• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Kurtzman: DS9 characters could appear in Picard

That's a very valid point about Bareil and that time in Kira's life. All these years, I never thought about it in that way, but it makes sense. It does put a different spin on him, as well.

A question... if Bareil and Kira never got together, do you think she would have found some sense of centerness that she got, or would it just have happened much later?
 
  • Like
Reactions: kkt
That's a very valid point about Bareil and that time in Kira's life. All these years, I never thought about it in that way, but it makes sense. It does put a different spin on him, as well.

A question... if Bareil and Kira never got together, do you think she would have found some sense of centerness that she got, or would it just have happened much later?

I think that "Duet" began her character change and while it might have taken awhile longer without Bariel, I think that he would have gotten there. He was important to her, I know, but I never really cared for the character.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kkt
I agree about "DUET" being that first step, but not for that. I think it was her first step toward letting go of the anger toward all Cardassians.

"BATTLE LINES", I feel, was the first step toward letting go of the anger about herself. Opaka's words, and her seeing what those people were going through, were a wake up call for her. I think that was a physical representation of the struggle within herself, and she definitely didn't like what she saw.
 
Garak is the better character, but Bashir has more potential for growth. I've said for many years that it was a crime that Picard never met Garak. Bashir had a little Garak in him by the end of the series, and Sid probably is a better actor now than Robinson.

(That said, I'm starting to feel that DS9 is a dead end with regard to the current producers. They'll take Section 31 as a hack to the Federation, but I doubt we'll see them using themes, tones or ideas from DS9.)
 
Why is Morn managing the bar and not Quark? That business is his baby.

Quark has mixed feelings about the bar. Yes, it's his, and it is a profit-making business and that's always good to a Ferengi. But it's not making a lot of money, especially now that Sisko and Odo won't let him go into profitable sidelines any more. He's never going to get his own moon that way. And when he's had a chance to make a lot of money and leave the bar behind, he always wants to jump at the chance. When he thinks he's going to be Nagus, he's eager to sell it to Rom, and not even bother to negotiate a price. When he's selling weapons, he doesn't care if the station crew and residents stop coming to the bar, because he's making a lot more money selling weapons. When he's stuck in 20th century Roswell, he's looking forward to making a fortune selling technical secrets to the Australians or Russians... and doesn't even think about the bar. The Nagus had it right when he told Quark he'll be tending that worthless little bar for the rest of his life; that's what it is to him.
 
So Kurtzman is just winding up the audience with tabloid puff'n'huff? Either they are or aren't.


Sounds to me like he was just asked a question and answered it off the cuff, in such a way as to keep the readers sweet while not promising anything. So no, he wasn't winding them up, he was improvising. Unfortunately it's exactly the kind of thing that creates problems, because look at the headline of this very thread – yes it includes the word "could", but you know damn well everyone is going to read that as "will" and then get annoyed when they don't get the thing they were never promised in the first place.

If there is one character I would love to see back, it's Ezri Dax. I've seen Deboer at the Las Vegas convention and she still looks great.


I agree that Ezri is one of the most likely characters to bring back – she was a long way from the breakout character of the show like Data or Seven were, but she is the most mobile and could pop up anywhere, unlike the rest who are more closely tied to their individual DS9 storylines. The Picard show as depicted so far (and we have no reason to believe it won't continue in a similar vein) has been all about Borg, Romulans and AI – all things DS9 has next to nothing to do with.

Tying that back into the Uhura idea also mentioned in that interview, the books establish that Uhura slept with Curzon at one point, so a reunion with Ezri would be interesting...

I've always wanted to see a scene involving Garak and Picard.
Picard would hate everything about Garak, and Garak would mark Picard down as predictable and potentially useful.


Picard doesn't hate anyone who hasn't hurt him, that's not who he is. And again they have met in the books, and they got along fine thanks to a shared interest in literature.

Although those books are loved by you and a lot of other people, they're not canon, and aren't going to be used by the writers of this show anyway


You say that like we don't already know. We know the books aren't canon, thank you very much, and the TV shows don't have to adhere to them. But the fact is they can if they so choose – it's all Star Trek, it all belongs to CBS/Paramount, so they are at liberty to use as much or as little of it as they want. For example, the ideas of Romulans having personal names that only their families can use, and of an advanced society of AIs that want to contact the AIs in our galaxy, are both out of the books.

It doesn't mean you have to go into detailed backstories and explanations, it just means it's an idea that first came up in the books and which the TV writers picked up to use in service of their own stories. No reason they couldn't do so again with other ideas from the books, if it served their purposes.

.
 
Bashir killed Sloan. Bashir is not the sort of operative Section 31 wants.
This is one of the reasons I balked at the DS9 writers making Bashir head of Section 31 in their hypothetical season 8 exercise. It completely contradicts what we know about his character and moral compass. So much of his character arc in the later seasons revolved around his desire to see Section 31 eliminated. Granted, a lot can happen to a person in 20 years, but it would have to be pretty seismic for him to do a complete 180 on the organization and rise its ranks to a leadership position.

I guess I could see it playing out the way it does in the novels, with Bashir attempting to bring Section 31 down from the inside (though this isn't really where I'd want his character to wind up) but it seemed like the writers were playing it straight.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top