Spoilers AHSOKA series [Spoiler Discussion]

[Ithekro]

In the World Between Worlds Ezra could hear people talking from across time. Past, present, and future. Be we already know the Force can do that. Palpatine had been foreseeing for a while. Seeing the future got the Skywalkers in trouble more than once, while seeing the past is useful in solving a mystery.

 

[Turtletrekker]

"Always in motion is the future.'

 

[CorporalCaptain]

Time travel ≠ changing history.

 

[Reverend]

If that's for me, I didn't say she was pulled into the future. I said she was pulled through a window by a boy from her future.

You're splitting hairs is what you're doing. Like I said; the narrative intent of the scene is clear: Ahsoka was pulled out of time by Ezra who was also out of time. Nobody travelled into either the past or the future. Anything else is semantics.

In the World Between Worlds Ezra could hear people talking from across time. Past, present, and future. Be we already know the Force can do that. Palpatine had been foreseeing for a while. Seeing the future got the Skywalkers in trouble more than once, while seeing the past is useful in solving a mystery.

The interesting part of that for me is that the voices from the past started even before he got into the Void; first in the hyperspace-ish/whatever the hell thing the Lothwolves did to get them back and forth across the planet in moments, then again when activating the painting. Unless I'm forgetting something, I don't think the voices from the future specifically started until he entered the Void physically, and while there were a few from the past (Yoda, the Daughter, and The Father leap to mind) from that point onwards they were predominantly from the future.

Not sure what (if any) significance there is to that. Best guess; it's a way to distinguish between tapping into the Living Force vs. the Cosmic Force.

 

[Tuskin38]

Maybe the jedi and sith's abilities to see the future is them tapping into the TWBW

 

[cooleddie74]

These are on the way soon, judging from the fact a UK toy retailer now has copies of them.

 

[Tosk]

Anything else is semantics.

It's funny, that's the word I was going to use too.

Two people from different time periods meet and interact. Everything else is semantics.

Like I said; the narrative intent of the scene is clear: Ahsoka was pulled out of time by Ezra who was also out of time.

Yes. Two people exited the point in time they previously inhabited. Then they came back to their respective points of origin.

You're splitting hairs is what you're doing.

I would argue that splitting hairs could quite possibly apply to something like saying that Ezra's hand shouldn't count because of some maybes.

I checked the scene again just to remind myself because it had been a while, and visually it sure seems like his hand exits the portal. It has those little ripples around it and everything.

 

[fireproof78]

Two people from different time periods meet and interact. Everything else is semantics.

I usually just call it birthdays or family reunions.

 

[Ithekro]

One could say the same about entering hyperspace as it is another dimension.

 

[Reverend]

One could say the same about entering hyperspace as it is another dimension.

And that it supposedly has a non-specific, possibly variable effect on subjective time.

 

[Mage]

Yes, they both travel from one place to another. Their two origins are places separated by both space and time. Then they both travel to a shared space and time.

Yes, but if I recall neither traveled to a different time in their own dimension. Lets call that Dimension A. They both went to another dimension, Dimension B, where time does pass. But two beings from two different times in Dimension A can enter Dimension B at the same time of Dimension B and interact.
This is NOT time travel. It's dimensional travel. They never traveled to another time in Dimension A.
Now, if they had spend time in Dimension B for, shall we say one year, and then enter Dimension A at a point where two years would have passed, one can say time travel took place. But they always re-enter Dimension A at a point where the exact same amount of time has passed as in Dimension B. So not time travel. Again, Dimensional Travel.

 

[Set Harth]

Yeah, Morai is a pretty big x-factor in all of this. We know she can get in and out of the Void at will (after all, how else does she keep appearing on different planets at just the right time?)

And Morai got to Peridea somehow!

But that doesn't matter because they both were in a space where time doesn't exist.

Or does it?

I checked the scene again just to remind myself because it had been a while, and visually it sure seems like his hand exits the portal.

Who you gonna believe, your lying eyes?

 

[Gaith]

Yes, but if I recall neither traveled to a different time in their own dimension. Lets call that Dimension A. They both went to another dimension, Dimension B, where time does pass. But two beings from two different times in Dimension A can enter Dimension B at the same time of Dimension B and interact.
This is NOT time travel. It's dimensional travel.

Stuff like this is why the phrase "a distinction without a difference" became a phrase. Even if Ezra didn't walk completely through a portal into another time, spend a week there, make friends, and invent rock and roll before returning to his time, I say that merely traveling from his normal reality/time to the World Between Worlds, where time has no meaning, is a form of time travel.

 

[Tuskin38]

So Filoni said at the Ahsoka S2 panel at celebration that the Mortis gods were a George idea.

I don’t know if this is old news or not, but it’s the first time I’ve heard it mentioned

Anyways, here’s the panel

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

Accept third party cookies

 

[JD]

IGN's overview of the panel
https://www.ign.com/articles/star-wars-celebration-everything-announced-at-the-ahsoka-panel

• Our first look at Rory McCann as Baylan
• Hayden Christensen is back as Anakin again
• They also showed a video which included Sabine, Ezra, Zeb, and Chopper
• We'll be seeing A-Wing, X-Wings, and Wings Filoni wouldn't talk about
• Loth-kittens
• Admiral Ackbar will be playing a big part in the season and we will be getting Ackbar vs Thrawn
• They also talked a bit about bring Ahsoka into live action for The Mandalorian and Season 1

I'm glad we're getting Zeb this season, since he was the only surviving Rebels character will didn't see last season.
Did we see Anakin as a Force Ghost last season, or was he just in the World Between Worlds and the hologram? I'm curious if him being back again means we'll be going back to the WBW again or if he'll just be a ghost.
I actually wouldn't mind if Force Ghost Anakin made recurring appearances through the whole Post-Return of the Jedi era.

 

[cooleddie74]

Anakin appears as a Force Ghost on Peridea in the final scene of Season 1, proudly watching over Ahsoka and Sabine from the shadows.

 

[Set Harth]

Did we see Anakin as a Force Ghost last season, or was he just in the World Between Worlds and the hologram?

Anakin was a Force ghost in the World Between Worlds.

 

[JD]

Anakin appears as a Force Ghost on Peridea in the final scene of Season 1, proudly watching over Ahsoka and Sabine from the shadows.

I thought I remembered something like that, but I wasn't sure.

 

[cooleddie74]

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

Accept third party cookies

 

[thribs]

Anakin is more interested in her than his own kids it seems