• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Stupid Stuff in TNG

Ro was defiant and obnoxious from the get-go. She needed to know her place. (And, you know, she WAS a convicted felon.) That's why I think Riker made her take off the earring - to take her down a peg.

Sure, because a good dose of religious and/or culturally based discrimination and/or intimidation is always a great go-to strategy for a superior officer to produce a well-disciplined and motivated crew. It's really great for overall morale. Especially in the star-spangled, oh-so-enlightened and more awesome than anyone Starfleet/UFP. Yet another bullet point on the list of reason why Riker is a total schmuck and should never, ever be promoted to command of anyone or anything more complex than the Mr. Coffee machine in the break room.
 
Sure, because a good dose of religious and/or culturally based discrimination and/or intimidation is always a great go-to strategy for a superior officer to produce a well-disciplined and motivated crew. It's really great for overall morale. Especially in the star-spangled, oh-so-enlightened and more awesome than anyone Starfleet/UFP. Yet another bullet point on the list of reason why Riker is a total schmuck and should never, ever be promoted to command of anyone or anything more complex than the Mr. Coffee machine in the break room.

Whether or not Riker was in fact being a dick, is another matter. The fact remains, he's the senior officer...he GETS to be a dick if he feels the situation warrants it. And in that case, it did.

Riker's treatment of Ro in that scene may be questionable...but she deserved it. :shrug:
 
Picard, Riker, Worf, and Data are always on the bridge together during most of the episodes. I know it wouldn't make sense to have a tv show without all the stars interacting, but who is in charge of the night shifts, etc.

It makes sense that the senior staff is on the bridge when there's something going on.
They're not there all the time as we saw in 'Data's Day'.
 
BoBW Part 2. The Borg making no attempt to retrieve Picard. The most WTF moment in Trek history.

Lets face it, the Borg is dumb, really dumb.

Locutus did say somethin like "incorrect strategy, Picard would never have approved".
quote - "I will continue aboard this ship to speak for the Borg while they continue, without further diversion, to Sector 001 where they will force your unconditional surrender." - end quote

The Borg saw no need to get him back. Why would they. They didn't consider the Enterprise to be any kind of threat.
 
Data typing when his robotic nature would allow him to communicate with the computer billions of times faster with the 24th-century equivalent to our WiFi!!
 
Main one for TNG generally: why does a top-of-the-range exploration starship – the Federation flagship no less – not have a science officer on the bridge? Even a backwater space station like DS9 had a science officer assigned to their senior staff to sit in the station control room, and that was before the stable wormhole was discovered...

I've always assumed that Data, operations officer, is basically the science officer.


If only there was an episode with dialog shedding light on the subject.

In "Conspiracy:

IKER: What is it?
QUINN: A form of life. It was discovered accidentally by a survey team on an uncharted planet.
RIKER: Why haven't we heard anything about that?
QUINN: Oh, you'll be hearing about it shortly, but first there remains much scientific study to be done. After all, it is a superior form of life.
RIKER: Superior?
QUINN: Totally. Come, have a look.
RIKER: I think I'll summon my Science Officer.
(Quinn grabs his arm with a surprising amount of strength)
QUINN: It won't like your Science Officer. It does like you! Vitamins. They do wonders for the body.

http://www.chakoteya.net/NextGen/125.htm

Clearly Quinn knew that Riker's science officer was either Data or someone else highly nonhuman that the parasite wouldn't like.
 
Last edited:
BoBW Part 2. The Borg making no attempt to retrieve Picard. The most WTF moment in Trek history.
They had no need for him at that point. :shrug:

It would be consistent with Borg not really trying hard to get Seven back...
 
When Picard said "I knew your father." to Wesley, it sounded so fake that I wondered if there was a second meaning to that. Turns out the series is not that deep...
 
If only there was an episode with dialog shedding light on the subject.

In "Conspiracy:



http://www.chakoteya.net/NextGen/125.htm

Clearly Quinn knew that Riker's science officer was either Data or someone else highly nonhuman that the parasite wouldn't like.
Data wasn’t the/a science officer, even if his Operations Management Officer position was created by TNG’s creative teams as fudge that did sort-of science officer things...
 
As in "Shades Of Gray", they wander on foot on completely unknown alien planets... I mean I am surprised they aren't more casualties among the crew like people being eaten alive for example. remember that only 65 million years ago (which is a small fraction of how long life has existed on Earth) the Earth itself teemed with beasts like the T-rex who would have made a quick light meal of Riker!!!
 
As in "Shades Of Gray", they wander on foot on completely unknown alien planets... I mean I am surprised they aren't more casualties among the crew like people being eaten alive for example. remember that only 65 million years ago (which is a small fraction of how long life has existed on Earth) the Earth itself teemed with beasts like the T-rex who would have made a quick light meal of Riker!!!
Not a fair assessment. How many times did we see on screen that a crew member scanned the planet's surface for signs of life and quantify their discoveries. If it's an M-class planet with a breathable atmosphere, you pretty much know what to expect.
 
Not a fair assessment. How many times did we see on screen that a crew member scanned the planet's surface for signs of life and quantify their discoveries. If it's an M-class planet with a breathable atmosphere, you pretty much know what to expect.

Yet obviously the scan wasn't good enough to detect whatever was lying in wait for Riker.
 
When Picard said "I knew your father." to Wesley, it sounded so fake that I wondered if there was a second meaning to that. Turns out the series is not that deep...
I think you are reading/expecting too much in that scene. It was safe to assume Picard hadn't seen them since Picard gave them the bad news... PIcard's demeanor in that scene makes sense.
 
I think you are reading/expecting too much in that scene. It was safe to assume Picard hadn't seen them since Picard gave them the bad news... PIcard's demeanor in that scene makes sense.

Are you referring to the scene shown in the brain rape episode "Violations"?
 
It has been mentioned several times over the years that Picard was the one that went back to wherever Beverly and Wesley was living at the time well before Violations came out (they never make it clear where it was, though Violations does imply it was at a starbase....), and told them that Jack had been killed.

:vulcan:
 
It has been mentioned several times over the years that Picard was the one that went back to wherever Beverly and Wesley was living at the time well before Violations came out (they never make it clear where it was, though Violations does imply it was at a starbase....), and told them that Jack had been killed.

:vulcan:

So when Picard said "I knew your father", Wes unexpressed thought was: "Sure you did! You're the one that told me he was dead!"
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top