This was Doug's thinking for the J. There would be multiple generations of crew and very long, distant missions. The transparent "refit" version as Doug calls it, was intended to illustrate his concept that space-time is compacted towards the edges of the saucer to provide much a larger livable volume inside than outside, with time dilation at the edges slowing the passage of time, extending the longevity of those that chose to live there.I quite like the idea that the E-J was a generational ship that lasted for centuries on missions of inter-galactic exploration, sort of fulfilling the original idea for the Enterprise-D.
That is insanely cool. I love that kind of high-concept thinking.This was Doug's thinking for the J. There would be multiple generations of crew and very long, distant missions. The transparent "refit" version as Doug calls it, was intended to illustrate his concept that space-time is compacted towards the edges of the saucer to provide much a larger livable volume inside than outside, with time dilation at the edges slowing the passage of time, extending the longevity of those that chose to live there.
The difference is that in the Shatnerverse novels, Kirk was resurrected right after Generations, so McCoy could still be alive. If this short is set in the mid 25th century, instead, I think that's a bit too much for poor Bones to still be around, no matter how stubborn he was.I completely agree, that Bones would've been a great addition - but, why does McCoy need to be dead? You yourself brought the Shatner-novels up and in those stories, Bones is still alive and kicking. When he asks Bashir, why that'd be and Subatoi says "Dunno", Bones says "Me neither". But Shatner knew - he said that Bones was "too stubborn to die".
*giggles* Okay, that's true. ^^The difference is that in the Shatnerverse novels, Kirk was resurrected right after Generations, so McCoy could still be alive. If this short is set in the mid 25th century, instead, I think that's a bit too much for poor Bones to still be around, no matter how stubborn he was.
Jorg deleted that post, so I'm thinking that may be his subtle way of retracting it.Apparently Kovich was in the crowd as well:
Good.Jorg deleted that post, so I'm thinking that may be his subtle way of retracting it.
If that were true it would really hint at a 31th century setting.Apparently Kovich was in the crowd as well:
Bluesky
bsky.app
The last novel take place after nemesis, in the early 2380s.The difference is that in the Shatnerverse novels, Kirk was resurrected right after Generations, so McCoy could still be alive. If this short is set in the mid 25th century, instead, I think that's a bit too much for poor Bones to still be around, no matter how stubborn he was.
Not necessarily. He is a time traveler, after all.If that were true it would really hint at a 31st century setting.
Yeah, it's kinda weird in that he's old here, then the younger Daniels is the one who takes the Xindi-primate fellas initiation medal (who is standing in front of Old Daniels/Kovich) to Archer in "Azati Prime".Not necessarily. He is a time traveler, after all.
How old would that make Saavik and her son?If that were true it would really hint at a 31th century setting.
Nice. Confirms some things, leaves some others vague or open to interpretation.![]()
Exclusive: “Unification” Producer Breaks Down OTOY’s Star Trek Short Giving Kirk And Spock A Final Goodbye
TrekMovie talks to Jules Urbach for a shot-by-shot breakdown of the short film that has fans buzzing.trekmovie.com
Nice. Confirms some things, leaves some others vague or open to interpretation.
Interesting that Colt viewing the lcars of Kirk’s body from PIC is in the Kelvin timeline.
You need a corpse or something.Kirk got there the short way round. Why not Saavik and Spock jr.?
Maybe they had already been. That's how Saavik knew to point Kirk towards Yor.Kirk got there the short way round. Why not Saavik and Spock jr.?
The objection to Mrs. Spock and offspring is that they might be too far in the future. If that's the case there were most likely corpses. (Why are THEY not being reunited with Spock before he dies? Who knows? Maybe they have to go see HER parents? ... Er, the Vulcan one.)You need a corpse or something.
We use essential cookies to make this site work, and optional cookies to enhance your experience.