• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Your thoughts on the end of the DVD releases in sight

I also figure once all the available stories are out on DVD they will go and blue ray them. *shudder*

The problem with that is translating 1970s-era videotape to high definition, along with film inserts for which the original elements no longer exist, doesn't work at present. If you want to see how it looks when they try, there are Confidential episodes on the Blu-ray of the new series that include clips from classic-era episodes, and the images suck. (If you have the Series 5 set, one of the Confidentials relating to the Silurian 2-parter if I recall has clips from either The Silurians or The Sea Devils, I forget which.)

One of the (many) reasons why DVD has survived rather than going the way of vinyl is that Blu-ray and high-def are not friendly formats for a lot of older TV shows. Anything shot on videotape, or on lower-grade film, can't - under current practices - be transferred to Blu-ray in an acceptable manner. Now I happen to be of the opinion that they'll figure out a workaround someday, though it may be a "reverse-VidFIRE" process where the videos are all transferred to film or something. But right now that's the main reason why a lot of older series aren't (and won't likely be) on Blu-ray. If a show was shot entirely on film, that's a different case (I'm assuming a Blu-ray release of, say, the Emma Peel era of The Avengers is not far off; ditto Secret Agent/Danger Man and The Saint and the Gerry Anderson shows, but we're not likely to ever see the shot-on-video-then-kinescoped Honor Blackman era of The Avengers on BD).

Right now, the only classic series story that could be put out on Blu-ray is Spearhead from Space because it was shot entirely on film. So could the 1996 TV movie. Everything else is either all-video or kinescoped (1963-1969), a hybrid of video and film (1970-1985) or shot completely on video (1986-1989 and occasional Tom Baker stories). I am assuming that when Pyramids of Mars was included as a bonus with the DVD and Blu-ray UK release of Sarah Jane Adventures Series 4 that it was just a straight DVD and not upconverted.

I was hoping that when the original 1960s Twilight Zone was released to Blu-ray last year that its half-dozen shot-on-video episodes would indicate the "video barrier" had been broken for BD. But I'm told they didn't turn out very well.

So when it comes to Classic Who and most of the other old TV shows I enjoy watching, especially classic sitcoms like All in the Family, I expect to have to stick with not only DVD, but also Plasma TV, as my brother and I did some extensive research before I took the HDTV plunge, and plasma in my opinion is the only TV format that renders lower-res images (broadcast, DVD, even VHS) in an acceptable manner. LED and LCD are fantastic for Blu-ray and HD broadcasts; but if you like watching anything else, prepare to be disappointed (friend of mine made the mistake and said she was very disappointed she couldn't watch her favorite shows anymore because they looked terrible; I recommended she swap out for a plasma).

Alex
 
^^ Agree with what you say about plasma TVs. I have one and can attest to that first hand.

Mr Awe
 
I hope they do NOT rerelease the series on blue ray as it would be robbing people who already own the DVDs of their hard-earned money. That's what I think anyway.
 
How would it be robbing anyone of their hard-earned money? No-one is under any obligation to up-grade.

Did the DVD releases rob the people who bought earlier VHS releases?
 
It is robbing in a small sense if the Blu-Ray sets feature exclusive features not found on the DVD sets, which has practically become the norm for films these (much to my incredible frustration and disgust). Granted I don't think this happened so much with TV sets but that is one way it would indeed be robbing viewers.
 
I'm working my way through, and enjoying, some of the classic episodes at the moment but I'm not happy with the way some of the classic episodes are being released. For example I already own Spearhead from Space, but if I want to buy Terror of the Autons I have to buy it in a boxset with Spearhead. I don't mind them releasing some of the episodes in boxsets, such as the Sontaran one, but I'd also like the option to buy them on their own.
 
