• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Lost from the beginning (NO SPOILERS)

The Life and Death of Jeremy Bentham:

We start with a couple new characters who are survivors of the Ajira crash. One, Ceaser, is going through a desk in the Hydra station. The other, Illana, walks in and tells him there's a man in a suit standing by the shore that wasn't on the plane. This man is John Locke, alive and well. Finally, it's time for the flashback I've been waiting for. Time to see what happened to Locke once he left the island.

He wakes up in Tunisia. I guess that's just where the wheel sends people. Did a polar bear turn the wheel somehow, then? Locke is picked up by Whidmore's people, and gets a meet and greet from the man himself. He claims that he's the good guy here, and that he's trying to protect people from Ben. He also reveals that he was once the leader of the Others. I'm not sure that I trust Whidmore any more than Ben. Have our heroes been caught in the middle of a giant pissing match between these two? Whidmore sends Locke on his way to bring the Oceanic Six back to the island. He gives him his new identity as Jeremy Bentham, and Abbadon as his driver.

His first stop is to meet Sayid, who is in the Dominican Republic doing a Habitat for Humanity type thing. Is this in penance for what he's been doing for Ben that past couple years? Sayid, of course, has no interest in returning to the island, and sends Locke on his way. Locke proceeds to meet Hurley, still in the mental hospital. Hurley is surprisingly nonchalant about seeing Locke, assuming he is dead. I'm still curious whether Hurley is really seeing dead people, or if he's just cracking up. When Locke insists he isn't dead, Hurley asks someone if he's having a conversation with a guy in a wheelchair. Once confirmed, Hurley is freaked out a bit. Locke might have had a shot at convincing Hurley, had he not seen Abbadon. Hurley freaks out even more and runs away. The meeting with Kate doesn't go very well either.

Locke makes two other visits while in the area. One is to Walt, and the other is to Helen, who has died. Locke wonders what might have been different if he had not screwed things up with her. Abbadon correctly tells him that this would have still happened, since she died of an aneurysm. As they are leaving the cemetery, someone places several bullets in Abbadon. Locke is forced to drive away himself. His terror and broken leg lead to him crashing. Coincidentally (or perhaps by fate) he is taken to Jack's hospital. Jack's meeting doesn't seem to be going very well either, until Locke mentions that Christian says hello. I like how Locke figured out who Christian's son had to be. It obviously couldn't be Sayid or Hurley's, so that left only Jack. Jack's calm exterior cracks at this, and the seeds of doubt are planted. Locke doesn't realize this, though.

Broken, distraught, and alone, Locke begins setting up his suicide. He's failed in his mission, has no idea how to return to the island, and has nobody on the mainland that cares about him. He's truly lost. He's ready to do the deed when there a knock on the door. Who should it be, but Ben Linus. Ben talks Locke down from suicide. He tells him that he's special, and that he's still needed. He also tells Locke that Jack has started taking LA to Sydney flights. Looks like Locke didn't fail as badly as he thought. Locke reveals two key pieces of information to Ben: the next stop is to contact Eloise Hawking, and that Jin is alive. Ben is taken aback by both of these pieces of news. He confirms that he already is acquainted with Eloise. Then he takes the cable that Locke was going to use to kill himself, and does the deed himself. :eek::eek::eek: Ben you cold blooded, horrible, evil, absolutely magnificent bastard!

But looks like it didn't stick. Locke is alive and well on the island. Or is he? I don't know. He looks over the injured passengers of flight 316. Among them is Ben. Locke identifies Ben as the man that killed him.

So.....Locke is alive. What's up with that? Does it have anything to do with why Christian is walking around? I had assumed that was the smoke monster. We already know that it can take someone else's appearance. The only difference is that when it was Yemmy, it didn't act like it was Yemmy. Christian and Locke both act like themselves for the most part. Does the island actually have the ability to resurrect people? If they actually are ressurected, then it doesn't explain how Christian got to be Jacob's voice. Maybe the smoke monster has gotten a little smarter in its deception? What's going on?
 
