Who is the better captain Picard or Jellico

Discussion in 'Star Trek: The Next Generation' started by Gabriel, Jan 9, 2019.

?

Who is the better Captain

Poll closed Jan 27, 2019.
  1. Picard

    58.3%
  2. Jellico

    10.4%
  3. Both

    20.8%
  4. Neither

    10.4%
  1. Makarov

    Makarov Fleet Captain Fleet Captain

    Joined:
    Jul 9, 2013
    Or Q takes one look at Jellico and wipes out humanity because there's no joy in anything :lol:
     
    Cutie McWhiskers likes this.
  2. Gabriel

    Gabriel Captain Red Shirt

    Joined:
    Dec 15, 2018
    Pretty sure about that
     
  3. Gabriel

    Gabriel Captain Red Shirt

    Joined:
    Dec 15, 2018
    I doubt Q thinks like Riker.
     
    Admiral2 likes this.
  4. Doc Mugatu

    Doc Mugatu Commander Red Shirt

    Joined:
    Jul 22, 2018
    I think there should have been a fifth option for the poll, "Situational." That's my answer anyway. Truth be told the worst thing that could happen to any organization would be to have a stockpile of just one type of leader or, in this case, starship captains therefore to ask which one is better is predicated on an invalid proposition. Picard, I would say, is better for a mission of exploration and diplomacy. Captain Jellico would be preferred in the maintenance and enforcement of order. Jellico would be better at fighting a war while Picard would be better at negotiating it's end. In most instances being decisive is better than being right. Jellico is more of a disciplinarian while Picard is less so. Neither is necessarily right or wrong. So long as the captain's are consistent and uniform in their respective approaches both could be, and probably would be, just as effective in their governance of their ships.
     
    Gabriel likes this.
  5. Voth commando1

    Voth commando1 Commodore Commodore

    Joined:
    Oct 4, 2016
    Location:
    In a sub-sub atomic universe with kittens
    Jellico striked me as the sort of all business captain. He needed to get the job done, and he didn't have time to care for what the crew thought of him.

    A captain like Jellico would indeed be the sort of captain in the long run to have crews transfer, quit, burn out, or otherwise leave. He doesn't inspire loyalty or devotion.

    Jellico would probably respond to that by saying "I don't expect the crew to love me, or even like me, I expect them to do their jobs, and if they can't handle that, they can transfer to a different ship or leave the service, they can think about me or feel about me whatever they want, so long as they do their jobs I don't care about their private feelings toward me."

    He's that sort of leader. And in some situations you want a captain who is willing to get the job done even if his subordinates despise or resent him and who doesn't care if his decisions offend or upset people. And in some cases that's the sort of captain you absolutely don't want. The sort of situation where that sort of captain causes the crew to waver, fail, retreat, mutiny, or otherwise break.
     
  6. Doc Mugatu

    Doc Mugatu Commander Red Shirt

    Joined:
    Jul 22, 2018
    I disagree and feel your assessment is short-sighted and unrealistic. Jellico, based on what we were given in The Chain of Command Pts I & II, , may not have demanded or cared if his crew "loved" him but he did conduct himself in a manner that would inspire respect (and that I daresay is something he would have cared about). A great many in a service love the order and discipline and would thrive under the command of someone like Jellico. The Vulcans, for example, would more than likely embrace his no-nonsense style. Just as there is no one preferred style of command (though there are certain characteristics that all good captains would share - though to differing degrees) there are also a healthy variety of crew members. Again, a great many are inspired by a stern commander who is decisive, consistent, competent, just and who lets them know exactly what is expected of them. In fact, I believe, in an actual quasi-military service organization, more would prefer a Jellico especially if they are still green.
     
    Gabriel and Admiral2 like this.
  7. Voth commando1

    Voth commando1 Commodore Commodore

    Joined:
    Oct 4, 2016
    Location:
    In a sub-sub atomic universe with kittens
    I disagree. Jellico didn't seem to care about the crew's opinions. Did he have vulnerabilities yes, and did he have things structured? Yes.

    But he isn't inspiring, Picard is the sort of captain the crew will follow, in war and peace, in mundane crises, and crazy anomalies. Jellico doesn't inspire that devotion. Picard will do whatever it takes for his crew, Jellico isn't like that. Jellico doesn't inspire that sort of faith.

    Is Jellico capable in the traditional military sense? Yes. But he doesn't have the shining paragon of moral virtue and intellectual openness and dare I say bravery that Picard does. Jellico doesn't inspire people to put themselves out on limb for him. Picard does. People will sing Picard's praises becuase he is lenient and empathetic, but that doesn't hinder his effectiveness.
     
    Makarov likes this.
  8. Doc Mugatu

    Doc Mugatu Commander Red Shirt

    Joined:
    Jul 22, 2018
    One might think that but, pragmatically speaking, leniency and empathy in commanding officers, especially in times of crisis, inspires doubt, relaxed standards and a breakdown of command. Jellico was not much different than Captain Kirk and Kirk is a far better captain than Picard.
     
    Gabriel and Admiral2 like this.
  9. Voth commando1

    Voth commando1 Commodore Commodore

    Joined:
    Oct 4, 2016
    Location:
    In a sub-sub atomic universe with kittens
    I disagree with you on the Kirk point. Though that is subjective I suppose.

