But only because he sent a command helmsman and a counselor there instead of an engineer or a repair robot in the first place even if just to work on the blast door that could save lives. We use robots to disarm weapons now, surely we would do it in the future?
Trek engineers run in three shifts so during a red alert there are three times the engineers available. This type of scenario that could destroy the entire ship is exactly what your damage control teams are for. Mind you, piloting thirty odd small craft must thin out your damage control teams substantially and Pike's crew was half Kirk's (albeit probably fewer scientists) and repair robots were doing their R2D2 thing on the hull.