• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

DEFIANCE Season 3

Did they kill off the McCauleys in order to free up the mine for the Omec and whoever? I guess this actually completes Stahma's plan without her having to get her hands dirty. I thought maybe she only mentioned her plan (to get ownership of the mine) to Daytak in order to get him to agree to the marriage of Alack and Christie. Now it belongs to baby Luke. I wonder if he'll ever find out that Grandma brutally murdered his mother? Or will Alack find out?
 
Alac saw Stahma ending Christie while outside the house...he just doesn't know the context behind her actions.
 
Did they kill off the McCauleys in order to free up the mine for the Omec and whoever? I guess this actually completes Stahma's plan without her having to get her hands dirty. I thought maybe she only mentioned her plan (to get ownership of the mine) to Daytak in order to get him to agree to the marriage of Alack and Christie. Now it belongs to baby Luke. I wonder if he'll ever find out that Grandma brutally murdered his mother? Or will Alack find out?

From a budgetary standpoint, they probably killed off the McCauleys to pay for the new actors. It certainly wasn't to pay for the special effects.
 
I muddled through last season, half-watching, but so far, this season has been a must-watch for me. I love Rahm Tak and I think it's great that he loves our culture, especially our music, but hates us. The scene with him and Alak discussing music was great! I also like Datak and Stahma working for General Tak. Before they were written as doings things because they were basically out for themselves, but their plans always seemed to lack a certain direction. This gives them a focus, as well as a bit of sympathy.
 
it's hard to have sympathy for Stahma because she's so ruthless. But she is so fascinating to watch as she schemes.
 
Completely agree. She is a great character. Having Jaime Murray playing her almost makes for the never getting her HG Wells Warehouse 13 spinoff.
 
Well, I kind of had it predicted as soon as the Biomen showed up in the elevator that we were going to meet Pottinger in the bunker, but otherwise this was an awesome episode. Still, predictable though it might have been I liked the reveal scene just for Nolan's "nuts" reaction.

Pottinger remains just as creepy and deranged as ever, and finally Amanda learns about his spy-cams in her room from last year, Though really, last year would have been the more appropriate time to do something with that storyline. If anything it feels like they threw that in to make him look creepy, then didn't know what do with that storyline until they pay lip service to it here when they wrap up Pottinger's story arc.

I don't really like the revelation that Pottinger was Amanda's rapist. Sure, it makes sense, and many were assuming that last year when the whole thing of Amanda being raped was introduced to the show, but to me it reeks of small universe syndrome. Okay, they try to rationalize it with Pottinger apparently being bisexual and having a thing for Connor Lang which led him to assault Amanda for his own twisted reasons, but is still comes off as really unlikely, one in a million type of thing that Pottinger got assigned to Defiance and essentially succeeded Amanda as its Mayor.

So just who is Lawkeeper in Defiance now, Nolan or Berlin? Nolan's the one giving all the orders, but Berlin still wears the Lawkeeper badge as opposed to a Deputy badge.
 
I was under the impression that Berlin is the "official" lawkeeper, and she clearly wants to keep that position because of her grudge against Irisa. Nolan might reclaim it in an official capacity, but he's mainly there to help protect the town.
 
Except as usual any time something needs doing Nolan takes charge or gets given the reins by others. When Tommy was the lawkeeper this made a lot of sense.
 
Yeah, Nolan is certainly acting like the Lawkeeper and treating both Berlin and Irisia as though they're his deputies.

I actually thought that he'd gotten his job back (again) between episodes or something.
 
The matter is rather confusing at times. The theory I've come up with is that Berlin is the Lawkeeper while Nolan has some sort of undefined security position which keeps him out of the Lawkeeper's typical policing duties, but in an emergency situation, he does have authority over the Lawkeeper's forces.
 
The matter is rather confusing at times. The theory I've come up with is that Berlin is the Lawkeeper while Nolan has some sort of undefined security position which keeps him out of the Lawkeeper's typical policing duties,

I don't know when Datak ans Stahma warned Tak that Nolan was coming his way they refereed to him as Defiance's Lawkeeper.
 
The matter is rather confusing at times. The theory I've come up with is that Berlin is the Lawkeeper while Nolan has some sort of undefined security position which keeps him out of the Lawkeeper's typical policing duties,

I don't know when Datak ans Stahma warned Tak that Nolan was coming his way they refereed to him as Defiance's Lawkeeper.

maybe they thought that refering to him as Defiance's lw keep would given some context to who Nolan was but not realising that Tak knew of him from the Pale Wars.
 
The matter is rather confusing at times. The theory I've come up with is that Berlin is the Lawkeeper while Nolan has some sort of undefined security position which keeps him out of the Lawkeeper's typical policing duties,

I don't know when Datak ans Stahma warned Tak that Nolan was coming his way they refereed to him as Defiance's Lawkeeper.

Bearing in mind that when they left Defiance, he was still the Lawkeeper, and they weren't aware he spent seven months away and that someone else was filling in as Lawkeeper. At the time they said that, they genuinely believed Nolan was still Lawkeeper. Hell, even when they do return to town, it was Nolan commanding the defenses that met with them, and who questioned them while they were getting a medical check-up, so they probably still thought he held the position then.

Of course, further confusing the matter, when Berlin arrested Datak for hoarding guns, he referred to her as "Deputy" despite the fact she was wearing the Lawkeeper badge and she didn't correct him. Then later, when Amanda visited Datak in the jail Berlin is referred to in dialogue as the Lawkeeper.
 
Tonight's episode: History Ryhmes
TV Guide said:
Amanda and Doc Yewll must enlist the Omec for help rescuing Nolan and Irisa, who have fallen into an unexpected and potentially fatal tour of their own past. Meanwhile, Datak and Stahma prepare a decisive move against Gen. Rahm Tak, leader of the Votanis Collective.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top