• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

The Twilight Zone — Episode-by-Episode Review Thread

Michael

A good bad influence
Moderator
I loved The Twilight Zone from the first episode I ever saw many years ago. It ranks among my all-time favorite television shows. Besides Star Trek there's virtually no other series that has influenced me in such a profound way. From the way I perceive drama in movies, television shows or books to the way I create my own artwork — all of it is coloured by this black and white show from the early sixties.

But even though I love this show so much, I must admit that I were never able to catch all of its episodes. It was years ago when it ran late in the night on small local channel here in Germany. Since then I watched some more episode here and there online. But I estimate I only saw half of the series.

Today I decided to finally watch the whole series once and for all. And while I'm at it I will try to write a small review for every episode which I will post here. I'm not particularly good at writing these kind of things. Hell, I'm not even sure if I will ever complete this project. I'm not as funny as TheGodBen or as insightful as MEG, but I write this in the hopes of other posters making comments and joining in on reminiscing about one of the best things ever produced for television.

So, let's get started ...




"Where Is Everybody?"

Synopsis: A man who looks, talks and dresses just like Trip Tucker finds himself on the set of Back To The Future, which is stripped of every human being. As he soon figures out, his mind is also stripped of every recollection of who or where exactly he is.

Review: A good actor makes or brakes an episode like this; an episode where the attention of the viewer has to be maintained by a single performance. Fortunately, Earl Holliman is such an actor and Rod Serling's fine script succeeds in making him a likeable character which the audience can easily realte to. That this is done in so little time is very impressive.

But it's also important for the success of such an episode to find ways for the character to express his thoughts to the audience. Where Serling could have made his work a little easier and use internal monolog, he decided otherwise and always tries to find excuses for his protagonist to have a soliloquy. Personally, I think this only works to some degree. In some scences it comes across as natural (when he talks to a recorded message in a phone booth or a mannequin, for examble), other times ... well, not so much. I was especially startled by a scene where he keeps talking to a barkeeper who he already found out isn't there.

As the first episode for The Twilight Zone "Where Is Everybody?" works beautifully. Even though it doesn't involve as much science-fiction elements as later episodes, it has a nice and sound message about lonliness and man's need for companionship at its heart. I just wish Rod Serling had incorporated the second twist he later wrote for a short story adaptation of the episode, where in the end Holliman's character finds a movie ticket in his pocket.

25hzpqt.png
25hzpqt.png
25hzpqt.png
25hzpqt.png
mlryuc.png
 
Good ep. Holliman always had sort of an everyman quality to him that works well here.
I believe this ep was made before the series had been bought; Serling used it as part of his pitch.
 
Not one of my favorites, but still a good start. Can we grade them here? If so, I'd give this one a B.
 
Another fan of The Twilight Zone here who still hasn't seen them all.

I watched this one yesterday for the first time and thought it was a very strong start to the series. I'd give it 4 stars too.

I'll be following this thread with great interest, bring on the next review!
 
I remember reading in "The Twilight Zone Companion" that the network was all "WTF?" It's all in his mind but he has a ticket stub? They were having a hard time dealing with the concepts.

And Charles Beaumont was probably one of the most creative writers for tv that ever existed. Not sure if he wrote this episode, but he wrote quite a few of the best ones.
 
I just wish Rod Serling had incorporated the second twist he later wrote for a short story adaptation of the episode, where in the end Holliman's character finds a movie ticket in his pocket.
Actually that twist was in the original pilot, it was even filmed. It's a special feature on the definitive edition set.
 
Great episode. I think they're all great though (pretty much).

I loved watching them on TBS (or whatever channel they were on) when I was a kid. My mom always loved them and it rubbed off on me. I'm a housewife and I LOVE when SyFy has Twilight Zone as the marathon that day...not much housework gets done but what can ya do? :lol:

I know you're gonna review them but one of my faves is Burgess Meredith as The Obsolete Man. Awesome episode. :bolian:
 
Can we grade them here?
Oh yeah, of course! :)

Will you be grading "The Time Element" if you have a chance to see it?
Actually I did see it some time ago. But somehow I forgot to review it for this thread. I should definitely catch up on it.

So, you're going to review all 156 episodes? :eek:
Well, I will at least try to do so. Finishing the first season would be cool, too, for a start. :D

Actually that twist was in the original pilot, it was even filmed. It's a special feature on the definitive edition set.
Really? I didn't know that. I really think it would have made for a stronger, more poignant ending.

I know you're gonna review them but one of my faves is Burgess Meredith as The Obsolete Man. Awesome episode. :bolian:
I'm looking forward to it. Another episode I have yet to see.

Another fan of The Twilight Zone here who still hasn't seen them all.
Boy, I'm glad I'm not the only one.

I'll be following this thread with great interest, bring on the next review!
Okay, here we go ...



"One for the Angels" (1x02)

Synopsis: Amiable pitchman Lew Bookman, whose greatest pleasure in life is to give candy and toys to children in his neighborhood, is visited by Mr. Death himself. He informs him that he has to die at midnight.

Review: When you've got only 25 minutes to tell your story, you better find a way to get your main protagonist's motivations across in a short time and simultaneously make him a sympathetic character. In "One for the Angels" this is done in a variety of ways: while Serling's opening monologue already gives away the most important information about Bookman, the rather stereotypic casting of comedian Ed Wynn does the rest to immediately introduce us to the protagonist. I really liked both leads, but especially Ed Wynn was a pleasure to watch.