I thought "The Life and Death of Jeremy Bentham" was much better than the last episode but not quite as good as the other episodes like "Jughead" and "This Place is Death"--it was good but not great.

One thing I loved about this season was the way the writers had it down by now on how to switch focus from certain threads while they worked in advancing other ones so those could catch up to where the other ones were already in order to advance to the next stage of the story arc.

I liked the touch that Widmore remembered John from 1954 but to John it had only been a few days further confirming that Dan's right and whatever happened originally had always been that way--in other words the survivors jumps through the past and interactions with people and events were always a part of the way things unfolded they just didn't realize their role until now. I also appreciated that John actually mentioned to Widmore before departing that he didn't necessarily trust him reminding Charles he was the one who sent the mercenaries to the island. This episode also answered the question I had for a few episodes now--how does John get his new ID, know where to locate the Six and have the resources to get around given the condition in which he left the island. It also confirms he is permanently cured of his paralysis off island as well meaning Rose who had worried that leaving the island would mean getting sick again would have been fine.

I also noticed that this time there were cameras in the desert fixed on the Tunisia exit point when there hadn't been any before when Ben ended up here in "The Shape of Things to Come". It was interesting that Widmore knew to put the cameras there--Widmore had mentioned to John that Ben tricked him off the island so I wondered if Charles had been tricked by Ben to go and turn the wheel ending up here and that was how Ben managed to wrestle control of the Others away from him and why Widmore had been determined for 20 years to return.

I was also intrigued by Charles mentioning a coming war--since S1 there had been hints of a conflict between two sides. But between who--the Others and the survivors? Dharma and the Others? Dharma and the survivors? a new third party? Charles also mentioned a "truce" that he helped maintain on the island. That definitely piqued my interest.

It was nice seeing Abaddon again--too bad they killed him off but I guess they had no chance given the fact he was a series regular now on another tv show.

I was sad to hear that Katey Sagel's Helen had passed away.

The rest of the hour just showed us what happened for the most part about things we had been told about i.e. Locke meeting with everyone but I like seeing stuff filled in like the margins.

I wasn't all that surprised by Locke's resurrection since we've seen dead people alive before--so I guess the island wasn't done with him. I wasn't too impressed by the two new characters--Cesar and Ilana--especially Cesar. At first I thought Ajiera was deposited in the past but it soon became clear they were on hydra island in 2007. I was curious where Frank and Sun had taken off to. The plot gods cleverly I thought had resurrected John and the people that knew he was dead were nowhere around to be shocked by it except Ben.
 
I'm back from my mini vacation with a couple more episodes in the bag:

LaFleur:

Well, this is pretty cool. Flashbacks explain how Jin wound up in a Dharma jumpsuit. Namely, it's 1977 and Sawyer, Jin, Juliet, and Miles are all Dharma members now. They came across a woman in peril and helped her. She betrayed them at the fence, though, and they were taken prisoner. After a pretty good bluff (which Sawyer is great at) they manage to integrate themselves into the initiative.

So, it's been three years for them. A lot has happened in that time. Jin has learned to speak English pretty fluently, and Sawyer (now calling himself LaFleur) and Juliet are now together. I think I kinda saw this coming. It actually works, too. It doesn't seem forced like with Kate. They've really built lives here. It would seem the last thing they need is a certain six coming back and adding complications. But alas, that's what happens. Jack, Kate, and Hurley were found by Jin. Does that mean that Sun, Ben, and the rest of the Ajira survivors are in the present? What about Sayid?

Namaste:

Sawyer pulls some strings and integrates everyone into the initiative. Jack is ironically made a janitor. I'll bet that's Sawyer's idea of a joke. :lol: Jin runs to the Flame to find out if Sun is also here. He's not going to find anything, though. While there, Sayid comes crawling out of the jungle. The guy at the flame automatically assumes he's a hostile, and Jin is forced to play along. Sayid is later brought to the barracks.

