• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

CBS/Paramount sues to stop Axanar

Status
Not open for further replies.
So, he basically sat there and thought of a way to get around the lawsuit and rules. Technically legal, but morally bereft.

And now a Part III when we still don't have a Part I and II? It's like it's a purposeful scam.

Alec has no morals and of course It’s a scam.

What will happen is like the last indiegogo. He won’t raise enough for the movie but he’ll decide to keep the money abd use it for something else like the studio and nobody can complain because they have to know what are getting into this time.
 
Alec has no morals and of course It’s a scam.

What will happen is like the last indiegogo. He won’t raise enough for the movie but he’ll decide to keep the money abd use it for something else like the studio and nobody can complain because they have to know what are getting into this time.
Sadly there are plenty of morons who will still pony up the cash.
 
The movie to be made is “the rise and fall of axanar:diary of a failed fan film and the narcissist behind it”
 
Just so we're all on the same page:
  • The $50,000 restriction on fan films in the guidelines applies only to the limit on crowdfunding per 15-minute episode. There is no limit to spending so long as the source of the funding is private. Under the settlement, Axanar Lite™ can't raise any money via crowdfunding. But they're allowed to raise as much as they can privately.
  • There was never intended to be a part 1 or 2 to Axanar Lite™. Prelude being called part 3 is a dramatic conceit to create an in-universe impression that these short films are part of some grander examination of the Four Years War on which Axanar is based. In fact, up until the lawsuit settlement, there were never intended to be parts 4 and 5. Restrained from producing a feature-length film, Alec Peters decided (over the objections of director Robert Meyer Burnett) to split up the 30 mins. allowed by the settlement into two episodes and producing them as if they were the concluding two parts of the in-universe Four Years War History Channel-style documentary retrospective. Burnett wanted to simply produce the first 30 mins. of the feature script since so much preproduction work had already been completed for that.
  • Expect some controversy over what constitutes "public fundraising" when the time comes. We've already seen several attempts at end runs around the settlement terms. Peters will likely assert that the restriction applies only to crowdfunding, when any public appeal for money (and/or creating a technical means for accepting said funds) in fact may violate the settlement. Stay tuned.
 
LFIM - Looking for loopholes in all the wrong places... ( sung to the tune of you know what )
leopard -- spots --> loopholes

loopholes=middle name:
Defendant Loopholes Spinstruthasneededforcurrentbigdealsincenofailurehaseverbeenmyfault
(of the Shellcompany County's Spinstruthasneeded branch of the Nofailurehaseverbeenmyfaults)
 
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

I think they missed one for their list......
 
I honestly don't see this at all. Maybe productions will be more cautious, maybe CBS will keep a closer eye - but the ONLY thing I can see changing is people being a little more reluctant to take the piss.

Whether by arrogance and ego or just misguided stupidity, Axanar was presenting itself as a professional production and crossed a lot of lines. Unless other fan films want to do the same, I think it's pretty clear that they're all fine.

The argument of brand confusion won't match either as no one in their right mind would think Continues New Voyages with their upgraded replication of a 1960's world would be a current and modern piece of output from CBS.



Thats not confusion. Thats just bad research.



To be fair - that means absolutely nothing. News outlets aren't exactly paragons of perfection. They're all about getting the content out as fast as possible (before anyone else does) and have more time to fill with news constantly being pushed out - even when there's nothing to say or there's a situation that they watch for hours trying to turn something into nothing.

It's not just the content thats downgraded, but the staff. Cheap staff and quick results - particularly within entertainment news - are more important than putting the homework in and mistakes have been made all across the board especially with genre shows and brands.

Put it this way - I've done professional reviews for a national audience on behalf of one of the top broadcasters in the UK. I do have some training (not really, a year before I switched degree's and I spent 90% of the time substituting the pub for the classroom) but they didn't know that. They never asked that. They never questioned me, or discussed much with me. But a researcher read my blog (in the days I could be bothered updating it) and considered me an expert.

Gods knows who CNN decided was their expert that day; but I have the feeling the poor soul was given the task for some stupid reason and no one questioned the results.

This kind of shit is why I preferred Starlog to any other outlet when covering science fiction media; at least that publication would NEVER do shoddy 'journalism' like what CNN did (and it also set up a house rule to NEVER use the word 'geek' or 'nerd' in describing science fiction fandom.) But because of the changes brought about because of the Internet, and declining readership, it went to the great magazine graveyard in the sky in April of 2009.

And what do we have in its place? Crappy online clickbait sites that do shoddy 'journalism' about the media that get stories wrong more often then they do get them right, plus a whole host of other errors. But the main ire should be that a major news organization that's supposed to be a respected leader in news gathering can't even get things right and is making schoolboy howler errors, plus can't even be calm, cool, collected and knowledgeable about a major event like this one compared to the coverage of said event by the main TV network of the country in which the event happened.

We really and truly need better news media.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top