Whois the best star trek doctor

[Tcsfan]

Lets say you just woke up in a sick bay you look around what st doctor would you want to see

 

[BillJ]

Bones

 

[Mr. Laser Beam]

As far as qualifications go, I'd say all of them. Every CMO we've seen in a Trek series has been an excellent doctor.

Bedside manner, or general personality, though? I'd have to say Phlox. He seems the friendliest of all Trek doctors so far.

 

[Tcsfan]

I like phlox he use to be my fav but I like crusher now she is motherly but phlox is funny Idk I would say phlox because then I could meet a Vulcan T'pol and I could meet capt.Archer

 

[sbk1234]

As far as qualifications go, I'd say all of them. Every CMO we've seen in a Trek series has been an excellent doctor.

Bedside manner, or general personality, though? I'd have to say Phlox. He seems the friendliest of all Trek doctors so far.

Probably this. However my personal favorite would probably be Bashier. He also has the benefit of a genetically engineered intellect to aid his medical expertise. I wouldn't mind that trait in my physician.

 

[sonak]

EMH.


Funniest, and the smartest and most capable due to having a built-in database of medical knowledge


(For those saying Phlox you'd better hope your medical issue isn't genetic, he might think that the voodoo gods of evolution have slated you for death)

 

[ILOVETREK1701]

Either EMH or Dr.Crusher

EMH has so many capabilitys and is a great doctor, but iffy bedside manner.

Dr.Crusher is a fair doctor but has the best bed side manner.

 

[horatio83]

Lets say you just woke up in a sick bay you look around what st doctor would you want to see

Probably Crusher, yet from a dramatic point of view she is the most uninteresting character among the five.

 

[Tcsfan]

You know what I changed my mind I would not even care I would fain because I would b so excited I would be in space it would be awesome

 

[BillJ]

(For those saying Phlox you'd better hope your medical issue isn't genetic, he might think that the voodoo gods of evolution have slated you for death)

 

[LS31]

EMH.

The EMH Mark I was first activated in 2371, and was programmed with 5 million possible treatments from the collective information of 2000 medical references and the experience of 47 individual medical officers.

Can't really beat that.

 

[BennyRussel]

Bones

^
Do you really want to be treated by a doctor that was best known for pronouncing people dead?

I'd take my chances with Dr. Johnny Fever first.

Give me Beverly, then a tie between Julian and EMH.

I like Phlox, but waking up after a trauma and looking up at that mug might throw me for a loop.

And please no Pulaski.

Honorable mentions to Drs. Ogawa and Chapel.

 

[T'Preea]

Most definitely Bones. Of course, in matters of feminine issues, I'd prefer Crusher.

 

[Enterprise is Great]

McCoy's the best. Dr. Crusher in my fantasies.

 

[FreddyE]

All BUT the EMH....that would be like having my boyfriend as my doctor. Why? Well..his hairstyle is the same as the doctors and his personality has big similarities to the EHMs (and Sevens too). ;-)

 

[bbailey861]

I think your best chance of survival would be with the EMH - but if he was out of the equation, as much as I love Dr. Leonard H. McCoy, I would pick Dr. Beverly Crusher just because of the extra years of medical advancements between the TOS and TNG eras.

 

[sbk1234]

For the purposes of this poll, I assumed all of the doctors having access to the same medical knowledge, since their time range is something like 200 years between them.

 

[RandyS]

And please no Pulaski.

Agreed. And no Phlox with his damn leeches.

LEECHES? In the 22nd century?? What the hell were they thinking??

My vote goes to:

Bones
Crusher
Bashir
Doc.

 

[SecretlyMrsKirk]

Dr. McCoy. He makes me laugh like crazy, he has those gorgeous eyelashes and princess-y blue eyes. *squee* Dr. Crusher is a good doctor, I suppose, but I don't really like her as a character. The doctor from Voyager...Hmm. I don't remember too much about him, but I suppose I wouldn't mind him treating me if he had to.

 

[Harbinger]

Bones is probably the best doc followed by "Joe" the EMH.