• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Star Trek: Picard 1x04 - "Absolute Candor"

Rate the episode...


  • Total voters
    283
So if you thread-banned him on my account, you might want to undo it. It's not fair as obviously some of you thought I was speaking as Board Manager and not as T'Bonz, who thought his definition was plain wrong.
Done, though I feel the ban was justified anyway because of the continuing derail, so I hope everyone will let the Mary Sue subject rest in peace.

qSfHw24.gif
DRINK!
 
Aw shit man. I was posting as a fan, not officially as manager. No need to ban him on my account. I guess I should have said something to the effect that this is not official, but it was late at night and sometimes I just forget I run the place, you know? I'm a fan of the show and his running the Mary Sue crap into the ground just got old and my tolerance is always low when I'm tired.

I'm not afraid of someone challenging me as regular poster.

So if you thread-banned him on my account, you might want to undo it. It's not fair as obviously some of you thought I was speaking as Board Manager and not as T'Bonz, who thought his definition was plain wrong.

Sorry to fuck up your forum. It wasn't intentional.

No more ale for me.
Dear mods and admins. Just copy my ignore list and everything will be just fine. ;)
If you want to clean up this place, make me a mod for day. :hugegrin:
 
You're going to wake up one day and find T'Bonz has invoked that little known and seldom used reserve activation clause.
think of it more like a retired Starfleet Admiral pulled back into a game after spending two decades on some vinyard
Just call him LG.

Sorry but "Comments to PM" kills it for me (it used to be "Comments to MA" when I was a mod). Do you really think I'd want them sending me messages? :p
 
Last edited:
Do Androids Dream Of Electric Sheep? Since Picard never read that book, I wonder what he thought it was about...

Do electric sheep dream of androids?

We don't know that the rest of the UFP was in favor of it. Clancy said 14 threatened to secede from the Federation. …

We know only what we have been told therefore can only form opinions based on those facts. We also know the Romulans pulled some shenanigans so there likely was some corruption.

Once the decision is made, there wasn't anything more he could have done there. Yes we hear that he could have tried to convince others, though I am not sure how that would have worked. Every other Power and every other World knew this was happening.

Tell that to The Red Cross. Tell that to Gandhi. Tell that to Fred Cox. Tell that to Zephram Cochran or Surak or Kahless. One of Star Trek preeminent messages has been "one person CAN make a difference."

I think it is alot to put on the shoulders of one man to say he needs to convince a whole Quadrant to do the right thing.

Absolutely, that what makes or breaks a hero! In this case we see it broke Picard and now he is on a quest for redemption.
 
I didn't love this episode. I liked it just okay. However, it made me love the entire series so much more, if that makes sense?

Like, this episode was what was a "planet-of-the-hats" episodes back in the days. And I didn't really care much about this' episodes main plot surrounding Elnor. But I absolutely loved that this type of episode is back, a story of the week, just better integrated into a new series format. How it connects with the main plot of the series, and just feels so much like "Star Trek" should feel. Also, they got all the little details right, from the little character moments, the new warp effect, the new and familiar Romulans, the fucking Warbird, to finally having starship battles with phaser beams again (instead of the "pew-pew"-bolts).
 
So the Romulan pub/bar whatever it was had a sign that said 'Romulans Only'. There was also another building in the background that had a sign that said 'No Romulans'.

to finally having starship battles with phaser beams again (instead of the "pew-pew"-bolts).
DSC Season 2 used beams too (though the little fighter things still used bolts)
 
The series could a little better by keeping Data more in focus. That might even just mean a simple 3 seconds of Picard reflecting on a picture of him..

Because it's hard to engage with Picard's purpose here. Go get the bookish miserly Maddox over several episodes is not exactly a thriller of an objective. I know he needs Maddox to get to Data's other daughter? But still it's hard to get your teeth fully into this.

I'm enjoying most of these episodes as episodes.

But the purposefullness of the show as an arc show could do with being strengthened.
 
Aw shit man. I was posting as a fan, not officially as manager. No need to ban him on my account. I guess I should have said something to the effect that this is not official, but it was late at night and sometimes I just forget I run the place, you know? I'm a fan of the show and his running the Mary Sue crap into the ground just got old and my tolerance is always low when I'm tired.

I'm not afraid of someone challenging me as regular poster.

So if you thread-banned him on my account, you might want to undo it. It's not fair as obviously some of you thought I was speaking as Board Manager and not as T'Bonz, who thought his definition was plain wrong.

Sorry to fuck up your forum. It wasn't intentional.

No more ale for me.
Heh ...
Any forum you wander into and deem necessary to talk to us from On High,
Always brings that ever present Varon-T into the conversation.

You're the Romulan Praetor around here and most of us bow in your presence.
bow.gif
 
Even the Borg needed a place to go where everybody knows their designation (bartended by an assimilated Saavik).

Borging your way in the universe today
Takes every Queen you got.

Taking a break from all your assimilation's
It sure would help a lot.

Wouldn't you like to really go astray?

Sometimes you want to go
Where everybody knows your designation
And they're always sad you came

You want to be where you can see
The Drones are all the same
You want to be where everyone can be reclaimed.

:beer:
 
Last edited:
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top