• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Star Trek: Strange New Worlds 1x06 - "Lift Us Where Suffering Cannot Reach"

Hit it!


  • Total voters
    199
I probably rated it a bit too high (8). But it was still good. It would have been better if there was any attempt at saying WHY the child was needed. How exactly does the planet go to hell?

Pike even asked that, and it went totally unanswered.
 
Uhura got unlucky, but I don't think she actually made any mistakes, they were attempting to graze the ship and the target changed course towards the beam literally at the last moment. I suppose the question is how much auto targeting is there at this point in the timeline. That is to say, does the computer have the ability to change where the phaser is aimed based on real time scans of the target?

Was it Riker or Worf in TNG's Lower Decks episode telling Sito that she should let the targeting lock 'float' until just before she fired? Sounds like once the ship locked on phasers, they were aimed at a set trajectory. Maybe Uhura locked it, fired, and before she could react, the enemy ship had maneuvered into the beam.

Now my question is: why didn't the Enterprise even attempt to beam off any survivors from the enemy ship before it crashed? Starfleet is usually willing to rescue their enemies once they are rendered defenseless. Answer: because then they would have told Pile about what the kid was going to do, and then we'd have no story.
 
Pike even asked that, and it went totally unanswered.
I thought she answered that the machine was designed only to work with a human neural network, and that's how their ancestors designed it; and they didn't know why that was, nor did they have a functional alternative...?
 
Now I know why Hemmer was NOT seen in this episode. With him being a "genius" he would have came up with a solution for Alora's people.

And I also know why Uhura was assigned to the CONN in an emergency.
 
Last edited:
I thought she answered that the machine was designed only to work with a human neural network, and that's how their ancestors designed it; and they didn't know why that was, nor did they have a functional alternative...?

True, but she never explained why the machine was necessary to begin with.
 
True, but she never explained why the machine was necessary to begin with.
The Majalans want their super healing powers that can cure delta radiation and everything else and aren't willing to let that go and evacuate the planet over the wellbeing of 1 kid. Obviously no one told them about Khan's blood.
 
True, but she never explained why the machine was necessary to begin with.
She also said earlier that the surface of the planet was mostly molten lava and the device kept their city/cities floating above it and without it, they would all fall into said lava.
 
So there's a pulsar nearby, per the Captain's log entry at the top of the episode.

How many pulsars do we currently know of within the 750 lightyear radius?
 
There's a moment where it seemed like maybe a scene was cut for time where Number One says to Spock "Are you telling me that I have no way to contact the captain when I need to?" I thought for a second we were going to get an example of why she's considered terrifying by the crew. Spock's expression was intensely apprehensive. Like, "oh shit." I would have liked to see everyone suddenly scrambling to find a way.

When Pike opens his communicator and says "Now, number one," they'd obviously figured it out but the implication was that she'd been waiting and he'd just regained consciousness so...

Anyway, a little more character business on the bridge of people jumping however high Una told them too would have been satisfying.
 
Just finished watching it. Ridiculous.

Are we expected to believe this alien lady would not have messed up Pike's irresistible, gravity-defying quiff during intimacy?

Post-coitus chat, not *one* hair was out of place.

Aside from that, good episode. I think this format demands more episodes per season though. Surely there'd be little objection to scuttling the other ones and plugging their budgets into SNW to give us a solid 26?

It maybe THE dealbreaker for him :p

Agreed on the 26-ep business. 10 episodes is seriously problematic. We need at least 15.
 
Aside from that, good episode. I think this format demands more episodes per season though. Surely there'd be little objection to scuttling the other ones and plugging their budgets into SNW to give us a solid 26?
Probably objections from the actors, since 26 episodes is a grueling schedule.
 
Hmm. You'd think after all these generations they could have 'scienced' up another solution.
They don't seem to truly understand their science. The little boy does, but that's because he's about to become the understander for all of them. The computer system seems to need that neural input, they don't know why. It powers everything, they don't know how, and it wants a humanoid child's neural network to do it with, they seem too afraid to find out what happens otherwise. It's all indicative of a system that wants the benefit of the sausage, without having to know the details of how the sausage is made.
 
It's kind of funny. For all the rap Kirk gets about 'banging those green alien chicks', does anyone have a definitive list? He hugged a few yeomen in moments of duress, met a couple of old flames along the way, but Elaan of Troyius is the only one I can actually recall off the top of my head. Where can we find Kirk's actual scorecard?

Total of 4 to 7 including the Universe reboot, depending on your inclusiveness (out of 11-17 total women).

https://scifi.stackexchange.com/que...-alien-women-has-capt-admiral-kirk-slept-with
 
Steve Shives did a video on Kirk being a promiscuous horndog and whether or not the reputation is earned. I'd link to it but I know some here don't like him and, well, many of his videos are longer than an A&E adaptation of Wuthering Heights.
 
I like the old-school TOS poetic episode titles. I loathed TNG's unimaginative, boring, perfunctory "The This," "The That," and "The Other" title format.

There's a lot to like about TNG, but the episode titles do not rank high on that list.

A lot of the TOS titles were lifted from Shakespeare... this is not a criticism. I loved them too.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top