• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Which Season is the strongest?

Best Season?

  • Chapter 1: Where no Trek has gone before...

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Chapter 2: What's on the other side of that Wormhole?

    Votes: 1 1.9%
  • Chapter 3: Enter the Dominion

    Votes: 2 3.8%
  • Chapter 4: Enter the Klingons

    Votes: 7 13.2%
  • Chapter 5: The Twilight Hour

    Votes: 18 34.0%
  • Chapter 6: Dominion War

    Votes: 18 34.0%
  • Chapter 7: Alpha Quadrant makes a stand

    Votes: 7 13.2%

  • Total voters
    53
All this time, I thought DS9 nuts liked the series because it was darker and more intricate. Now I see that it's just because there were more explosions and space battles...

Personally, I prefer the later seasons because I find they are darker and more intricate than the first three.
There's actually not that much action, explosions etc. in later seasons as some people seem to think. Yes, you have some episodes that are heavy on action, but even in episodes like "Sacrifice of Angels" most of the run time is devoted to character development and telling a story.
One of the things I noticed about later season episodes was that they just kept getting better at handling several storylines at a time. When the show was at it's best, it would effortlessly juggle three or four storylines without breaking a sweat, and it was sheer pleasure to watch.
IMHO the earlier seasons just weren't adept at that. In general, I felt they were in fact often more simplistic in that they would use the common TNG A/B story formula in which those two plots often wouldn't even connect. Later on, the storylines would overlap more often (I'm not saying they never did A/B later on, they did but not quite as often). This would contribute to greater complexity and allow them explore more difficult subjects and deal with the characters in greater depth.
There's many more things IMHO that put the later seasons head and shoulders above the earlier ones. But rest assured, it's not 'splosions and stuff like that :).
 
Basically a coin toss between 3, 5 and 6. Can you toss a coin between three things? No? Well fuck it, that's what it is ;)

Voted 5 because I find it the most consistent of the three, although the more stand-out episodes are in 3 and 6.
 
One of the things I noticed about later season episodes was that they just kept getting better at handling several storylines at a time. When the show was at it's best, it would effortlessly juggle three or four storylines without breaking a sweat, and it was sheer pleasure to watch.

Thats why I liked the later seasons too, and why I'm getting them on dVD before the earlier seasons - and I would leave the early seasons if I wasn't obsessed with having a full set again.

The use of recurring characters was also way better than the other shows, which only got better as the seasons went on and really helped set up both sides of the war with regular appearances from Weyoun/Damar near the end.

It did get a little strange though as Jake was a regular cast members but Nog, Martok etc got a lot more story and screen time.
 
All this time, I thought DS9 nuts liked the series because it was darker and more intricate. Now I see that it's just because there were more explosions and space battles...

I cannot go along with this reasoning. The final three seasons were darker than the earlier seasons. Can you honestly see Sisko giving a speech like the one at the end of In the Pale Moonlight back in season the early seasons?

Season 1 was a TNG clone with only three great episode; Emissary, Duet and In the Hands of the Prophets.

Season 2 was much better and was a very good season. The mid-season slump that effected most other seasons of the show wasn't as noticeable here and it had a great run of episodes from Blood Oath right up until the end. Probably the second strongest season, but it was hampered by the fact that they didn't really have a plan other than teasing about the Dominion.

Season 3 doesn't have the same consistency, but the writers have a better handle on the characters. There's some great episodes, but a lot of the episodes were average.

Season 4 lost the plot, literally. The network wanted them to shake things up so they went the route of conflict with the Klingons and stopped focusing on the Dominion. It was fun at the time, but when you watch the series as a whole you realise that season 4 was going the wrong way.

Season 5 quickly got things back on track. They tied up the Klingon war, and for the first time they had a real plan for the season. They knew they wanted to end the season by plunging the Federation into war with the Dominion and they carried through on that plan very well. What's more, there was no mid-season slump, the middle part of the season was incredibly strong.

Season 6 had the great six episode arc, and then stopped. The show was darker, the characters were under more pressure and they wrote some great episodes along the way, but the rest of the season didn't have much of a direction because they focused so much of their energies at the start of the season to the first six episodes.

Season 7 started out great, had a few clunkers in the middle, and then went out on a high in the 9 episode arc.

