• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

6x01 The Impossible Astronaut (Grading/Discussion) (SPOILERS!!)

How would you rate this episode?


  • Total voters
    175
Regarding the stargate question, Anna Louise Plowman was in "Dalek" as Stratten's assistant (She was Osiris in Stargate).


I've heard Robert Carlyle was considered a candidate for the Doctor at some point.
 
I'm thinking they're trying to make Jammie dodgers into the 'new' jelly babies. Maybe the Doctor gave the JBs up because he discovered the Master was fond of them, too ;)
 
There's quite a few actors who appeared in the 1963 toi 1989 Who who then turned up in 1987-2005 Trek. Off the top of my head...
Christopher Neame: Skagra in Shada, the lord in Janeway's gothic holo-novel back in early Voyager (also in Blake's 7 and Babylon 5. And once turned up in Dallas and Dynasty in the same week...).
Maurice Roeves: Stotz in Caves of Androzani, Romulan commander in TNG: The Chase.
Guy Siner: General Raven in Genesis of the Daleks, Malcolm's father in Enterprise.
Jane Carr: Computer voice in Slipback (radio serial), Malcolm's mother in Enterprise, Londo's wife in B5.
There's bound to be more... I'm fairly sure there's someone ho wsa in the original series and then turned up in Who after returning to England.
 
Simon Pegg was in the latest Star Trek film and The Long Game from Eccles' run as the Doc.
 
Neame also played the extremely campy "Dark Jedi" villain in a Star Wars video game, Dark Forces II:Jedi Knight. Olaf Pooley, the oldest living Star Trek actor (Seen in Voyager: Blink of An Eye) was also Professor Stalhman in INFERNO (As well as Stalhman's counterpart in the other universe ;).


Also both Leonard Nimoy and Sheppard (Who both appeared in Trek XI) have been the main voiceovers for the Civilization series of PC games, although I think I already mentioned that :)
 
Anyone notice when Amy is in the oval office and see's the Silent, there is a Secret Service agent right behind her looking at the the door also but yet either does not see the Silent or is uneffected by it.
 
Anyone notice when Amy is in the oval office and see's the Silent, there is a Secret Service agent right behind her looking at the the door also but yet either does not see the Silent or is uneffected by it.

Yeah I noticed that too. And how did the Silent make his way unnoticed to the Oval Office in the first place (or even to a White House bathroom)?

Yeah once you look away you forget you see them, but they would still create QUITE a huge commotion before that happened, I would think. Soldiers and Secret Service aren't exactly trained to run or look away from a deadly threat, after all (and certainly wouldn't if that threat were a freaky, big-headed alien!)

My guess is that somehow this particular Silent was only appearing in Amy's mind.
 
Anyone notice when Amy is in the oval office and see's the Silent, there is a Secret Service agent right behind her looking at the the door also but yet either does not see the Silent or is uneffected by it.

Yeah I noticed that too. And how did the Silent make his way unnoticed to the Oval Office in the first place (or even to a White House bathroom)?

Yeah once you look away you forget you see them, but they would still create QUITE a huge commotion before that happened, I would think. Soldiers and Secret Service aren't exactly trained to run or look away from a deadly threat, after all (and certainly wouldn't if that threat were a freaky, big-headed alien!)

My guess is that somehow this particular Silent was only appearing in Amy's mind.

Good points. I did wonder about the pandemonium they would cause. Their "disguise" really only works one person at a time. I guess if it breaks down with 2 people, they just off the person, like Joy. But, no good with groups.

And, we also see why it's set in the past. Today, there are too many surveilance cameras and people walking around with camera, such as in their phones like Amy.

Mr Awe
 
I don't think this has been reported but some really good news for all the nay sayers...

Matt Smith has been nominated for the British Academy Television Award (BAFTA) for Best Actor for his performance as the Eleventh Doctor in the 2010 series of Doctor Who - the first time in the programme's history that one of its leads has been nominated for this prestigious award

He is up against Benedict Cumberbatch (for BBC One's Sherlock, created by Steven Moffat and Mark Gatiss), former Comic Relief Doctor Jim Broadbent (for Channel 4's Any Human Heart) and Daniel Rigby (for BBC Two biopic Eric and Ernie).

