• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Agents of SHIELD - Season 2 Discussion Threads. (Spoilers Likely)

I'd honestly completely forgotten that EJO was coming to the show...that is so freaking awesome all over again!
 
I still have a bit of cognitive dissonance over seeing a sheik in full Arab garb as a member of an organization that started out as Nazis. I suppose this goes back to my general skepticism over the idea that a Nazi cult could ever evolve into one that isn't racist.
But is Hydra actually a Nazi orginization? I'd been kind of assuming they were a separate group that was simply working with the Nazi's during WWII. According to Wikipedia, the comics' orginization goes all the way back to Ancient Egypt, and the Renaissance. Is there anything to rule out that kind of history in the MCU?
And even if they did start out as Nazis during WWII, I think at this point it's pretty clear they've moved beyond Nazism to their own separate thing.
 
But is Hydra actually a Nazi orginization? I'd been kind of assuming they were a separate group that was simply working with the Nazi's during WWII. According to Wikipedia, the comics' orginization goes all the way back to Ancient Egypt, and the Renaissance. Is there anything to rule out that kind of history in the MCU?

I think the burden of proof would go the other way. Captain America: The First Avenger pretty clearly established HYDRA as a research wing of the Nazis that the Red Skull turned into his own private empire, breaking ties with Hitler. There's not a shred of evidence in the movie universe that it existed before then -- and that ancient origin for HYDRA in the comics is a relatively recent retcon, if I'm not mistaken. (Seriously, though, why Ancient Egypt? It's named for a monster from Greek mythology!)


And even if they did start out as Nazis during WWII, I think at this point it's pretty clear they've moved beyond Nazism to their own separate thing.
Well, there's the Ward/Skye argument all over again. Ward likes to think that HYDRA is untainted by its Nazi origins, but Skye rejected the idea that such a thing was possible.

Then again, wasn't Volkswagen created by the Nazis? Not to mention all the rocket science done by von Braun and the like. So yeah, maybe it's possible for something founded by the Nazis to shake off its racist aspects. But in this case we're talking about an evil organization bent on world conquest. I don't see them as the sort to go in for sensitivity training.
 
But they would - and apparently did - amend their ideology to fit the available talent and cash sources.
 
By now we've seen that Hydra is an organization that grows within other organizations...there's not reason for them to be beholden to the Nazi party line any more than they were faithful to SHIELD's ideals...especially after 70 years.
 
Beholden to the Nazi party and grew from the Nazi party are two different things. Hydra has never been portrayed as beholden to the Nazi party.
 
I'm sure HYDRA will work with anyone they can exploit, but given that their whole purpose for existing is about evil and hatred and cruelty, I doubt they have a lot of concern for equal rights. Nazi or not-Nazi, it's not that important a distinction. They're still bad guys either way.
 
Baron Von Strucker?

Same guy since 1944 or Grandson?

In the comics it's the same guy. Not sure what they're going to do in the MCU.

I'm going from memory here, but I remember most of his story from the comics.

First he was given an anti aging serum that extended his natural lifespan.
Then there were a few LMDs used by Hydra.
Eventually, he was resurrected by the Red Scull and, I believe, is still alive in present day.

Like I said I'm going from memory, so I'm a bit hazy on all the details, but it's the same guy.
 
The MCU version of Strucker is purely a contemporary figure, a former SHIELD agent recruited into HYDRA. He wasn't around during WWII like his comics namesake.

By the way, I hadn't realized that his right-hand man Dr. List, who appeared in this episode, was also in the Winter Soldier tag scene. That's one more movie character who's appeared in the show. Although the actor, Henry Goodman, was uncredited in TWS.
 
No sign of Ward or Agent 33, which is fine with me...

There certaninly seems to be some opening in the management levels of HYDRA that they may be able to fill.
Maybe, but Ward never had any particular interest in HYDRA, and now seems more interested in getting back into SHIELD's good graces.

It was nice that they devoted so much time to Tripp. I especially liked Coulson visiting his mom personally and the scene where everyone is sitting around talking about him. I was kind of hoping that there would be a last minute save....
My favorite part of the episode. Particularly loved it when Skye and Gemma imitated Tripp's soft southern accent, "c'mon girrrrrl". This is the way you deal with an important character's death, you show it's impact on his friends, family, and colleagues. Not like another show I could name that killed off a major character and then ignored it. :rolleyes:
Yes, I hate the "shocking death of a major character" gimmick. Here, at least, it was dealt with on an adult level.
 
I'll bet that Bobbi and Mack are spying for Stark/The Avengers via Maria Hill, and that this is set-up for the show's tie-in angle with AoU.

The first thing that occurred to me was that they were working for Edward James Olmos' upcoming character, and that he's making a move to take over and rebuild SHIELD in cooperation with the government again, but the government won't let Coulson remain in charge because he went on the run and was "possessed" by the alien blood, so he represents too high of a potential risk factor for them to let him stay in command.

They're setting up the anti-alien factionalization on the team with Mack and Simmons, and that may have influenced Mack's decision to assist in taking Fury's "tool box" from Coulson, whose judgment and ability to resist alien influence Mack now questions. Olmos' character, if he turns out to be along the lines that I'm thinking above, could further play into that division of loyalties among the team.

The way Olmos' character was described makes him sound like he's a sometimes antagonist/sometimes grudging ally but not necessarily an enemy; more in the manner of a Talbot than someone affiliated with Hydra for instance.

Olmos will play Robert Gonzales, whose debut this spring in “Marvel’s Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.” will have massive repercussions for Director Coulson and his team.

“Edward James Olmos brings an amazing gravitas to any role he inhabits, something we knew we needed for Robert Gonzales,” said Executive Producer and Marvel’s Head of Marvel Television, Jeph Loeb. “When Olmos first appears on our series, everyone will have to take notice--including our favorite Agents.”
The emphasis on his gravitas leads me to believe they're looking for someone to take a leadership role, and the rather mundane name (which does not correspond to any existing Marvel character) doesn't strike me as something you'd choose if you were creating a new Hydra villain. Also they emphasized Coulson's position as director in the press release and said Olmos' introduction will have "massive repercussions" for him and the team. Like a change of leadership perhaps?

It's all extremely circumstantial to say the least, but that's my two cents on who Mack and Bobbi are working for, since I don't see them as being traitors so soon after Ward and Hydra, and since they're introducing his character soon anyway.
Damn, I also forgot EJO will be appearing on the show later on. This theory makes even more sense, although I agree with others that it'll probably tie into AoU in some way.
 
I hope the showmakers know what they're doing...if they pit EJO against Coulson, I'm liable to root for EJO....
 
It's kind of funny how after HYDRA members were going off about how SHIELD was doomed and how unstoppable HYDRA was, that SHIELD just strolls in and wipes out a chunk of their leadership.
 
It's kind of funny how after HYDRA members were going off about how SHIELD was doomed and how unstoppable HYDRA was, that SHIELD just strolls in and wipes out a chunk of their leadership.
Better yet- doing a mind game and having Hydra kill off it's leadership by itself and then head shoot the last remaining one...
 
^I'm not sure why I "knew" something bad was going to happen. They don't have many flawless executions.
 
I like the suggestion that Edward James Olmos might be the character that Bobbi and Mack are working for. It would certainly be a good introduction that would set him up as a major player right from his first appearance.

As for all the folks wondering if it's Stark/Hill, that's possible too, but you're forgetting one very obvious possibility: Bobbi and Mack just think they're helping Stark/Hill, but their real master is Ultron.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top