• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Star Trek: Discovery 2x07 - "Light and Shadows"

Hit it!


  • Total voters
    206
Talosians

unknown.png
I think I'd prefer it if they didn't have that nose part.
 
I think it looks kind of cool actually. We've never seen the Turbolift from the outside before, and it looks like a convayer belt for baggage at the airport (Or at least the way Toy Story 2 (?) portrayed it.)


My Fanon is that all the empty space is artistic license for decks and bulkheads. Those layers are just turned off so we can see the turbolift shafts.
 
not sure if I like the TCW stuff, to be frank

There were a couple of cool moments in there, but the time technobabble and Stamets stuff just felt like a load of Voyager nonsense to me. Not keen on that direction.

At least the silly Tyler situation was acknowledged. But that just made it seem even goofier. Mount was the saving grace of those segments. I really wanted Pike to kill Tyler and was sad he didn't. Don't tease me like that, Discovery.

The Spock scenes started off weak, with the awkward childhood flashback, but, surprisingly, ended up being the better part of the ep. This might have been Frain's best work, I thought. SMG was good, too.

Overall, the anomaly stuff felt like a bit of a time-filling runaround. Necessary to the season, maybe, but not much on its own.
 
Last edited:
This was Burnham's best episode of the season.

Amanda must be pissed about Sarek having Burnham take Spock to Section 31. Leland definitely got Burnham to let her guard down around Section 31. First by having assigned Tyler to Discovery earlier, and now by acting all sympathetic. She didn't trust Georgiou, but her mistrust was aimed in the wrong direction.
 
Hrrm...yeah, I'm going with a seven this week. It was a decent episode, but not one of Discovery's better ones.

I guess I'll start with the A plot - Burnham's search for Spock finally drawing to a close. I thought that this was - generally speaking - well done. SMG put in an above-average performance for her (aside from the very beginning of the episode). I enjoyed seeing Amanda again as well. I felt like Sarek's decision to not just turn Spock in, but turn him over to Section 31 made little narrative sense though - it just happened because the plot demanded it. And after that discussion it's very, very hard to see why Amanda would ever stay with Sarek. Not sure how I feel about finding out that Spock is...erm..."special" either. I liked seeing Georgiou's character deepen a bit, though I felt like - once again - people were being dragged along a bit by the needs of the plot rather than anything which was grounded in the characters.

As for the B plot - holy hell was there a lot of technobabble! I appreciate that this plot helped to build trust between Pike and Tyler, but that's really just about all I appreciate about it. Otherwise it just was a bunch of flashy graphics and plotted way, way too goddamned fast.
 
I hope so but thought that one could be a dude as well. None of them should be dudes.

The talosians were played by women, but the characters themselves were male.

The one on the left here appears to be played by a woman

unknown.png
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top