• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

A Niner Watches Babylon 5 (NO spoilers, please)

Yes, but you are so adamant in how "bad" season one is, and you don't really fudge it at all, thought I'd add some perspective. Plus, I knew it would annoy you.

:D

Dude, you would be a bit irked if someone insisted in coming to, say, a Farscape thread and repeatedly slamming that show, repeating essentially the same points as if they are gospel.

You should be. It's annoying.

:cool:
 
Can we have this thread locked until TGB adds another review? This is just ridiculous...

Please people, can't we create a separate "B5 Debates" thread since all B5 threads just go to shit immediately from the pent up discussion demand?
 
Dude, you would be a bit irked if someone insisted in coming to, say, a Farscape thread and repeatedly slamming that show, repeating essentially the same points as if they are gospel.
I'd argue with the guy but I wouldn't do the quotey thing.

And I don't think I've repeated myself that much. Pretty much only on In the Beginning, I talked about that at the start of the thread.
 
I'm impressed that this thread is still ticking along and generating replies despite having gone days without an update from TGB. :lol:
I'm shocked too. :eek: I'm seriously beginning to worry that this forum will continue to exist without me should death or a girlfriend drag me away from it. I had always assumed the whole place would disband due to grief.

I think we scare him.
A little. :alienblush: I'm just a little fish surrounded by sharks, and one or two people here might be on the same intellectual level as me. Not actually smarter, I hasten to add, but they're so close to matching me that they present a threat to my superiority complex.

Can we have this thread locked until TGB adds another review? This is just ridiculous...

Please people, can't we create a separate "B5 Debates" thread since all B5 threads just go to shit immediately from the pent up discussion demand?
I wont be too much longer, I wasn't even intending for it to be this long but I had a busy day today and when I got home I had so many things I had to do that I didn't have to time to watch an episode. I vow to watch the next episode, The Parliament of Dreams, tomorrow evening and hopefully that will get me back on a once per night schedule.
 
Can we have this thread locked until TGB adds another review? This is just ridiculous...
I left it open, because there was some good discussion going on, making some nice filler until TheGodBen had time to get back. Which it would appear he is soon to do....


Please people, can't we create a separate "B5 Debates" thread since all B5 threads just go to shit immediately from the pent up discussion demand?
Once TGB picks up his reviews again, then perhaps folks can do start a separate thread if there's more to say. It'd make sense at that point. This one has been a pretty well-behaved one fore the most part. Most B5 threads are. Not sure where you get the "go to s@$% immediately" part, however. :confused: THis oen did get a little tense and heated a couple of times, but folks cooled it down, and that's a hallmark for a good group of fen.



I wont be too much longer, I wasn't even intending for it to be this long but I had a busy day today and when I got home I had so many things I had to do that I didn't have to time to watch an episode. I vow to watch the next episode, The Parliament of Dreams, tomorrow evening and hopefully that will get me back on a once per night schedule.
Boy howdy can I ever identify with that queuing up of things that have to get done. Good to know that you will be reviewing more, though. It really is a kick to see the show through a new viewer's eyes.
 
I wont be too much longer, I wasn't even intending for it to be this long but I had a busy day today and when I got home I had so many things I had to do that I didn't have to time to watch an episode. I vow to watch the next episode, The Parliament of Dreams, tomorrow evening and hopefully that will get me back on a once per night schedule.

You'd better. I'm just kicking around for the snark.

I may watch "Parliament of Dreams" tonight myself, to refresh my memory.
 
The Parliament of Dreams (**½)

I'm beginning to regret my earlier love of Londo and G'Kar because the more I see of them the more I think they're cartoon characters that somehow ended up on a drama series. Take Londo: his main role in this episode was to get really drunk, shout nonsense about gods and pass out on the table. I don't have a problem with comedic elements in a drama series, I love The Way of the Warrior partly because of how funny it is, and the episode which made me a fan of BSG was Six Degrees of Separation, an episode with some hilarious Baltar moments. But Londo getting drunk and passing out feels forced, and drunk jokes are only a few steps up from fart jokes, in my opinion.

As for G'Kar, he also act rather comically for a man whose life in is danger, he stomps around the station in a huff and he freaks out when Garibaldi finds underwear (presumably female) in G'Kar's couch. G'Kar's suspicions of Na'Toth seem pointless for anybody who has been paying attention to the opening credits, she's hardly going to be an assassin sent to kill G'Kar and then stick around for the rest of the show after failing. This story isn't all that ground-breaking, although it did teach me what a man without an ear pinna (I learned that word so I could type it here) would look like when wearing glasses. Answer: silly.

