• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Star Trek: Strange New Worlds 2x06 - "Lost in Translation"

Hit it!


  • Total voters
    179
To me, that's distinction without a difference. We all encounters character different ways in different media, but by now we should all understand that they're going to keep being portrayed differently over the course of time, and depending on the production.

And even with characters who originated in prose, I suspect most modern audiences first encounter them on screen before delving into the books, but that doesn't mean they have to imprint on the very first actor they ever see play the character.

I mean, I would be lying if I claimed that I first encountered Dracula, Tarzan, Bond, or Sherlock Homes by reading the original books. I first saw Bela Lugosi as Dracula long before I read Bram Stoker's novel in sixth grade. But that doesn't mean that I expect every subsequent Dracula to copy Lugosi. "That's not Dracula!"

Same with Kirk. I grew up on TOS reruns, but I don't expect Kirk to always be like William Shatner anymore than I expect Batman to always mimic Adam West.

No actor owns a role forever. That's how acting works.
Me no like monosyllabic movie Tarzan. I like multilingual literary Tarzan.;)
 
10 out of 10.

It astonishes me how these people fucking nail exactly what Star Trek once was and "ought" to be, week after week, from so many different angles with so many kinds of stories.

Yeah, it would have been nice if the title of the episode didn't give the game away right up front. Alas...:D
 
As for our check-in with everyone's favorite couple this week, how long do you suppose it will be before Christine tells Spock something like, "Y'know, we have to just accept that having what you thought you wanted isn't everything you hoped it would be when you wanted it?"

I mean, he learned that somewhere. ;)
 
Yeah..they've said some things will be tweaked, some things will be left intact or just modified a bit.

Kirk will still have fought a Gorn on Cestus 3, just now he'll have had a little prior experience with them..but the events of "Arena" will still have taken place
 
As for our check-in with everyone's favorite couple this week, how long do you suppose it will be before Christine tells Spock something like, "Y'know, we have to just accept that having what you thought you wanted isn't everything you hoped it would be when you wanted it?"

I mean, he learned that somewhere. ;)
I believe the line goes:
"After a time, you may find that having is not so pleasing a thing after all as wanting. It is not logical, but it is often true."
:vulcan:;)
 
View attachment 35470

Ships!!!


Am I missing something, or could this station just not be towed out of the nebula? Seems wasteful to pew-pew it.

Lucky thing these aliens didn't take a shine to the Mutara Nebula.
I FULLY Concur, such a waste of resources.

Not every nebula is going to have Life-forms living in the Deuterium.

Just tow the Deuterium Collection array to another Stellar Nursery.

That seems SO wasteful and a unnecessary strike against Captain Pike.

Yes, stopping the Deuterium Collection that hurts the Deutrium Aliens is all fine and stuff.

But blowing up the array when it can be towed to another system?

-__-

I'm just glad it was routine and "normal" and not filled with bar fights, chokeholds on the bridge, and absurd jokes about finding out someone's first name as was portrayed in the Kelvin universe.
There's plenty of time in the future for all sorts of "Shenanigans".
 
I FULLY Concur, such a waste of resources.

Not every nebula is going to have Life-forms living in the Deuterium.

Just tow the Deuterium Collection array to another Stellar Nursery.

That seems SO wasteful and a unnecessary strike against Captain Pike.

Yes, stopping the Deuterium Collection that hurts the Deutrium Aliens is all fine and stuff.

But blowing up the array when it can be towed to another system?

-__-


There's plenty of time in the future for all sorts of "Shenanigans".
That didn’t make sense to me, either, unless it was so far away to move the thing that it was totally impractical, in which case a line to that effect would have been good. I figured the writers just couldn’t resist blowing something up.
 
I FULLY Concur, such a waste of resources.

Not every nebula is going to have Life-forms living in the Deuterium.

Just tow the Deuterium Collection array to another Stellar Nursery.

That seems SO wasteful and a unnecessary strike against Captain Pike.

Yes, stopping the Deuterium Collection that hurts the Deutrium Aliens is all fine and stuff.

But blowing up the array when it can be towed to another system?

-__-


There's plenty of time in the future for all sorts of "Shenanigans".
1. Heat of the moment. Those lifeforms were being tortured as they stood there.
2. The array wouldn't shut off, and so more drastic action had to be taken.
 
Same with Kirk. I grew up on TOS reruns, but I don't expect Kirk to always be like William Shatner any more than I expect Batman to always mimic Adam West.
Exactly. If that were the case, I would have given up on Batman movies several actors ago.

Strangely, I do enjoy different actors as Batman. And before people say "Well, those are also different universes" Keaton, Kilmer and Clooney are all the same Batman character.
1. Heat of the moment. Those lifeforms were being tortured as they stood there.
2. The array wouldn't shut off, and so more drastic action had to be taken.
Yeah, this didn't strike me as any more extreme than destroying other devices to preserve life.
 
That didn’t make sense to me, either, unless it was so far away to move the thing that it was totally impractical, in which case a line to that effect would have been good. I figured the writers just couldn’t resist blowing something up.
They literally have "Warp Tugs".

When the USS Enterprise was hobbled & needed Warp Tugs to drag it's hull back to space dock for repairs, it took several Warp Tugs.

That was when Pike transfered over to be temproary Captain of the USS Discovery.

The same can be done with a larger Deuterium Refining station.

I'm all fine with blowing something up when it makes sense to do so.

This was just excessive and wasteful of resources.
 
I voted a six. The episode was good, I liked almost every aspect of it and the stuff with Uhura I'm just not sold on this Kirk. It's not fitting for me and, really, there's no need for him to be here. That's really my only "complaint" or issue with the episode. That's not Kirk. Otherwise I probably would have given the episode an 8.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top