I just saw it. I came in with high expectations based on the glowing reviews, and while the film is very good, it didn't meet those expectations. A solid 3 stars out of 4 from me, though.
I liked the stylistic changes that Coogler makes to give this its own identity and move this series squarely into modern times. Much has been made about how Coogler shot the film and justifiably so. It's equal parts slick, personal (as in you're right there with the characters) and grit.
I was surprised by how likeable Donnie is as a character...he comes across as a genuinely nice guy, and you can see how he so easily disarms Rocky and convinces him to become his trainer. Despite his past, he didn't have a chip on his shoulder and he is eager to learn and be around Rocky. Sure he slips up, but you forgive him because it's understandable why he thinks the way he does. And it's easy for you to root for him because you genuinely like him.
I liked that Rocky had a purpose in the story other than simply being the trainer. And while less time is spent on romance here than in the original Rocky, Bianca is also a likeable, realistic character.
But the emotional punch and character journey I was expecting didn't quite materialize. Rocky's ordeal just kind of happens, and while some critics are praising the film's MAIN training montage, it didn't really do much for me because it didn't feel EARNED like in other Rocky films. The setting was unique, sure, but...I expected more punch from it.
And the climactic fight...again, it just kind of happens. There's very little buildup to it and suddenly you're there, with less than 20 minutes of the film to go. But I will say that the final round was awesome. You're genuinely pumped like the rest of the characters. You're with Donnie all the way, and you want him to "go through him! Run over him!" as Mickey would say. It generates more excitement than most of the Rocky sequels, and the composer waits until this very moment to unleash some of the original music. It's perfectly timed and makes you want to shout "Yeah!"
I don't know if it'll get any Oscar WINS, but I can see at least 3 nominations for "Creed." And that in itself is an achievement.