One of the most effective scenes visually was the introduction of Mr. Death: at first he's only standing silently in the background making notes in his book; but when the camera is closing in (and Serling brings an end to his monologue) he suddenly breaks the proverbial fourth wall and is looking right into the camera. I can't imagine a better way to introduce the otherworldly nature of the character. (It's also in this first scene that you can spot a Robby the Robot toy, by the way.)

I've been listening a lot to this wonderful Twilight Zone soundtrack collection for the last couple of weeks, so I was delighted to recognize some of Bernard Herrmann's cues in this episode. Especially the scene in Lew Bookman's apartment deploys his music effectively.

I really don't think it's fair to judge every episode on its twist ending, but I can't do without mentioning the rather poor ending of this episode. The montage of Bookman keeping Death away from taking the girl comes across as nothing but contrived. Even within the story's own logic the scene doesn't make a whole lot of sense, especially when you consider Death's behaviour from the beginning of the episode. I see what they were going for, but I didn't buy it. (It's also worth noting that I found it very strange that the girl wasn't brought to the hospital when she was hit by the car, but kept at home.) But I guess the end does make a little more sense when you look at Death's behaviour as a trick to finally bring Bookman to let go of life and come with him.

25hzpqt.png
25hzpqt.png
mlryuc.png
mlryuc.png
mlryuc.png
 
I remember reading (again, from "The Twilight Zone Companion"--but it's been years--I love that book) that the casting of Ed Wynn was considered a mistake because of how he spoke. This guy was supposed to be a salesman and it was thought that Ed Wynn's slower speech was just not a good fit. Now, his son (Keenan Wynn) could probably have pulled it off--he was usually a bit bombastic--but then he might't've fit with the rest of the character.
 
I remember reading in "The Twilight Zone Companion" that the network was all "WTF?" It's all in his mind but he has a ticket stub? They were having a hard time dealing with the concepts.

And Charles Beaumont was probably one of the most creative writers for tv that ever existed. Not sure if he wrote this episode, but he wrote quite a few of the best ones.


Agreed. And let's not forget Richard Matheson, who also wrote many of the classic episodes: "Nightmare at 20,000 Feet," "Little Girl Lost," "Steel," etc.
 
But I guess the end does make a little more sense when you look at Death's behaviour as a trick to finally bring Bookman to let go of life and come with him.
I like to think of it more as Death having some empathy for the old man and allowing him to succeed in his dream of the big pitch. Not a trick as much as a generous concession.
 
I'd be a little more generous and give this one 3 stars.

Agree with you about the effectiveness of Bernard Herrmann's score during the scene in Bookman's apartment. I love the part when Death touches the flower and it dies, a simple shot but made very effective by the score (as well as Ed Wynn's reaction to it of course).
 
I like to think of it more as Death having some empathy for the old man and allowing him to succeed in his dream of the big pitch. Not a trick as much as a generous concession.
Yeah, I guess that is a valid way to look at it. It also makes Death a much more sympathetic character; however weird that sounds. :lol:


"Mr. Denton on Doomsday" (1x03)

Synopsis: Former gunslinger Al Denton, now the local town drunk, gets a chance to get a handle on his life again, when he is visited by a curious salesman named Henry J. Fate (wink, wink).

Review: One of the most fascinating aspects of an anthology show like The Twilight Zone is the possibility to again and again get to know a new universe with every episode. In the course of merely 25 short minutes we meet a whole set of characters and learn of their backgrounds. And it's because of this, that the viewer always gets to witness the most important, most crucial moments in the life of the protagonists. While a regular series always has to retain the status quo, you never know how a Twilight Zone episode will end.

The format also allowes the writers to change the rules of the universe with every episode. In "Mr. Denton on Doomsday", for example, an abstract term like destiny is personified in the form of a salesman who sells magic potions. And next week it's something completely different. I love that!

I'm not getting tired of mentioning how fantastic the music on this show is! Even though the score for this one is stock music (I'm not sure if it was from another production altogether or just from another episode), it works beautifully in the introductory scene at the beginning. Just brilliant, sad music.

What I think ulatimately hurts the episode, though, is the fact that Al Denton (believably portrayed by Dan Duryea) doesn't really get to make his own decision. I would have favoured an ending, where on his own free will he decides to reject the duel and start a new life, rather than be manipulated by the salesman. What's the message? That you actually can't make your own decisions? I think that's a rather questionable note to end your episode on.

Wort mentioning is my astonishment when I recognized a young Martin Landau in an unusually vicious supporting role! Oh, and does anyone know the name of the guy playing the barkeeper? I know him from somewhere, but can't put my finger on it.

25hzpqt.png
25hzpqt.png
25hzpqt.png
mlryuc.png
mlryuc.png
 
Not sure about the barkeep, but Bill Irwin (credited as "Man") played Doctor Dalen Quaice in the TNG episode Remember Me.
 
Ah... his name was Charlie. I should have looked at pictures for the entire cast. Cool find. Almost everyone has either been in the Twilight Zone or Star Trek if they acted in the 60s.
 
There was a lot of studio/producer loyalty. You'll see a lot of the same people working for the same production companies. Desilu had a key role in getting Twilight Zone on tv.

[yt]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BxAYn286vtA[/yt]
 
Last edited:
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top