A visit between Jack and Sawyer leads to a rather good scene. Sawyer talks about how Jack was an ineffective leader because all he ever did was react. Now that Sawyer is essentially the one in charge, he's stopping to think about his course of action. It's something that's never really occurred to me, but it's true. Every single major decision Jack has ever made has ended in disaster. In the mean time, Sawyer has managed to successfully integrate himself and his friends into the Dharma Initiative, and actually make a happy life for himself. Of course, things aren't going to stay happy for long, I can tell. The Six's return to the island ensures that trouble will be brewing. It may be pretty close. A child brings Sayid some food in his cell, and that child is a young Ben Linus.

Meanwhile in the present, Sun, Frank and Ben make way toward the main island. Sun doesn't trust Ben, though (and rightly so) so he takes a paddle to the face before Frank and Sun set out alone. Why did Sun and Ben get left in the present, while Jack, Kate, Hurley, and Sayid end up in 1977? There's got to be some reason for this. Sun and Frank make their way to the barracks, which is in pretty bad shape since the smoke monster tore it up the last time we saw it in the present. Wow, has it really been that long since we saw this setting in the present? That was way back in The Shape of Things to Come. At the barracks, they find Christian. He shows them a Dharma recruits picture from 1977 that includes Jack, Kate, and Hurley. Reuniting everyone is going to be a bitch.
 
I've tended to wonder how things for the Dharma folks might have turned out if there hadn't been...well, let's just call it outside interference.
 
THe last two episodes didn't quite have that extra something to make them great but "La Fleur" does. Another fave from S5 for me.

A lot of what I enjoyed were just the really cool simple brief moments--picking up with the survivors right after Locke fell down and learning that fixing the wheel indeed stabilized the island's time shifts, being teased by the back of the statue that we hadn't seen since S2(was its face deliberately being kept a secret? Was it Richard?), the survivors coming across Amy & Paul being harrassed by 70s Others, seeing the sonic fence again

This show also did a good job in assembling their recaps--this one right before the episode was particularly well done.

One element I think might have been handled better was showing us the teaser with Sawyer wearing a DHARMA jumpsuit and living in one of their housing units. We all knew what was going on so it wasn't quite as effective as other WTF reveals where you didn't know what was happening. So I don't think showing their hand this early was a good idea. It would have also built into what the survivors were going to do now that the island has stopped jumping.

But that said I did think it was a clever idea for the survivors to seek refuge by becoming part of DHARMA and in a nice touch the writers smartly use an established character trait by having Sawyer put his con skills at work on Horace. It was smart to choose a side and they know they'd have a better chance in penetrating Dharma than the hostile Others.

I'd always been intrigued by DHARMA and it was nice to see them being brought back into the main storyline in such a central way. I had been hoping for a while that S2 and S3's "The Man Behind the Curtain" wasn't the last word on them by the writers. Now it seems that those earlier DHARMA elements like Horace, like the stations, like young Ben were just an appetizer for things to come. I also liked the symmetry of having 3 years of time pass for the Oceanic Six and the time travelling survivors. Early on I thought that for the survivors it would seem like only a few days had passed since they last saw the Six.

I was pretty indifferent to all the attempted romances on the show-Shannon/Sayid, Jack/Kate, Kate/Sawyer, Des/Penny. I did think Claire/Charlie were sweet but Juliet/Sawyer in just this one episode won me over and I consider this the best pairing--it wasn't forced, it wasn't in your face, it was sweet, believable and innocent. I also appreciated that the writers hinted at it earlier in the season. The two actors managed to sell the bond and make me believe that they had been together for 3 years even though from the viewer's POV they had only been a couple for 45 minutes. One of my favorite moments was Sawyer reassuring Juliet about saving the baby and the fact that she was comfortable enough to share that very painful part of her time on the island.

Also loved seeing yet another generation of Others with the only constant being Richard. I enjoyed the scene where the Others come defiantly strolling into the Dharma village and Sawyer saving the day. It was nice for a change to see the Others in the dark and Sawyer holding some answers they didn't have. Plus it gave me hope we'd get to see the Others in the 70s and more about the Dharma/Others conflict.

