair of them to remember the bit in the previous episode where Riker asks the computer where Data is, showing it knows where all the crew-members are at any one time (though I'm not sure it's been established on screen yet this is due to the comm badges). If Picard's giving orders in engineering whilst his locator has him on the bridge that should send up a pretty big red flag.
 
Well, it doesn't seem that the computer actively knows where people are at all times otherwise there's several episodes where the computer should have spoken up right away when crewmembers are removed from the ship by some outside force.

So the computer only "knows where someone is" when asked and, yeah, it seems to depend on the use of a combadge. In "Brothers" Data's able to imitate Picard on the bridge while the real Picard is in Engineering.

I would just think the computer would tell the difference between a recording of a voice and the voice being actually spoken.

Otherwise it seems all one needs to take over a starship is to tap into the comsystem (something apparently Wesley can do without violating any rules or laws), record someone's voice, and then play it over the intercom or to the computer.
 
I like the end when Data hurriedly throws in the isolinear chips. And his calm 'No...' answer when Riker asks if he'll be finished in time.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top