Doctor Who: The Impossible Astronaut, scored an Appreciation Index figure of 88, one of the highest figures of the weekend.

The score is the joint highest ever received for a series opener, Smith and Jones also scored 88. Lead in show Don't Scare the Hare recieved one of the lowest scores on record with 46

In a measure of how successful Doctor Who was over the weekend, no programme on Sunday managed to get more than 6 million watching, including Coronation Street which had 5.9 million viewers; this means Doctor Who remains in 13th position for the week, one which will rise when final figures are released.

BBC Worldwide have revealed that the series premier of Doctor Who broke new records for BBC America giving the channel its highest-rated, most-watched telecast ever in Live + Same Day ratings.

Altogether Doctor Who delivered almost 1.3 million viewers in the states, a rise of 71,000 viewers over last season’s opening episode The Eleventh Hour.

The channel also notes

  • Viewership across all of BBC America's Doctor Who YouTube content reached an all-time high of 3.5 million views.
  • The official debut of Doctor Who on Tumblr reached over 10,000 followers in two weeks.
  • Doctor Who is currently the number 1 TV series on the iTunes store.
  • BBCAmerica.com pulled in its largest traffic ever. On its best day, Saturday, April 23, 74% of users were new visitors to the site.
Meanwhile across the border on SPACE, a record 538,000 total viewers watched the premier in Canada, up 3% over the previous most-watched Doctor Who episode, making The Impossible Astronaut the most-watched SPACE broadcast this year.
 
If it appeared only in Amy's mind, then how did it manage to murder Joy? Or was that an illusion, too?

Hmm, good question. Maybe they're using that "perception filter" technology that we heard a lot about last season, and can disguise themselves or appear only to the people they wish to appear to.

Of course if they had that ability, there wouldn't be much need for their special amnesia powers....
 
Christopher Neame: Skagra in Shada, the lord in Janeway's gothic holo-novel back in early Voyager (also in Blake's 7 and Babylon 5. And once turned up in Dallas and Dynasty in the same week...).

Actually, Christopher Neame was in the Beowulf holoprogram in Voyager's Heroes and Demons. He was also a German General in Enterprise's Storm Front.
 
Doctor Who Ratings Rise in the US, Fall in the UK

http://www.escapistmagazine.com/news/view/109547-Doctor-Who-Ratings-Rise-in-the-US-Fall-in-the-UK

There's good news and bad news for the Doctor, but which news he gets depends on where he is.

"The Impossible Astronaut," the premiere of season six of Doctor Who has managed the impressive feat of being both the highest and the lowest rated season premiere since the show relaunched in 2005. US ratings were higher than they've ever been, but unfortunately, in the UK, the reverse is true.
BBC America reports that the episode received the highest ratings ever for the network, with 1.3 million viewers either watching live, or watching on DVR the same day. This is up 71,000 views from the channel's previous best, which was the premiere of season five of Doctor Who, last April. In the UK, however, the show had an average audience of 6.5 million, over two million less than the next lowest, the opener for season two, "New Earth." The BBC notes that that figure does not include people who watched the show on DVR, but still says that the episode is still unlikely to match, let alone beat, its predecessors.
 
I liked it. Didn't love it, by any means, but I didn't hate it either.

The aliens were creepy, and the concept of forgetting them after you lose sight of them is interesting. I love the quirky aspects of this Doctor, but he still almost feels like a secondary character to me. I like the fact that Doctor doesn't trust River. It's obvious that Amy and Rory's future child is critical to this season's arc. Although I liked Amy early last season, I grew to like her less as that season wore on, and I never liked Rory. I wish they were no longer on the TARDIS. I'm also a bit weary of mostly arc-based stories. I would like to have seen some feeling of resolution in this single story.

Oh well. I'm still watching.
 
The whole bit with the "What? A mysterious summons and you think i'm just going to go?"

Shades of the tenth doctor and the Ood summons.



I like the "Don't play games with me, don't ever ever think your capable of that"



10402523.jpg




I do miss the shaggy hair. He's too clean cut now.
 
Well, if the tribute to Lis Sladen is any indication, you may get your wish.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top