The episode provides the exact year Juliet was brought to the island and it was fun seeing her right back where she started. Interesting bit of info that the pregnancy phenomenon doesn't exist yet. We meet Horace's wife who he builds what later becomes Jacob's cabin.

I also love the way the series effectively makes you feel that you are in the time period both visually because the way it is filmed and through the atmospherics. This definitely felt like a high point in the history of the island--everything was so vibrant and alive. I also loved the music. I also liked the black title cards helping us keep up with where in the timeline what we were seeing was occurring.

"Namaste"--Another solid one but not as good as "La Fleur".
I liked the attention to the details--like seeing Jack assume Dharma had returned to the island hence the jumpsuits, Sawyer's clever way of bringing Jack/Kate/Hurley into the group without being caught, the way the 3 year flash allowed for Jin's English to be much improved, seeing the Flame again, meeting the much talked about Radzinsky from S2, seeing the little geo dome model of what we recognize as the Swan station, Ethan being Horace and Amy's son which Juliet saves but who goes on to lure her to the island and lived next to her as seen in "Not in Portland", Sawyer finally getting a nice pair of glasses after the early seasons with him with taped together broken glasses:lol:, we first heard of 14J as a code used by Alex to warn Ben she was with Keamey and here we learn where it came from--it was the designation used by Dharma for hostiles-neat . We *finally* learn why the Others were building an airstrip from S3--for Aijera to safely land on--cool. Does Ilana not really know who Ben is? We hear more about the "truce" that we first heard about from Widmore in ep 5.7

I loved Sun whacking Ben--it just reminds you of how she really has come into her own. The village scene was creepy. Was Claire there? Nope spooky Christian. What is he up to now? Where was Dan? Did he off himself or join the Others over his grief of losing Charlotte? Definitely curious about that.

I had just been thinking about if young Ben had arrived at the island yet and had the survivors run across him yet? And was he working with Richard & the Others?

Also the writers sure do think ahead since they wisely had Sun back in "Theres no place Like HOme" unable to attend the memorial service for Jack's dad otherwise she would have seen his portrait at the service and been totally freaked out by seeing him standing before her alive and well.

Also this episode helped the timeline along by giving us a better window of when exactly Dharma came to the island--72 was the earliest recruitment photo we saw plus kinda neat to know that recruitment photo of Jack, Kate and Hurley were in that photo all along and as many times as our characters had been in that rec room they never bothered to stop and look.
 
Last edited:
One of the most memorable things about "Namaste" for me whem it originally aired was it sparked immediate and intense fan debate about who the "extra guy" was in the photo. If you look at Christian's photo carefully, you'll notice when it cuts to the 70s and picture being taken, there's a guy missing from the back row. Fans speculated about it being everything from Jacob to a ghost to a simple goof to a deliberate fan mindf*ck.
 
He's Our You:

Sayid goes to one damn dark place. We get a flashback where Ben releases Sayid from his service after he kills the last of Whidmore's people. Sayid is really confused, and lost. This is a guy that has lost everything. I guess the killing gave him a purpose. Without it, he doesn't know what do. Damn, that's messed up. Sayid meets Illana in a bar, and thinks he's going to get some. He ends up being captured by her instead, and coincidentally (or not) taken on Ajira 316.

On the island, Sayid is still sitting in a cell. He's tortured a lot. He refuses to talk. Sawyer even gives him every chance to very easily get out of the cell, but Sayid won't take it. Damn the man is stubborn. The Dharma folks aren't being too nice about it either. They're ready to execute him. The war between the two sides doesn't seem to be as one-sided as I initially thought. The Dharma people seem to be almost as bad as the Others.

Sayid claims to have found a new purpose on the island. Namely: killing Ben. Sayid wasn't around for Daniel's can't change the future speech, so he has no idea that this probably isn't going to work. Young Ben keeps bringing Sayid food because he thinks that Sayid is one of the others. Sayid plays into this by saying that Richard sent him, and he was sent to bring Ben. Ben eventually breaks Sayid out of the cell, using a burning van as a distraction, and the two escape. They run into Jin on the way. Sayid knocks him out, takes his gun, and then shoots Ben square in the chest. Damn! I mean, I know Sayid thinks he's doing good in his own twisted mind, but child murder is over the line.

