• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

The unnecessary reboot/remake of the week thread

The Michael Mann version was fine. We don't really need another one and even if they did one I feel like this would be best used as a comedy movie were you set it in the 80's. Have it star Paul Rudd and Craig Robinson.
 
The new version of Prison Break has been greenlit. Hopefully it’s as entertaining as the first two seasons of the original but that they know this time that’s the time to quit:
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
Those two guys don't look happy about it. ;)
 
A new adaptation of A Christmas Carol with Johnny Depp as Scrooge.


So a creepy version of Ebeneizer Scrooge? I'm not sure how sure how that work work. And to be honest, I don't see him as an old miser. I find it difficult to picture Depp as one given how most of his movies have been milking franchises dry. Speaking of which, I'm surprised we don't have a DCU (Depp Connected Universe) thing going on.
 
So a creepy version of Ebeneizer Scrooge? I'm not sure how sure how that work work. And to be honest, I don't see him as an old miser. I find it difficult to picture Depp as one given how most of his movies have been milking franchises dry. Speaking of which, I'm surprised we don't have a DCU (Depp Connected Universe) thing going on.

It could work. Their are creepy aspects to the story, what with it having ghosts and whatnot. Plus it seems to have some talent behind it in Ti West and and he writers worked on Legion, Tales from the Loop and Oblivion.
 
It could work. Their are creepy aspects to the story, what with it having ghosts and whatnot. Plus it seems to have some talent behind it in Ti West and and he writers worked on Legion, Tales from the Loop and Oblivion.

Creepy aspects, sure, in terms of the ghosts which have always been generally more on the campy side of things, but the character of Scrooge himself was always seen as a hardened man skimping on his co-worker's pay. But Depp has IMHO has always tended to go for creepier takes on roles especially if paired with Tim Burton. I just can't picture him as Scrooge.
 
Creepy aspects, sure, in terms of the ghosts which have always been generally more on the campy side of things, but the character of Scrooge himself was always seen as a hardened man skimping on his co-worker's pay. But Depp has IMHO has always tended to go for creepier takes on roles especially if paired with Tim Burton. I just can't picture him as Scrooge.

Behind the creepy aspects though has often been some heart. Edward Scissorhands was a kind soul that his version of Ed Wood was a man of passion and kindness for people who were rejected by society. I could see them taking the approach of making him someone who experiences the ghost before he becomes the cranky old man but a younger version on the verge of becoming him.

Instead of showing him dead as his vision of the future it might be of himself as the old man version we are familiar with. Alone at Christmas. Nobody in his life that cares about him except Tiny Tim and he ends up being mean to him. I just realized also I am thinking sort of along the lines of what Doctor Who did when a good portion of the story was focused on young Scrooge. Well their version of Scrooge.

Scrooge decides to become a better man before he ever fully becomes the bad older man.
 
Behind the creepy aspects though has often been some heart. Edward Scissorhands was a kind soul that his version of Ed Wood was a man of passion and kindness for people who were rejected by society.

Fair enough. I suppose it comes down more to personal preference. But personally, even his older movies such as Edward Scissorhands have become harder to watch for me the older I grow.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top