• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Star Trek: Lower Decks 4x03 - "In the Cradle of Vexilon"

Rate the episode...


  • Total voters
    92
Honestly, I'm not sure "does it make sense" is a useful metric when talking about a Lynch work. A lot of his stuff is essentially arational, as opposed to irrational. There's a logic there, but it's a .... dream logic?
 
FWIW, I'm a Twin Peaks fan, and I totally didn't see the reference until I read it here. I thought it was just more koala wackiness. I tend to compartmentalize a bit, so outside references sometimes go right over my head.

But I did appreciate the Paramount mountain in the background. Will Boimler someday realize that he's a fictional character?

(Everyone here has read Redshirts, right?)
 
Plus "Fire Walk With Me", which was its own kind of mess. There are also 90 minutes of deleted scenes from that movie in the collectors box.

I think this is a film that's been somewhat reappraised in recent years. Certainly I wasn't a fan but I've only seen it once and that was in the 20th Century. Certainly I know a lot of horror/Lynch aficionados who initially were cool on it yet rave about it now.
 
I first saw Twin Peaks for real a few years ago. Back when it was first on, I tried to watch the finale (I was 13 or so?) and had no idea what was happening.

I remembered the The Simpsons clip and there's an episode of Darkwing Duck called "Twin Beaks" which is full of weirdness, like a talking log, which is also something that references something in the show.

Anyway, when it was revealed who BOB was, I did think of Redjac from "Wolf in the Fold".
 
View attachment 36427


What the **** is Nomad doing in the Anomaly Storage Room??!!!:guffaw:

I'm pretty sure that eye visor wouldn't have shielded the wearer from Medusan-induced madness.

How did the Cerritos end up with all this stuff? Good fanfic potential there.
If this show is supposed to be cannon, and excepted as existing in the same universe as other Star trek shows, then how can the Nomad probe possibly be sitting in that room when it exploded roughly 200 years earlier? !!!
 
If this show is supposed to be cannon, and excepted as existing in the same universe as other Star trek shows, then how can the Nomad probe possibly be sitting in that room when it exploded roughly 200 years earlier? !!!
If there is a collectible replica anywhere in the universe it would be on the Cerritos.

An a more serious note (well... MORE serious) Nomad came out of nowhere, nearly destroyed a Federation Starship easily, and was able to bring people back from the dead. Of COURSE some lunatic would try to build another one.
 
If this show is supposed to be cannon, and excepted as existing in the same universe as other Star trek shows, then how can the Nomad probe possibly be sitting in that room when it exploded roughly 200 years earlier? !!!
It exists as an elevated retelling of in universe events.

Also, Boimler loves collectibles.
 
(Everyone here has read Redshirts, right?)

I DNF'ed it about 2/3 of the way through.

Eventually, the "real world" story became as or more contrived than the supposed "bad" science fiction of the early chapters, and my patience was shot. Supposedly the last few chapters are just Scalzi breaking the fourth wall to lecture on what he thinks makes for good or bad sci-fi, and no thank you.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top