Whatever Happened, Happened:

Little Ben is shot, and the "hostile" has escaped. Things are a bit panicky in Dharmaville. Fingers are starting to get pointed after they realize that Sayid must have had inside help to escape. A set of janitor's keys are found in the lock, narrowing down the suspects. Sawyer moves everyone to one house to keep them out of the fray.

Ben isn't doing so good. Juliet is trying her best, but she's no surgeon. The person they really need is Jack. Unfortunately, Jack is not willing to help. Whatever happened to the Hippocratic Oath? I guess Jack is being a hypocrite. ;) Kate decides to take matters into her own hands, and becomes a blood-donor for Ben. He's stabilized, but still in bad shape. With the best doctor not willing to do anything, there may only be one option: taking him to the Others.

Kate and Sawyer sneak Ben out and find the Others. Richard tells them there may be a way to save Ben, but it would change him. He would lose his innocence, and would forever be one of them. Ah ha! So, by shooting Ben, Sayid actually set into motion the course of events that would make Ben the man he is today. Whatever happened, happened.

There's also a Kate flashback in the episode which shows what she did with Aaron. She gave him to Claire's mother much as I expected. The reason seems to be responsibility dodging. How typically Kate that is. :rolleyes:
 
I thought WHH sucked big time. Kate so badly wants to save Ben but then gets out and talks with Sawyer for half an hour while the kid is in the van dying.
 
I don't really have a lot to say about these last two episodes since it is mostly exposition and advancing the plot along and on those terms they are solid.

I also liked how they gave more context to "Man Behind the Curtain" and it was interesting to see that Kate would seem to have a cosmic bond with Ben--help saving him from Keamey last season, giving blood for his transfusion in this episode and helping take him from the village and to the Others.

Interestingly the one time Jack decides not to try to save people--or in this case someone--he inadvertently set things in motion in my mind for Ben to become the man he is.
 
As pointed out, Jack seems unable to make good decisions.

So Odo, what is your take on the characters now? Things have changed rather quickly, no?
 
If I hadn't already liked Sawyer his tenure with Dharma would have converted me easily enough.

Mmm, Dharma Kool-Aid...
 
Dead is Dead:

Have I ever mentioned that I love Ben Linus? Every episode that has ever focused on him has been solid gold. He elevates every single scene he's in. He's terrifying, he's funny, he's a total bastard, he's unbelievably sympathetic. How the hell does he do it? Emerson's addition to the show has been a boon from the start. He's so awesome that he can somehow, in his fifties, play a twenty-something Ben in flashback, and I don't so much as bat an eyelash.

Let's take for example the scene at the beginning of this episode. Ben awakens from his oaring to Locke sitting over his bed. There's a complex display of emotion going in his face. There's surprise: Holy shit! The man I killed is up and walking around. There's absolute terror: HOLY SHIT! The man I killed is walking around. What is he going to do to me? Then there's him quickly moving to making up a bullshit story in order to save his ass. I knew immediately than Ben had no freaking idea that Locke would be revived on the island, and said that only out of self preservation.

So in this episode, Locke and Ben are paired up again. This is good news for me. I love when these two characters are together. The actors have such chemistry and play very well off each other. I read that O'Quinn and Emerson really clicked while making the show, and are shopping around a new show starring the two of them. I would watch the hell out of that show. I don't even care what the concept is, I would watch it just to see these two on screen together some more. Anyways, back to the show. Ben wants to return to the main island to be judged for breaking the rules and returning to the island. Locke doesn't buy this at all. He knows that Ben's true guilt comes from the death of Alex.

The dynamic duo plans to take one of the outriggers and row back to the island. Caesar is having none of this, though. Unfortunately for him, he had no idea who he was dealing with. Caesar gets a chest full of shotgun, courtesy of Ben, and they take their boat. That took my by surprise. They had built Caesar up to be a major recurring character. I never expected him to be dispatched so quickly and pointlessly.