By the way, I think I've figured out who the Big Bad of this show is. It's that insect mafia guy, right? The final episode will have an epic confrontation between Sheridan and big insect man, and it will probably end with the two of them falling into a pit of fire.

Then there's the b-plot where Sinclair meets an old flame... with sexy results! You can tell that Catherine is a love interest the moment Garibaldi sees her step onto the station and Moments in Love starts to play in the background. As far as romance on television goes this is quite cheesy, but when it comes to romance in science-fiction this isn't that bad, it's way, way above Meridian. The dialogue is at the standard level of awkwardness for science fiction romances, but I do appreciate the fact that Sinclair's back-story is being filled in and we get to see another side to him beyond reckless endangerment of his own life.

There's a c-plot about the different religious customs of the various alien species, but there's not much to that beyond Delenn and Sinclair getting married, or something. The episode ends with Sinclair introducing all the various faiths of Earth, a scene made laughable by the stereotyping done by the costuming department.
 
The Parliament of Dreams (**½)

I'm beginning to regret my earlier love of Londo and G'Kar because the more I see of them the more I think they're cartoon characters that somehow ended up on a drama series.
And so it begins....;)

By the way, I think I've figured out who the Big Bad of this show is. It's that insect mafia guy, right?
I don't think it's spoilery to say that there's not just one Big Bad on this show.


Then there's the b-plot where Sinclair meets an old flame... with sexy results! You can tell that Catherine is a love interest the moment Garibaldi sees her step onto the station and Moments in Love starts to play in the background. As far as romance on television goes this is quite cheesy, but when it comes to romance in science-fiction this isn't that bad, it's way, way above Meridian. The dialogue is at the standard level of awkwardness for science fiction romances, but I do appreciate the fact that Sinclair's back-story is being filled in and we get to see another side to him beyond reckless endangerment of his own life.
Parts of that dialogue came from real life. Guess Geek Romance and SF Romance have some parallels.

There's a c-plot about the different religious customs of the various alien species, but there's not much to that beyond Delenn and Sinclair getting married, or something. The episode ends with Sinclair introducing all the various faiths of Earth, a scene made laughable by the stereotyping done by the costuming department.
Many of the people in that scene provided their own formal religious costumes.

Jan
 
anybody who has been paying attention to the opening credits, she's hardly going to be an assassin sent to kill G'Kar and then stick around for the rest of the show

Actually, I believe G'Kar's first aide, Ko'Dath, was in the opening credits for the first few episodes originally. She had to be replaced due to makeup problems after her first appearance IIRC.

The DVDs do not contain that version of the credits; and there are a few other places where originally the credits were a bit different for a few episodes, but the generic season credits ended up attached on the DVDs for whatever reason. Stuff like a character's rank or status changing was originally reflected in the credits only after it happened, but on the DVDs that isn't always the case.

They do include "special" credits in a few particular cases, though.....
 
A suggestion about DVD credits: Skip the season two credits for the first two episodes, they're spoilerific as well.

I'm beginning to regret my earlier love of Londo and G'Kar because the more I see of them the more I think they're cartoon characters that somehow ended up on a drama series.

Ah, yes. That.

The problem is less the characters and more JMS's sense of humour. He is not good at telling jokes and any one of his characters can sacrifice whatever respect I had for them trying to set up a punchline.

But nevermind, I suspect the point about characters will be hashed to death in an episode or two's time. Fivers already know the episode - and indeed the speech, for there is always a speech - which I mean.


The episode ends with Sinclair introducing all the various faiths of Earth, a scene made laughable by the stereotyping done by the costuming department.

You thought that scene was laughable? :wtf: Wowzas.

Upon rewatch it bugged me that Sinclair identified the Daoist as 'a Taoist'. While that's a common alternate spelling, the word is correctly pronounced daoist.

This is true right up to the point an earnest person more informed than me corrects my vague understanding of pinyin transliteration and pronunciation (likely shortly.)
 
Last edited:
Yeah, "Parliament of Dreams" can be pretty stilted in places. It has its moments, and count me in as a fan of the ending, but it's still pretty average overall. The next episode is pretty cool, though, an it introduces one of the series' best recurring characters.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top