I just want to see unresolved issues explored and I think a lot of others do too, it is more than just "hey I know that thing". It is more "I want to see what they're up to and where they ended up". Give me nostalgia trips over red angel and whatever the fuck caused the burn.
As I mentioned in the Vox thread, what you want is "To Boldly Go Where We Have Been Before". Which is fine, on occasion.
But what so many seem to want is pure nostalgia bait all the time. It's what Terry Matalas has basically promised with every mention of a continuation under him.
You can only milk nostalgia for so long before it becomes tiresome and meaningless. The franchise will become stagnated and eventually flounder out, again.
Paramount only has so much money to throw around, and even that seems to be dwindling. To devote such time, effort, and money towards projects that appeal to no one but Trekkies, is shortsighted, at best.
Star Trek isn't as popular as we'd all like to think. We need NEW fans if the franchise is to thrive. Nostalgia bait does nothing for people who are new or only mildly interested in the franchise.
I think Strange New Worlds has the perfect approach, and not just because of it's non-serialized format. It works for old fans and new fans alike. Yes, there is obvious nostalgia in the setting, ship, and some character, but with virtually every episode they brought something new to the franchise. They visited a new planet. Made a new discovery. Met a new species or greatly expanded on ones we knew little about.
In the end, in my opinion, Star Trek is about about exploring strange new worlds. Seeking out new life and new civilizations. And yes, Boldly going where no one has gone before.