• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Kurtzman intentionally killed Legacy?

TNG Season 1 is objectively and mostly mediocre, but it did take wacky swings at the ball, even if it missed a whole lot. TOS was the same.

"Want an episode with a talking rock creature and Abraham Lincoln" would never happen now.
 
The first season is fucking weird, but it's interesting. I'll take that over the increasingly beige writing that took over in the Michael Piller/Jeri Taylor years, which is really only good for specific episodes.

DS9 managed to be weird and interesting across nearly all seven seasons, which is why the series is so eminently rewatchable for me.
 
The first three seasons of TNG, because the show was still finding its way they were more willing to try anything. It didn't always work, in fact for much of the first two it rarely did, but that willingness to try anything gave the show a fresh and innovative feel to it. By the third season, they finally caught their stride, they were truly creative and they found out what was working. Sadly, in the fourth season that willingness to try anything was gone and the show became mired in a formulaic rut it never really broke free of. That said, I will admit, the last two seasons had some legitimately good character work, a probable combination of the writers really getting to know how to handle the characters and the actors being comfortable in the roles. Really, if you could take the ingenuity of the first three seasons, with the eye for quality of the third, with the character writing and actor performances of the sixth and seventh, TNG could have been a masterpiece.
 
Then perhaps I should have said flawless? Whatever else one wants to say about the show, I'm sure we can all agree it had its flaws.

Yeah, I know, I just opened the floodgates for "everything has flaws."

It has flaws and holes that one could fly the Enterprise-J through. That is part of the charm. If it was all flawless, there wouldn't be much to talk about.
 
Really, if you could take the ingenuity of the first three seasons, with the eye for quality of the third, with the character writing and actor performances of the sixth and seventh, TNG could have been a masterpiece.
A fun writing exercise would be taking the scripts of season one and giving them rewrite with the characters handled with the confidence of that sixth season staff.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top