Ranking them from favourite to least favourite is simple for me: 7 > 6 > 5 > 4 > 3 > 2 > 1 :p
Ranking them by actual strength? 5 > 2 > 7 > 6 > 4 > 3 > 1
 
I thought at the time (and still think) that S6 should have had the Cardassian/Dominion spend the entire season on DS9/Terok Nor and the Feds fighting them from off station. that would have resulted in some incredible and awesome storytelling. that 6-epsode Occupation Arc was one of the best things to happen on trek, not to mention DS9. imagine the wondrous things they could have done if they'd run with it. unfortunately, they copped out. oh well.
 
I thought at the time (and still think) that S6 should have had the Cardassian/Dominion spend the entire season on DS9/Terok Nor and the Feds fighting them from off station. that would have resulted in some incredible and awesome storytelling. that 6-epsode Occupation Arc was one of the best things to happen on trek, not to mention DS9. imagine the wondrous things they could have done if they'd run with it. unfortunately, they copped out. oh well.


Interesting!!

Still, I felt if they (starfleet) was away for a long time from the station you would start to lose the connections with the primary characters.
 
I thought at the time (and still think) that S6 should have had the Cardassian/Dominion spend the entire season on DS9/Terok Nor and the Feds fighting them from off station. that would have resulted in some incredible and awesome storytelling. that 6-epsode Occupation Arc was one of the best things to happen on trek, not to mention DS9. imagine the wondrous things they could have done if they'd run with it. unfortunately, they copped out. oh well.

They didn't cop out, that's what Ira Behr and others wanted to do but the network wouldn't let them because they thought it would confuse viewers. :rolleyes: First they were told they had to recapture the station in one episode, then they were told they could have four, but when they began writing they realised they needed five episodes and eventually they made six.
 
yes, I don't mean the writers, I meant Paramount. I know the writers wanted it.

Ezri, if they'd written it the way they wrote those 6 episodes, the connections wit the primary/regular characters would be intact, I believe.
 
Personally, my take on the series is this:

Season 1 was the weakest, I can't remember too much of Season 2 to make a good judgment of it.

Starting with Season 3, I felt that season had a lot of strong episodes, but also a lot of very weak episodes. I find myself rewatching a lot of Season 3 but also skipping the most.

Season 4 IMO may have been the most consistent as far as quality. I usually rewatch most of this entire season because front to back there are so many "rewatchable" epsiodes. The only ones I don't particularly care for are Rejoined, Little Green Men, and The Muse. Everything else is pretty solid, even if the main story arc is a little "off."

Season 5 was decent, but overrated IMO. Apocalypse Rising and Nor the Battle to the Strong were excellent in finishng off the Klingon arc, but the rest of the first half of Season 5 was mediocre to me. Things Past is a good flashback episode, and Rapture was decent, but the rest of it was just throwing in crap to pass the time until the Dominion threat becomes imminent. Season 5 really took off at "For the Uniform" and was pretty excellent until the end, except for remember that terrible disk with A Simple Investigation, Business as Usual and some other crap.

Season 6 was probably the biggest hit or miss season of all. The Occupation Arc is easily the best thing in the series, and you can pick any evening and just have an easy 5 hour marathon with it because it is so good. Other than that, this season was pretty weak. It was more like Occupation Arc + Inquisition + In the Pale Moonlight + Far Beyond the Stars.

Season 7 was only consistent because of the great final saga, which was pretty excellent, even though the set-up is very long (come on, Penumbra and To Death Do Us Part are kind of weak). There was a strong beginning to it because of the Sisko storyline, but other than that its like 1st 3 Episodes + Siege of AR-558 + Last 10 Episodes.

So in conclusion, my favorite series is either Season 4 because its so consistently good (and the first season were Sisko is bald since thats when he became 100% badass), and Season 6 because it had the best stand-out episodes even though the rest of the eps sucked.
 
Season 5. Everything felt like it was coming together, and it was a great transition from the Klingon situation to the Dominion and the alliance with Cardassia. There were so many phenomenal episodes this season like Nor the Battle to the Strong, Trials and Tribble-ations, Things Past, In Purgatory's Shadow/By Inferno's Light, Ties of Blood and Water, In the Cards and Call To Arms.

After that, my order from favorite to least favorite:

Season 4
Season 2
Season 6
Season 3
Season 7
Season 1
 
Season six. I don't care about the clunkers. The opening six-episode arc is fantastic, and it also has three of my favorite episodes of the series: "Waltz," "Far Beyond the Stars," and "In The Pale Moonlight."
 
There all good, even S1 w/ Move Along Away From Here and Never Come Back.

My favorite still stands w/S4.

WoW and The Visitor (in a row) rocks the house.
 
If we're doing order of preference, then the "correct sequence" is:

Season 5
Season 7
Season 2
Season 6
Season 4
Season 3
Season 1
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top