Once back on the island, our heroes(?) travel to the barracks where Ben has his smoke monster summoning thing. Sun and Frank are still there, having been told by Christian to wait for Locke to arrive. They're understandably skeptical, since Locke was dead, but hey they really can't argue with the man standing right in front of them. We get to see the inside of Ben's secret secret room which is a little underwhelming. It's a pond with a drain inside. Ben does his summoning thing, but no smoke monster appears. Locke decides if the monster won't come to them, they'll have to go to the monster.

They arrive at the temple, and Locke and Ben go down in. Ben ends up falling through the floor, and Locke runs off to find some rope. Soon, Ben comes face to face with Smokey itself. Time to be judged, Ben. He's forced to relive his shame, as we see Alex's death again, and again. Eventually, the monster takes the form of Alex. Ben tries to apologize, but the vision of Alex pins him to the wall and makes him swear to follow John Locke's every word. He agrees, and then the monster vanishes.

Ben has gone on quite the journey. I remember at the beginning of season three, cancer aside, I though Ben pretty infallible. He seemed like he knew everything that was going on. He had a plan, and he was five steps ahead of everyone. All the other people on the island were just pawns in his little game. He was a true villain. What is he now? He's a broken man. He's scarred, and he's scared. The world that he had has collapses around him, and he has no idea what to do anymore. All he can hope to do is follow, and hope that he can find some purpose or some answers. It's quite the character arc.

I haven't gotten to mentioning the flashbacks yet. We see a couple of events that had been hinted at but not shown: Ben kidnapping Alex, and Whidmore's exile. The first plays out pretty much how I had imagined. Whidmore's exile I found a tad underwhelming. I had imagined he was exiled through donkey wheel turning, like Ben. The truth is that Ben simply kicked him off. At least the last bit is great. We see what Ben was up to when he decided to keep his promise to Whidmore. Alas, Ben can't bring himself to kill Penny once he sees that she has a child. The monster has a heart, after all. That doesn't save Ben from Desmond handing him a really epic ass kicking, though. That was a jump up and cheer moment. Once again, Ben totally freaking deserved it. So, how many time has been had his ass kicked on this show, now? It has to be more than all of the other characters combined. By this point, it's just kind of expected that Ben will get his ass kicked every few episodes or so.
 
It is crazy how LOST could put out so many great episodes in a single season let alone in the first 12 episodes. This for me goes down as a classic 4 star piece.

Like other Ben-centered episodes, this one is not only a key mythology episode in the Lost Puzzle but a solid episode on its own.

Lots to love about this--we learn why Ben came back to the island, Ben was surprised to see the survivors being Dharma folks, how the writers used the cliffhanger with Ben waking up to a live Locke sitting by his bedside, we got a tease of the Temple with the outer wall and the underground ruins, the Sun/Locke/Ben pairing, we got some gaps filled in on Ben's life from 77 to 92, saw that Ben was the one who took baby Alex, Ilana finally becomes an interesting character when she seems to be a part of an armed team who is up to something nefarious--could she be an agent of Widmore or a new third party like Dharma and could this be the first steps toward Widmore's War referenced in 5.7?

Who or what was Alex and what was it all about? Where did Locke sneak off to at the village? Ben seemed genuinely unnerved by the fact that John was alive but he is an expert liar so who knows if he is telling Sun the truth--afterall we have seemingly seen the dead up and about on the island? If Ben is telling the truth then why is John so important that the island would resurrect him? Is that why John is acting a little weird with a newfound sense of purpose? How did Ben summon the smoke monster by draining the water? The glyph we see briefly was intriguing.

I didn't particularly care for the way Widmore's exile came about--he had a life off-islandand had Penny with an outsider. I thought Ben tricked him into turning the wheel or something.

Just an exciting installment.
 
Ben is by far my favourite character as well. Emerson is one of the best actors alive today.
 
Ben is by far my favourite character as well. Emerson is one of the best actors alive today.

When O'Quinn and Emerson share a scene it's amazing no matter what. They could be reciting lines from the worst play ever written and it'd be riveting.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top