• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers The Mandalorian season 2 discussion

Yes, but can he act without moving his upper lip?
I was thinking of the Tarkin novel, where Palpatine appoints him Grand Moff at the end, with the implication that this was a unique circumstance and that the title wasn't one that existed until now. I could be misremembering, it has been five years since I read it.
IIRC that books takes place fairly early on in the Empire; very shortly after RotS, and yes at that time Tarkin was the only Grand Moff because he was the first Grand Moff. Others were appointed later.
 
yHOp1k4.jpg
I always got the impression he did know but was just being coy
 
Obi never suggests he doesn’t know Artoo. Just that he didn’t recall ever owning a droid.

Of course, there was R4...
 
I was screaming NO FUCKING WAY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


Yup. A short two minute sequence with like(stand in and cgi) and it has almost made up for what that moron Rian did to Luke. Abrams to. They felt the need to tear the originals to build their characters up. Horrible storytelling. Hamill 6 years ago worked out to get in shape for nothing. We all expected a real battle with actual lightsabers clashing and never got it. Hamill hated getting in shape and won’t do it again. But this episode proved what the fans had been wanting for years. It was a great bit and outclassed anything we got in the sequel trilogy. By far. Hell we even got Artoo.
 
Yup. A short two minute sequence with like(stand in and cgi) and it has almost made up for what that moron Rian did to Luke. Abrams to. They felt the need to tear the originals to build their characters up. Horrible storytelling. Hamill 6 years ago worked out to get in shape for nothing. We all expected a real battle with actual lightsabers clashing and never got it. Hamill hated getting in shape and won’t do it again. But this episode proved what the fans had been wanting for years. It was a great bit and outclassed anything we got in the sequel trilogy. By far. Hell we even got Artoo.

TLJ > Every other Star Wars made since 1983
 
Obi never suggests he doesn’t know Artoo. Just that he didn’t recall ever owning a droid.

Of course, there was R4...

Property of the Jedi Council/Order, not Obi Wan personally.

(also permanently embedded into a ship!)

Moff Gideon ended up being a paper tiger in the end, didn’t he? Maybe if Mando hadn’t threatened him we could buy that it was the element of surprise but he ended up seeming a bit of a chump.

He was very smart and also a formidable combatant. He would have killed Din and all of his friends if not for a last-minute Deux Ex Machina.

hardly a chump.
 
TLJ > Every other Star Wars made since 1983
Lol! The mandalorian toys are easily outselling any toys they made during your beloved TLJ era. Sorry but it looks like Favereau will be adding more of the Star Wars most of the fans like. We won’t be seeing Rey for a few decades. Maybe never again.
 
Lol! The mandalorian toys are easily outselling any toys they made during your beloved TLJ era. Sorry but it looks like Favereau will be adding more of the Star Wars most of the fans like. We won’t be seeing Rey for a few decades. Maybe never again.

Well, thank god the toy sales are here to validate filmmaking quality! Whew.
 
Well, thank god the toy sales are here to validate filmmaking quality! Whew.

We definitely won’t be seeing Finn ever again. Lol. Mostly likely Poe will never be shown again. You’re favorite trio will never ever gain the significance of the originals because they just repeated their story. They weren’t first. Sorry but the sequels are done and no one cares to explore that era of Star Wars again.
 
Sisko, Kira and Odo will never gain the cultural significance of Kirk, Spock and McCoy but that doesn't mean they're not of value.

And Sisko, Kira and Odo were in some pretty shit episodes and storylines.
 
So, been thinking things over, and I realized that it was perhaps a mistake to have that scene last week where Din had to remove his helmet while at the Imperial refinery since now because of that we know he's not adhering to The Way as strictly as he was in season 1 in that he's already removed his helmet but is continuing to wear it afterwards anyway, which I'm thinking robs his good-bye with Grogu some extra poignancy. Yes, it's still significant in that this is the first time he's voluntarily removed his helmet in the presence of others (last week it was by necessity to access the computer terminal), I'm thinking that if we hadn't had that scene last week, it could have really been a significant moment. For the first time ever, he removes his helmet in front of others in order to say good-bye to Grogu, then we end on him standing there without his helmet. If we hadn't had the scene last week, that could also have driven a question of what is Din's status now? Is he going to adhere to the Way and not put the helmet on again, or is he going to continue wearing the helmet and follow a more liberal interpretation of the Mandalorian code, like Bo-Katan and her Mandalorians so? Instead, we can pretty much assume he's following the liberal interpretation.

Could it be that his interpritation of the code is taking off his own helmet in front of others, rather than people seeing his face? The Imperial helmet he took off wasn't his, it was some Imperial's they stole. So could he still put on his own helmet because that wasn't what he took off? Now with Grogu, that is different. That was his helmet and he was in front of others. Though it was to say goodbye to the other half of his clan.
 
Yeah, the Grogu moment was a lot more significant in context. The creed says don't remove your Mandalorian armor helmet in front of others. An appropriated Imperial Remnant helmet that wasn't even his to begin with doesn't count the same way, and like Ithekro said he needed to in order to access the computer terminal and learn the location of Moff Gideon's ship. One was necessity and allowed him to exercise a loophole without violating the code. The other was to express his love for Grogu and say Goodbye.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top