Kelvin Timeline all but confirmed
- Thread starter captainkirk
- Start date
I think it's just a case that different people like different things or it's simply a case of preference. It also could be that people have different levels of involvement or personal investment in regards to Trek as a complete narrative. Some might like things to fit together as much as possible while others couldn't care less if it fits together at all.
Me? I'm just in it for the starships, regardless of when or where...
Or a Robau appearance.
Last edited:
If they wanted, they could just name-check the Kelvin NCC-0514 getting orders in subspace radio chatter, a la the two FJ scouts in TMP at Epsilon IX, but even less conspicuously. That would cost (practically) nothing.*
* - AFAIK.
* - AFAIK.
Last edited:
That was one of my three requirements. The others were give me cool sets* and a new uniform I can wear without looking like a complete idiot.Me? I'm just in it for the starships, regardless of when or where...
I'm happy on all counts.
(* edit: I wrote ships. Can't have that twice!
)
Last edited:
For me, at least, it has nothing to do with disliking the Prime timeline. Just watched three episodes of Enterprise the day before yesterday. I just feel it is time for a clean slate.
And if it turns out to be explicitly not the timeline they wished for? Will they not tune in? I get the sense that this is the insinuation made elsewhere, and I find that possibility baffling.
No matter how explicit any mentions are, there are those who absolutely will not accept them under any circumstances.
Even if, as has just happened, the producer of the damn show says it's in the prime timeline. Some fans refuse to believe it. I have no explanation for this stubbornness.
Even if, as has just happened, the producer of the damn show says it's in the prime timeline. Some fans refuse to believe it. I have no explanation for this stubbornness.
No matter how explicit any mentions are, there are those who absolutely will not accept them under any circumstances.
Even if, as has just happened, the producer of the damn show says it's in the prime timeline. Some fans refuse to believe it. I have no explanation for this stubbornness.
Why do you care how I choose to interpret the material?
^ No, you're right. Kirk will be in his twenties so I'm sure he's long since graduated.
In fact at the time of DSC, Kirk is probably on the Farragut, with the associated disaster just waiting to happen...
In fact at the time of DSC, Kirk is probably on the Farragut, with the associated disaster just waiting to happen...
Not necessarily Prime. Just not Kelvin timeline.
No matter how explicit any mentions are, there are those who absolutely will not accept them under any circumstances.
Even if, as has just happened, the producer of the damn show says it's in the prime timeline. Some fans refuse to believe it. I have no explanation for this stubbornness.
Just like how George Lucas can tell us that the prequels are part of the same continuity as the good films, and some fans refuse to accept stupid garbage from a man determined to shoot himself in the foot.
Doesn't make it untrue, just means you disagree with it.
Even if you personally don't consider Discovery or the Star Wars PT as part of their respective franchises, they still are, that is a fact.
If we take Lucas' word for granted we might as well believe him when he claims there's a fourth Indiana Jones film.
One cannot disagree with truth.
There's no truth involved - just opinions.
And if I think that Kirk is a Denebian slime devil, well, that's my opinion, too.
Did I stumble in to the "Religion" thread? We're now discussing truth? O_o
Starfleet could be invaded by Saucermen from Mars and I'd watch it.
Are you a time traveler from the Beforetime? Because the new President would like to have a word with you.
Similar threads
