There must be something weird about me, because I really like all of these episodes. Some of them — like Cogenitor, Past Tense, It's Only A Paper Moon, His Way or The Way to Eden — are actually among my favorite episodes of the whole franchise.
Opinions differ. There are better ways to disagree than tellling someone that they're trying to be a dick. Infraction for Flaming. Any relevant comments may be directed to PM.It is and I did give a serious answer to the OP's question. Our planet revolves around the sun, not DS9... nor Niners opinions.
I thought the thread was for serious answers.
"There is more of heaven and earth than are dreamed of in your philosophy." -Shakespeare
You do realize that your opinion, if this is indeed your opinion, is so ridiculous that nobody in their right mind who knows anything about the subject can take you seriously? Being a "Niner" or not a "Niner" doesn't figure in it at all. I may think that VOY is the weakest Trek show, and that DS9 is the best, but I'd never write something as preposterous as that every DS9 episode - including If Wishes Were Horses, Meridian and Profit and Lace - is better than Meld or Living Witness and almost all of the other Trek. If you really don't understand that you're just making yourself look silly when you're claiming that every TOS episode including Mudd's Women, The Alternative Factor, Spock's Brain, Catspaw, The Way to Eden or The Cloud Minders is better than Duet, In the Pale Moonlight, Necessary Evil, The Visitor, Call to Arms, Sacrifice of Angels or Treachery, Faith and the Great River, well... I have no words.
But I doubt you really think so, I think you're just trying to 'make a statement' (read: to be a dick).
It is ALL personal opinion. IDIC and such, I may hate what the other guy loves. That is what makes a thread like this FUN.There must be something weird about me, because I really like all of these episodes. Some of them — like Cogenitor, Past Tense, It's Only A Paper Moon, His Way or The Way to Eden — are actually among my favorite episodes of the whole franchise.
I do, however, consider The Omega Glory and Code of Honor to be really, really bad. So I can't be completely out of my mind, right? Right?!
I think what makes an episode forgettable (or at least I try) is when a character is written totally unlike what is established. For instance a usually smart person gets an episode where they act dumb.Oh yeah, I forgot about "Meridian". I just try to block it out of my mind. Even as one of the most unabashed Jadzia fanboys here, I can't find anything to like about it. She comes across as such a moron in that episode.
What?! I've heard some pretty crazy things before but I think this takes the cake...
Really? How much longer until you guys take up the mantle as The Thought Police? Honestly, if you read some of the posts that come from that camp it is apparent that their only real goal is to get under peoples skin not contribute to the discussion as a whole (which is all DevilEyes was pointing out.)
I thought Cogenitor was great, and Past Tense, It's Only a Paper Moon and His Way were good episodes. These are ust individual opinions, and I don't think that those episodes are widely hated or anything. The Darkness and the Light, Chrysalis and Nemesis were also very good episodes IMO, and I don't get the hate for Valiant, and I don't remember what was so wrong about Shadowplay, it was all right as far as I remember. The Outcast was not one of the best, but not one of the worst, either. Interface and Aquiel, as far as I can remember them, were average. I remember I liked Emanations, too.
There must be something weird about me, because I really like all of these episodes. Some of them — like Cogenitor, Past Tense, It's Only A Paper Moon, His Way or The Way to Eden — are actually among my favorite episodes of the whole franchise.
I do, however, consider The Omega Glory and Code of Honor to be really, really bad. So I can't be completely out of my mind, right? Right?!
As I've already said, comments may be made to me in PM or you can take it up with the board administration. This thread is not the place to argue about a warning.
Although, I am not a huge fan of Enterprise, I can understand why so many hated TATV. When I watched it, I felt as though it dismissed all those fans who loved the show and had an emotional investment in those characters. "Haha, the joke's on you! They weren't real! It's all a hologram," seems to be the joke played upon those fans.
Wouldn't be the first point I've ever missed.
