Well aware of what? I haven't even given my review. What are you referring to?
Spoilers Starfleet Academy General Discussion Thread
- Thread starter Tuskin38
- Start date
Well aware of what? I haven't even given my review. What are you referring to?
So the Burn justifies the Federations justice system becoming worse then the Klingon Empires?
Sorry, but I'm going to have to disagree on that. Because disasters like that are supposed to be when morals are put to the test, not discarded wholesale.
So nothing. Talk about ignorance. Smh
Not to state the obvious, but have you been paying attention at all as to how things are being done by the current US Presidential Administration.
Seems to me that there is a perfect example of how wrong you are with that post.
How was it shown as being worse in any way?
We’ve been talking about it behind the scenes and would like to ask you to reduce your use of the "Sure, Jan" meme to a minimum. It reads like a mean-spirited, thinly veiled personal attack, ridiculing those who are saying something negative about the show. Disagree with each other, but don’t attack other posters. Thanks.Sure, Jan.
They want to set up an arc where we see the Federation "lost its way" for awhile, in order to have it built back up again into something stronger than before. It's a much more mature arc than what Discovery intimated, where everything other than the scope of the Federation was back to normal by the start of Season 4.
Even in Berman Trek, there were plenty of stories which showed that the Federation was often imperfect at reaching its ideals. It was never utopian, just stretching towards it a bit better than we do.
Yes, I have. But you really don't want to have that discussion here.
The Klingon government at least gave you a trial with the right to a defense lawyer before sending you away to a penal colony for life.
All we saw here was the sentencing really, we dont know how much of a Trial there was beforehand. Ake even says she could have pulled a fast-one and allowed the Mir's to stay together.
There's a difference between "even utopia has it's shadows" and "we're the bag guys".
Paper or plastic?
Where was it said they didn’t get a trial?
All we saw was the sentencing, and they’d clearly been there for a bit because Ake and Caleb’s mom had talked before that.
I'll go ahead and say I consider myself a fan of SFA. I liked Discovery and Prodigy, and this series feels like both, so it makes sense that I'd be a fan of this.
So far, I'm liking it better than DIS and PIC. Both shows suffered from not knowing what they were, where I think this show has a very good idea of that.
Yeah, the show is TV-14, but it's only due to language. Otherwise, it's pretty family-friendly.
The final test will be the fifth episode. That's the thing I wanted to see how they handle. Still is. If they do it well... then this is what I'll say: I still think the show will only run two seasons, because I really think we're in the late stage of this production era, but it'll be a great two seasons to watch.
Similar threads