Most of the sets are released individually over here in America. Thank God as they are getting really expsneive and I don't always want every title that are in the sets.:techman:
 
Well I just went onto Amazon looking for a book and saw the following Doctor Who DVDs will be released over the next three months:
Doctor Who: Death to the Daleks June 18
Doctor Who: The Krotons July 2
Doctor Who: The Greatest Show in the Galaxy July 30
Doctor Who: Planet of Giants August 20

I must say that they're really belting these out. I knew about Death to the Daleks but not these other three. Some of the extras look interesting.

http://www.amazon.co.uk/Doctor-Who-...ef=sr_1_4?s=dvd&ie=UTF8&qid=1337898744&sr=1-4

http://www.amazon.co.uk/Doctor-Who-...ef=sr_1_3?s=dvd&ie=UTF8&qid=1337898981&sr=1-3

http://www.amazon.co.uk/Doctor-Who-...ef=sr_1_2?s=dvd&ie=UTF8&qid=1337898981&sr=1-2

http://www.amazon.co.uk/Doctor-Who-...ef=sr_1_1?s=dvd&ie=UTF8&qid=1337898981&sr=1-1

I've rather fallen behind, I've yet to get the Ace box set or the single volume edition of Season 6 of the current show, now it looks like I'm going to get even further behind. Ah well I suppose there's always Christmas.
 
Since I have probably less than half of the ones out, I'm not really giving a fuck - still got lots to collect.
 
Posted an earlier post saying that i wont be able to get all the classic epsiodes of dr who,i wasnt wrong,got most of them,a dozen more and i will have them all.
 
Releasing shows on Blu-Ray as SD is pointless; just stick with DVD!
So shows that will never be up to HD quility should never be released on it. So what happens once DVD goes away? SD contant should never be realeased again? That's rather stupid and narrow-minded.

Well, since all Blu-Ray players are backward compatible with DVDs, there's simply no reason to put SD content on an HD format. New releases can still be on DVD, which would make them available to a wider audience than just those who do Blu-Ray. (And there's some who suspect that Blu-Ray won't last long anyway because it will quickly be supplanted by online downloading.)
 
Releasing shows on Blu-Ray as SD is pointless; just stick with DVD!
So shows that will never be up to HD quility should never be released on it. So what happens once DVD goes away? SD contant should never be realeased again? That's rather stupid and narrow-minded.

Well, since all Blu-Ray players are backward compatible with DVDs, there's simply no reason to put SD content on an HD format. New releases can still be on DVD, which would make them available to a wider audience than just those who do Blu-Ray. (And there's some who suspect that Blu-Ray won't last long anyway because it will quickly be supplanted by online downloading.)

That's country dependent; New Zealand has shocking internet speeds and prices, and if all movies suddenly went Internet only many Kiwis wouldn't be watching many movies at all... :)
 
I have nearly all the of the dvd's released so far, I'll be glad when I can stop forking out for them.

Once they are done I would rather see some restoration work done on the missing episodes.

I would prefer there be new animations rather than endless re-releases with different extras.
 
So shows that will never be up to HD quility should never be released on it. So what happens once DVD goes away? SD contant should never be realeased again? That's rather stupid and narrow-minded.

Well, since all Blu-Ray players are backward compatible with DVDs, there's simply no reason to put SD content on an HD format. New releases can still be on DVD, which would make them available to a wider audience than just those who do Blu-Ray. (And there's some who suspect that Blu-Ray won't last long anyway because it will quickly be supplanted by online downloading.)

That's country dependent; New Zealand has shocking internet speeds and prices, and if all movies suddenly went Internet only many Kiwis wouldn't be watching many movies at all... :)

Whilst the UK might be slightly better if you live in a rural location your speeds at best are upto 8mb, more urbanised areas have upto 20mb, cable/fibre optic so they have far faster speeds so DL is an option to them.

So going to DL only, is actually reducing the potentil the potential customer base.

As for SD quality only stuff being released on BR, there is a reason why it could be justified, BR discs hold far more inofrmation that DVD's. So whilst an entire season could take upto six discs to release on DVD's it might only take 2 BR discs. Which means less packaging, fewer discs which could make it cheaper to manufacture. i.e more profit.
 
^yes but do you get that 4-6 on an upto 8 exchange or on an upto 20 exchange?

4-6 on an upto 8 exchange is a good speed, on upto 20 it's not stellar but decent enough.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top