• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Star Trek: Discovery 4x01 - "Kobayashi Maru"

Rate the episode...


  • Total voters
    174
So.. The debris field..
Guess the navigational deflector ... Phasers, torpedoes were broken?
Or that they couldn't use phasers to vaporize the methane before it impacted the Shields. My other question would be doesn't the 32nd Century version of the discovery have shuttlecraft? IE they could have just blown the escape craft free from docking airlock, and had multiple shuttles waiting; or hell, why wouldn't the shovels in the 32nd century have a transporter array themselves? The discovery shuttles of the 22nd century had built-in Transporters already. So what the 32nd Century shuttles got a downgrade?
 
According to Memory Alpha, Lieutenant Audrey Willa appeared in this episode.
Does anyone remember seeing her?
Did Willa don the same uniform from last season, or did it reflect the more colorful new style?
 
According to Memory Alpha, Lieutenant Audrey Willa appeared in this episode.
Does anyone remember seeing her?
Did Willa don the same uniform from last season, or did it reflect the more colorful new style?

Lieutenant Willa appeared about 20 minutes into the episode, she informed Burnham that Vance wanted to talk to her after Burnham and Tilly talk following the President’s speech to the new cadets, and Willa is wearing the same kind of dress uniform as Tilly and the non-Captain Disco crew.
 
According to Memory Alpha, Lieutenant Audrey Willa appeared in this episode.
Does anyone remember seeing her?
Did Willa don the same uniform from last season, or did it reflect the more colorful new style?
9k.png
 
Although I understand the story reasons for this, I don't understand why it was this way in the ST universe.

They have one escape vessel. It can house 9 people safely (there were 10 crewmembers on that station and 2 beamed over, making it 12, and 3 stayed behind to catch the next trip). Why couldn't the escape vessel carry those additional three people?
 
Still bothers me from season 3 that there was no progress in propulsion in nearly 1,000 years. Are we still getting around the same way we did 1,000 years ago?
 
Horse and carriage was the fastest mode of transportation on land for 4000 years. When you've reached reliable and ludicrous superluminal speeds in the Start Trek universe, what's the drive to fix something that isn't broken? There's a need in the 32nd century after the depletion of dilithium and the Burn, there wasn't one in the previous millennium.
 
Still bothers me from season 3 that there was no progress in propulsion in nearly 1,000 years. Are we still getting around the same way we did 1,000 years ago?

Seemed to me that the Galaxy was known, that random independent couriers knew about and could (with appropriate resources) use transwarp tunnels and slipstream drives.

Inventions since Discovery's time to improve speeds and mentioned in the first couple of episodes of season 3

* dilithium recrystallizers
* quantum slipstream (requires benamite)
* Tachyon solar sails (relatively slow compare with warp, despite doing Bajor to Cardassia really quickly)
* Something trilithium powered (which I suspect is rather dangerous)
* Artificial wormholes (which destroy light years of space)
* Transwarp conduits (which have a lot of debris in)

There's evidence the Federation has detailed knowledge and (pre burn at least) presence in the entire Galaxy, even with dilithium supplies drying up (they were drying up before the Burn). With dilithium, hopping tens of thousands of light years in a few hours/days is quite normal, so speeds are vastly increased over the 24th century.
 
Someone upthread who described the opening scene as like from a buddy movie: yes! Starfleet used to be fairly serious professionals on the job, and now — as someone else mentioned, they are all chummy and quippy like a Marvel movie. Wasn’t there an “I love you guys” group hug near the end of last season?

I’m gonna stop ringing in here. The same things bug me and it serves no purpose.
For better or worse, things like these solidify the effect that Discover is kinda NuTrek: The Series no matter in which timeline it is set.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top