Early Criticism: What’s Unfounded and What Isn’t
- Thread starter trekfan_1
- Start date
They'll be blocked the next time I see them on my feed.
I'm surprised this is considered surprising honestly.
You either die a hero or live long enough to see yourself become the villain
Well you answered the question yourself, in the bolded section. If you go look at all the ratings you will see a decline in the ratings, only difference I think is season 3 of picard. Season 5 of disco, and season 3 of SNW have a decent decline.
I think this is just continuing the trend, but it might be absorbing the the same decline that disco was getting.
If people stop watching it will happen faster.
DS9's ratings sank further down almost every week it was on the air. Of all the Trek shows, only TNG's ratings climbed after its first year.
It's also a streaming show so it's bizarre to use the old ranking system.
? Not using an old ranking system for the streaming shows.
@Michael Sorry for the double post, but it was not letting me put a new edit another post in.
If we want to talk about viewership, I have been using the website @Starflight posted to keep track of the WW numbers over the weekend.
Those same skirts also disappeared rather fast.Not at all. I'm just playing devils advocate here........no one had much of an issue with the Starfleet skirts in TNG. Well maybe some did but I don't remember hearing much complaints. So I'm just wondering if this is the issue some people are having. If all the cadets were wearing the skirts would there even be this 10 page discussion????
I was not talking about viewership, I was replying to why the negativity in the rating system.
If we want to talk about viewership, I have been using the website @Starflight posted to keep track of the WW numbers over the weekend.
That's a Kilt, not a skirt.
This has nothing to do with IDIC. Don't even try going there with me. You are taking this WAY too personally for someone that recently said "It's just a fictional show."
Last edited:
Tell me you didn't watch the video without saying you didn't watch the video.
Tell me why you think I didn't watch the video, please.
Because you said this,,,,
What part of that video was hating? He was pointing out, with detail, criticisms that fans have of the show. There was no "hating" as you put it. So you either didn't watch it, or have a very warped interpretation of hating.
As I've pointed out already in this thread, you guys can't handle constructive criticism. Your reaction to this video is a perfect example of that.
Last edited:
The main difference between a kilt and a skirt comes in its cultural and historical significance, not its structure. Tradition makes it more socially acceptable for males to wear one if they choose to, and James Bond chose to.
In Starfleet culture it's socially acceptable for males to wear skirts and Jay-Den chose to.
Calling the kind of kvetching going on here "constructive" is torturing the language.
Except he didnt - and he certainly wasn't being constructive. He can't even be bothered to pronounce a character name correctly.
And youve now edited your post
Again I ask...where was the hating? It shouldn't be hard to provide details since you watched it right?Except he didnt - and he certainly wasn't being constructive. He can't even be bothered to pronounce a character name correctly.
And youve now edited your post
Last edited:
Similar threads
- Poll
