Why does it look like a demotion if you know nothing of what kind of role he could have in the future?
Maybe trying to divine other people's motivations based on the end result is not a good idea.
(Darth Vader voice): The head canon is strong in this one.
Yes, you can.
Calm down. It’s called having a different opinion. There were no caps lock tirades, exclamation points, or insults at other posters in my reply. I gave reasons for my thoughts on the episode. Give yours—or shut it. It’s just a TV show.
Maybe in your mind.
I'm not the one calling a TV script "repugnant" or losing my shit over a story. I know it stings to be told that you're taking fiction too seriously, but it's not as clever as you think to repeat people's words back at them.
You seem to be the emotional one here.
Honestly, what is going on with you? Do you think you're your avatar and trying to defend a show you like? Discuss the points or don't bother me.
"I know you are but what am I?" is probably the least effective argument. Perhaps you can address the reasons I gave you for why such a suit wouldn't happen rather than trying to pick a fight?
I'm just pointing out that you seem way too emotional about a TV show. "Repugnant" is such a strong word for something like this. People take fiction too seriously.
If "calm down" is enough to set you off like that, and if you interpret it as such of an insult, the internet is not for you. Instead I would suggest not taking things so personally. In short: calm down.
Closely related to the Zathras family.
Stern, but fair.
So were Lorca and Georgiou, didn't save them.
What does one have to do with the other? They can only cast disabled actors if their character can't die? That's ridiculous.
You know I heard about this show in the 60's called "Star Trek", and it's basically a rip-off of 'Forbidden Planet'!
You are correct, of course. Lorca, however, I'd consider part of the main cast, at least for season 1. As for Georgiou, if one considers her mirror self, was at least very recurring.
Which is a rip off of the Tempest by some English dude.
The term you're looking for is "Gary Stu", by the way, although it isn't synonymous (nor is Mary Sue) with an overpowered character.
You are literally picking a fight.
Oh? Like I love that I hate that that sucks totally absurd etc etc etc are any different. Reread my initial reply. There is no hysteria beyond that you are reading into this. Calm down.
Again picking a fight. If the internet is the way it is, look in the mirror as to why.
The Chapel/Spock thing is kind of obvious from my perspective. T'Pring looks down on humans. Chapel is a human. Spock is going to be as Vulcan-like as possible to impress T'Pring. Hanging around Chapel means her "human-ness" rubbing off on Spock and thus, from Spock's point of view, lessening his chances with T'Pring. So Spock cuts Chapel off in hopes T'Pring will accept him, leading to the situation in TOS.
I'm just telling you that such a suit is extremely unlikely to succeed. How is that picking a fight?
I didn't say anything about hysteria. I suggested you should take the show less seriously.
Telling you that you're wrong is not picking a fight. Your opinions are not sacrosanct.
You have been insulting and combative from your first and in every reply.
If I'd said Anson Mount raped my childhood, you'd have a point.
I would have gladly discussed every point I made and we could have shared our thoughts in a friendly and perhaps mutually persuasive manner. You know, like what the boards are supposed to be about. Instead we got this back and forth.