I'm sure you mean well, but ...
Which would be criticized as bringing nothing new to the franchise and aping TNG if it was "Star Trek: Orville".
"The Orville" did bring in some of the writers and producers of TNG, but at the same time they did go in new
dimensions directions, in ways TNG did not go.
But a couple episodes are too much of a knockoff (e.g. the colony inside an asteroid) And Orville, like Star Wars, did take from other franchises and styles and successfully made their own...
It's also technically a sci-fi parody, though since then it got a lot more serious undertones (Season 2). It's become its own show. TNG never did the "species forcing sex changes and hates heterosexuality" shtick... Data may have had a few too many siblings after a while to remain credible but thankfully only one of them was an emotionally psychopathic genocidal maniac and not the lot of them... Isaac was more like the Cylons but with a hint of Data as a ruse, and consistently without any emotions of any sort. So they knew from the get-go how Isaac would be, but I digress..
Also, speaking of aping, DSC was pretty quick to bring in Mudd and the Mirror Universe, having the lead character be the best thing ever (rather like Kirk, but if anything ramped up a bit), and so on..... the new things it brought to the table -- well, we know Spock would not be a murderer as such and everything else anyone could think about - well that's just a super-dee-duper SECTION 31 thing (in yet another example of a pointless prequel mimicking... ) (On edit: yeah, it's a prequel but those tend to have little creativity to begin with, and trying to answer questions that were never asked but end up causing more questions for no reason...)
Then they saw how well Orville was doing so they moved toward silliness. Tilly being the prime example of her going toward a caricatured extreme... The tv trope
Flanderization usually takes a bit more time...
That said, I have posted clips of good scenes before... as with most things, there's good or bad. Even bad episodes can have good scenes and good episodes can have bad scenes. It's an entire spectrum.
(On edit, consolidating)
I'd think in light of seeing anything Star Wars or Star Trek in recent times, it would be evident that longstanding fan satisfaction is not the priority
Or if the longstanding fans don't care they don't care. Some have and to varying extents. Which is strange given how PIC, told to us by its producers that
it's not a sequel, surely is striving really hard to be one. And sequels are generally aimed more at fans than newbies, reintroducing old characters, you name it. (But keeping in mind TWOK is a sequel to TMP, which was a sequel of TOS and none of those three are the identical tone; styles and formats will be tweaked or shifted. So there's more going on to what makes a show work or not...)