    Picard is lenient and empathetic but he isn't soft in that he lets offenses pass or that he doesn't expect the job be done.
     
    Makarov likes this.
  10. Gabriel

    Gabriel Captain Red Shirt

    Joined:
    Dec 15, 2018
    No Kirk was better and jellico are a like in a way.
    I mean Kirk wasn’t exactly like jellico but they are similar. Although this is just my opinion though. Frankly I disagree with janeway saying that Kirk and his crew would not be able to operate be in the 24th century starfleet. While Kirk is not my favorite captains he has shown many times that he is a great captain.
     
  11. Voth commando1

    Voth commando1 Commodore Commodore

    Joined:
    Oct 4, 2016
    Location:
    In a sub-sub atomic universe with kittens
    Erhm, no I really do think Picard was the better captain.
     
    Makarov likes this.
  12. Gabriel

    Gabriel Captain Red Shirt

    Joined:
    Dec 15, 2018
    I’m assuming you mean jellico vs picard (in which in some instances you are right) however if you mean Kirk vs picard.
    No, Kirk has saved the federation and earth on many occasions and is a captain most would want to serve on. Kirk has shown that he can balance diplomacy, exploration, and defense better than most.
     
    Cutie McWhiskers likes this.
  13. Discofan

    Discofan Rear Admiral Fleet Captain

    Joined:
    Feb 23, 2018
    Location:
    Discofan
    When Kurn, Worf's Klingon Brother, brought a little discipline and even severity on board it didn't seem to displease Picard in the least, in fact, he was all for it. If he had time to think about it, instead of his mission, Picard would have approved of Jellico's style of command. I am pretty sure of it.
     
    Gabriel and Cutie McWhiskers like this.
  14. Makarov

    Makarov Fleet Captain Fleet Captain

    Joined:
    Jul 9, 2013
    Picard already seemed displeased with Jellico's judgment of Riker. He already rubbed Picard the wrong way by tossing that book at him and telling him he's not coming back.

    I don't think the engineering crew would be more disciplined after the round the clock changes, they would just be burnt out and possibly needing more time to get up to speed working with the new configurations.
     
  15. Cutie McWhiskers

    Cutie McWhiskers Commodore Commodore

    Joined:
    May 18, 2017
    Location:
    The clinic located by the Q Continuum
    True, Picard wasn't pleased with Jellico's treatment of Riker - observation and personal friendship being partial factors. Doesn't mean Picard would disapprove of Jellico based on his overall record, despite occasional differences?
     
    Gabriel likes this.
  16. Gabriel

    Gabriel Captain Red Shirt

    Joined:
    Dec 15, 2018
    Engineers probably have been having to work around the clock sometimes since WWI. If they can’t handle it then they shouldn’t wear the uniform. And by the way starfleet crew seem fine when they have to pull double shifts every now and then.
     
    Last edited: Feb 11, 2019 at 2:40 PM
  17. Nyotarules

    Nyotarules Rear Admiral Rear Admiral

    Joined:
    Jan 20, 2016
    Location:
    London
    Comparing the viewers' perception of Picard who had 6 seasons to get know the character to Jellico who shows up under potential war scenario for 2 episodes is an extremely weak comparison. I think Jellico is closer to TOS Kirk, who in some episodes made an order and expected it to be carried out, said order was not open to discussion.
    I think McCoy being almost downright subordinate towards the Captain (Kirk was his friend who gave him too much rope IMO) and the XO (just because said XO Spock, was half human) has probably given the audience a wrong perception of discipline on a semi military space ship.
     
    Doc Mugatu and Gabriel like this.
  18. Discofan

    Discofan Rear Admiral Fleet Captain

    Joined:
    Feb 23, 2018
    Location:
    Discofan
    I don't like that in the episode(s) we were sort of urged to think like Riker when he said and did all the wrong things!
    I wanted to look the writer(s) in the eyes and ask "Are you kidding me?"
     
    Nyotarules and Gabriel like this.
  19. Mojochi

    Mojochi Rear Admiral Rear Admiral

    Joined:
    Aug 18, 2007
    You see though, all of that judgment is based on a singular example of how Jellico had to work, under this one & only circumstance. We don't know that his decisions here or even his posture are at all what he does under normal operations. It's what he & perhaps his superiors concluded was the simplest way to undergo this particularly set of conditions, but it's entirely possible that back on the Cairo, they find him entirely dissimilar to what he's having to be here, because he is in just as uncompromising a situation as Picard is.

    Their missions are, by all rights, both impossible, except for the thinnest margin. He could very well be executing things along that narrow line, because anything else fails. People only assume he is doing what he's doing by choice or preference, which makes him dislikable. If he isn't though... then he becomes a very sympathetic character imho
     
    Gabriel likes this.
  20. JesterFace

    JesterFace Fleet Captain Fleet Captain

    Joined:
    Jun 1, 2014
    Location:
    Suomi Finland
    This thread should just fade away.

    Like it has been mentioned before, there's no way to compare Picard and Jellico as captains.
    Picard was in every episode for 7 years, Jellico was in 2 episodes.
    That could be the end of that discussion.
    Over and out.

    And now I just bumped this thread up.. oh no.