Season 5 suffers (and I
DO mean
suffers) from the 2 China eps...
"Purity" &
"Back in the Bottle" and (
SORRY Saturn5

)
"Married with Fishsticks".
Its hard for me to "pick" a fav season. It always seems "the one I'm watching" is my fav at the time. Its not that I'm fickle, but rather that I enjoy the totality of the experience. When one of Xena's primetime competitors closed shop the same year the series ended
(Star Trek Voyager 2001) I spent 5 nights and countless hours pouring out my thoughts season by season, explaining why each one was precious in its own way.
Despite my immersion in the Xena subject these last 11 months, I do not feel adequate to do the same (just thank your lucky stars) for this show.
I will admit, that
every season touches my heart.
I absolutely
love the evolution of
Gabrielle throughout the years, from village girl hiding behind the nearest rock while Xena fought the bad guys, to Amazon Princess, then Battling Bard, then Peacenik (
SORRY Saturn 5

) then Warrior Queen.
I loved the way she "rebelled" against the accepted standard of her day, and ran off to join Xena. (NMore fun than running off to join the circus!) I also loved it when she ran across her betrothed again, and became smitten by mid season 1 but STILL left to follow Xena. I really liked it when they met again in season 2 and she fell in love with him and my heart bled for her when he was killed.
Tim (?) has bemoaned the fact that TPTB made Callisto nice, but what I really like is that
although TPTB
did allow Gabrielle (and Hercules and Joxer) to have an impact on the
humanization of XENA: WARRIOR PRINCESS, they
never whitewashed her back story.
Xena killed hundreds if not thousands in her campaigns across Europe and the far East, not even counting what she did in Higuchi. She was not above lying, kidnapping, stealing and of course killing if it suited her purposes. And each time you thought it couldn't get any worse... ("Friends in Need") we learn evil Xena
HAS done "worse".
Just as I liked how
Evil Xena was
truly evil... I also love the show's message of
working towards redemption that comes through nearly every "week". As Kate Hepburn once suggested,
stop boo hooing over your lot in life and the bad breaks you've been handed, and DO something to change it. Xena
tried to "change it" on her own but couldn't. Still she eventually
did recognize someone who could help her on this journey of redemption, and like any good commander, she took advantage of the people available to her.
I also like the show's message that a home is what you make, and its corollary that "family"
isn't just a biological entity. Its a social construct. This is as true in ST:Voyager as in Xena:WP.
Regarding
"definitive lists"...
Whoosh has an article in their archives from 4/2004 #88 detailing their "essential" and fans' "best" lists... unfortunately I can't link to it so just go to whoosh.org and click on articles and start
scrolling down (
No pun intended

)
RJ Stewart on
Xena:WP