• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Star Trek Discovery Renewed For Season 3

The argument is more that, as adblockers and DVRs have gained widespread use, corporations have begun to deliberately trigger conservatives and alt-right types by embracing "woke" messages, not out of a desire to "expanded to aspects of communities it used to ignore" but to make themselves the subject of social media furors. You can't be adblocked if alt-righters and the left wing folks they target do the marketing for you by yelling about your brand!
Yeah, and back in the sixties ad companies would sometimes deliberately make their commercials obnoxious for the reasons you list above. They wanted people talking about their commercials even if the talk was critical. Doing things to make your commercial stand out, if that is what is going on, is an old tried and true marketing method.

But because those methods may now be being used to market to different groups than in the past, those old methods now need a new label, I guess, because to so many, "this is not normal".
The aforementioned HBomber whose video was referenced is a left-wing YouTuber who identifies as a socialist and has partnerd with other progressive media analysts such as Dan Olson of Folding Ideas and Lindsay Ellis of...herself. So don't think the critique is coming from some place of wanting to marginalize PoCs or minority communities. It come from frustration and anger
And ignorance, evidently. Their hearts may be in the right place (and that's a pretty weak defense if that is what it is meant to be), but they may not realize the extent to which they may have bought into some of the same tropes espoused by the alt-right. No doubt they probably also lack somehistorical perspective. They wouldn't be the first liberals to "think" they were doing the right thing while blindly doing the opposite. I think these guys are dead wrong at least with respect to marketing issue.
Personally, I find it a compelling view as it lines up with things I started to notice about the marketing of Marvel and Star Wars movies versus their actual contents – specifically the claims made at panels and on social media that various characters are bisexual, pansexual, or otherwise non-binary that is then not supported at all in the texts of the movies themselves. I can't help but notice that it whips social media into a frenzy over the progressive wokeness, while not putting anything in the films that could alienate Billy Joe Bob in Alabama or any of the censors in the Chinese government.
To me, you all are way over-thinking this. Since all you have to do to trigger conservatives or alt-righters is include minorities and too many women in positions of power, or other than heterosexual characters. The studios' move toward diversity alone guarantees the aforementioned groups will stay triggered.
Because Disney still wants their dollars too, you see, and they're perfectly happy to inflame cultural divisions online to get it. They have no loyalty, no ethics, and no real commitment to liberal values beyond what nets them $$$.
This just makes me weary. I don't see how Disney or CBS is marketing any differently than it has been done in the past. It is a happy coincidence (for those corporations) that social media exists. That these corporations are marketing just to stir up the right doesn't seem too cost effective or even plausible.
 
The most common one seems to be that CBS is taking a massive loss to push its New World Order/SJW agenda/indoctrination of the masses, etc.
Err, if their agenda is indoctrination of the masses, why Discovery isn't broadcast on the free-on-air television..? They are very bad at this...
"Did you hear the last inspirational speech of the Führer?"
"Um, no man, I had some problems and I haven't renewed my subscription but, err, I'll catch up on the next month... I think..."
 
Interesting how folks who have never acted a day in their life, think that they are the final arbitrator as to someone else's talent.
Your just a couch critic, and any assertations you may espouse, are not worth much in the grand scheme of things.

You can say in your opinion you don't like the way a particular person has portrayed a character/role, but you have no authority to declare how good or bad it is, without actually trying it for yourself and succeeding or failing on your own merits.
Then you MIGHT be able to make a informed judgement.
(but at that point you'd probably realize that it's not as easy as you may think)

Hollywood Producers with the responsibility of creating Multi-Million Dollar shows and/or movies do not on the whole hire "bad" Actors.
(and if they do, it's usually discovered long before any of us see any of their product, and dealt with)

Many of the Professional Actors that are being compared in this thread, have been PAID to do what they do for decades.
And many of them began in Professional Shakespearean Theater Company's where only the Good Ones Survive.
NONE of them would still be getting Paid Roles if they weren't more than competent at it.

Again, you may not care for the way a particular role is being portrayed, but you certainly may not define your assertions as being factual.

:rolleyes:
Fallacious bullshit.
 
You're not missing anything.
It's a stupid made up term.

And both liberals and conservatives use it which makes it all that more obnoxious. Paranoid right-wing conspiracy believers use the term as do progressive activists who feel they've stumbled onto some new level of awareness about an issue. It sounds stupid no matter who says it.
 
I can't be that out of touch, but I don't even know what "woke" means.


Me neither. Can’t we just have a TV series without all this woke, virtue signalling BS baggage that comes with it? Everything has to have a sodding agenda attached to it or ensure that both the left and right don’t get angered. I’m sick of all the “right on” hashtags, statement making bollocks.
 
No I don’t, but woke, virtue signalling etc are mentioned at every opportunity. Why?.. I want TV to be entertaining without having to pick apart every aspect of it.
 
The TrekBBS wouldn't even exist if we didn't pick things apart and analyze them on a subatomic level. That's what we DO. We're Star Trek fans.

I suppose the board could be about porn and food without Star Trek to bring us all together but that's kind of what it's already about anyways.
 
To discuss the series, definitely. To pick apart every aspect? IMHO, no. To do that, the words “fan board” become moot. I may look at things more simplistically than some, but I am entertained by Discovery. Sure, there are some aspects I would change and I prefer certain characters over others, however, when the discussions enter into a political arguments, then perhaps the life has been sucked out of the TV series you are watching. Surely, you are either a fan or not, like the series or not?
 
I can't be that out of touch, but I don't even know what "woke" means.

I am afraid that, yes, not knowing what woke means does suggest you are a little out of touch. It been a pretty well known slang term for at least the last four-five years. Heck, Websters added it to their Dictionary 2 year ago.
 
No I don’t, but woke, virtue signalling etc are mentioned at every opportunity. Why?.. I want TV to be entertaining without having to pick apart every aspect of it.

Funny, I see a show where people are doing their jobs in the context that its on a Federation Starship in the mid 23rd century. All this "BS baggage" of what you speak, IMO, is being brought by people in the early 21st century with their own personal axes to grind who are imagining things that aren't actually there. But I see few people here ascribing anything you are talking about on this board.
 
Funny, I see a show where people are doing their jobs in the context that its on a Federation Starship in the mid 23rd century. All this "BS baggage" of what you speak, IMO, is being brought by people in the early 21st century with their own personal axes to grind who are imagining things that aren't actually there. But I see few people here ascribing anything you are talking about on this board.
This. This VERY much.

Also, I cannot believe, seriously not believe how anyone can still use a term as ridiculous and devoid of actual meaning as "virtue signalling" without spontaneously combusting. It's frankly just silly.
 
I am afraid that, yes, not knowing what woke means does suggest you are a little out of touch. It been a pretty well known slang term for at least the last four-five years. Heck, Websters added it to their Dictionary 2 year ago.

Me: I'm still young!
Some Kid: That's woke!
Some Other Kid: SWAG! YOLO!
Me: ... No. No, I'm not. Face it. You're 40.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top