• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

USS Enterprise (eventually) on Discovery?

This is my favourite part of the design, I love the physical deflectors.

87mHKmA.png
 
That's a great looking dish.

So far it looks like a good model but it does look a little floppy in places. I'll chalk that up to prototype though.
 
zX34WQj.png


You know, if the ship really is 480 meters long, that is going to be a big turbolift shaft.

Also the bridge window is going to be huge compared to Discovery's.

What if that two story interior set we saw in the production trailer really was the Enterprise's bridge?

It's certianlly a domed shape interior, it has struts like the Discovery bridge, there are what I think are consoles along the outside of the circle. At 480 meters deck 1 would certainly be big enough
96AA418B5F7DAE76EE2E2A5DD1A895C5B211BDF5
 
Last edited:
That file on Mudd is hilarious at times....got the whole sell-'em-the-Brooklyn-Bridge thing going there. :D

I'm very curious what's behind the Enterprise's distress call....do they need someone to get Spock to Vulcan, because it's pon farr time and he's starting to run amok? :lol:
Yeh - especially the bit where he sold some aliens their own ocean :guffaw:

and my guess for the Enterprise distress call is that the crew is slowly being turned into bionic zombies. Who sound Swedish.
 
TBH, nothing about the show makes me think they would have the guts to reimagine Spock or the ability to pull it off. What they have given us has been highly derivative, and even the biggest changes haven’t been reimaginings so much as obvious attempts to up the kewl factor. (See also: adding gratuitous sex and nudity.)

Their take on Sarek was about as rote and dull as I can imagine, and even the last-second attempt to make him into a genocidal maniac seemed more like cheap plot shorthand than a deliberate character choice.
I must admit the whole thing does smack of the Radioactive Man movie (“I want to get as far away as possible from that awful camp 60s tv show...”)

I think this is particularly evident regarding the Enterprise herself. And, as I said above, even the changes they have made don’t do enough to make the ship fit in with the DSC universe. If they were going to do a (in some cases highly derivative) visual update, I’d have thought they’d have picked one style and designed everything to fit with it.

The DSC Enterprise is the equivalent of the Enterprise B modifications to the excelsior. And we even have starfleet with different types of uniforms all over the place.

Generations is back.
 

Still a very nice demonstration of how this design looks. Again, I don't dislike it at all.

That's a great looking dish.

I wish they had illuminated it somehow. My only gripe with the DSC Enterprise right now is that the front end is a bit dark.

The DSC Enterprise is the equivalent of the Enterprise B modifications to the excelsior.

How so? We knew the B was an Excelsior class for years before the movie came out.
 
How so? We knew the B was an Excelsior class for years before the movie came out.
I meant in terms of the added fins and cutouts etc. The extent of the changes to the DSC Enterprise remind me of the changes to the Enterprise B model. It’s not a reimagining per se - it’s just gluing flares and fins to it. If they were going to reimagine the Enterprise for DSC they could have made it look much closer to the overall DSC aesthetic.
 
I remember someone complaining it looked too similar to the TOS Connie back when the finale aired, but I don’t remember who.

I remember someone else didn’t like the deflector dish because it was too ‘primitive’
 

Well, the ship needed updating, but they updated all the wrong parts, and left alone the parts that needed updating. The deflector dish was by far the most retro 50/60s design element that needed updating, but they left it alone. Then they changed everything else around it to be modern, and so it looks out of place. Most of the design is ok, but the neck and deflector just kill the whole thing. The ship is also too squat. And overcorrecting for the JJprise, I assume, the nacelles are TOO far apart.

I remember someone complaining it looked too similar to the TOS Connie back when the finale aired, but I don’t remember who.

I remember someone else didn’t like the deflector dish because it was too ‘primitive’

It was me. See above.
 
Last edited:
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top