• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Star Trek: Strange New Worlds 2x04 - "Among the Lotus Eaters"

Hit it!


  • Total voters
    198
I'm not buying Pike and Batel's relationship. Pike feels like he can share his delta radiation vision with Una and heck, even Alora, the overseer of the kid torturing planet Majalis (and if Pike is really so in love with Batel, why was he bedding Alora in that episode anyway?)

Yet Pike obviously isn't in a place where he feels he can share this with Batel (unless he somehow has offscreen). If you feel you can share personal information with just about everyone other than your supposed girlfriend, maybe you should start asking yourself why you can't share this info with your supposed girlfriend and whether said woman should be in the position of girlfriend.

Plus, the concept of Pike's supposed love for Batel leading him back to his memories feels very harsh when we now know that Batel's nowhere around in Menagerie and not mentioned, and she's not there to follow Pike to Talos 4, etc. Unless Batel is outright killed off, sounds like this relationship will end badly.
You have some absolutely bizarre ideas about sex and relationships
 
A very middle of the episode and SNW continues it's muddy 2nd season run.

Poor
Great
Good
Average

Not quite the start I had hoped after 4 episodes. Season 1 was so much better.
 
You have some absolutely bizarre ideas about sex and relationships
Ok what? Your comment is totally uncalled for. I said nothing profane, immoral, unethical, or illegal in my post. We are discussing fictional charcters, yet you go straight to a personal attack against me, a real person.
 
Last edited:
I enjoyed it. ive had mixed feelings about the AR wall because it often calls attention to itself and isn’t exactly seamless; I can always see where the studio floor ends and the wall begins. But it really looked great here, conjuring the icy wilderness.

The plot was fine for what it was. SNW continues to reboot Trek’s greatest hits to a new audience; we’ve had our Trekkian courtroom drama, and our time travel to contemporary earth attempting to restore the timeline (and meeting a fellow crew officer who happens to live in that time period on Earth and looks identical to their later self). Now we’ve had the “Starfleet officer goes renegade and takes over a primitive world causing cultural contamination” trope. Very familiar Trek fare. This was quite well excited though with some great performances all round. It also gave Oretegas a little to do without being overtly annoying and smirky. That’s a win.
 
I enjoyed it. ive had mixed feelings about the AR wall because it often calls attention to itself and isn’t exactly seamless; I can always see where the studio floor ends and the wall begins. But it really looked great here, conjuring the icy wilderness.
I forgot about the AR walls. It does seem strange that one matte painting shot of the moon over Rigel from a production literally filmed in 1964 is more memorable than all the AR backdrops in this episode from 2023
 
Well, I liked it. Good but not great. I was in the 6-8 range and gave it an 8. As I have tinnitis anyway, that didn't bother me much.

Good character development for Pike. I did not even remember Rigel VII as part of the Cage.

Why couldn't Spock read his tablet? I guess Una's enhanced immune system was no help here..
 
Over the past few months, I have experienced the loss of my mother to cancer, and I have had to adopt our cats out so they could have a better future than the one I could give them.
I'm very sorry, honey. *HUGS*

A very fun take on the old "cultural contamination" trope. Nice to see Spock wasn't immune for once. Good to see Ortegas saving the ship!

A few people mentioned this was scary and I totally agree. Dementia runs in one side of my family, so losing my memory is a real fear for me.
 
Speaking absolutely seriously, I intend to read Homer one day, it’s long been on my list, but no I’ve never read it.

I’m a fan theoretically, I wouldn’t say I’m not a fan.
It’s quite good. I liked it better than the Iliad (and not because it’s shorter…well, not only ;) ). Both were required reading in my last year of high school. Along with the Roman knockoff, the Aeneid.
 
The idea of examining dementia is laudable but this was the weakest episode in terms of execution. A low 7 from me.
And, honestly, there was no real reason for this planet to be Rigel VII so maybe a waste of that moniker for this story.
 
It’s quite good. I liked it better than the Iliad (and not because it’s shorter…well, not only ;) ). Both were required reading in my last year of high school. Along with the Roman knockoff, the Aeneid.

The Aeneid is another on my long long list.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top