What would you want the plot of Star Trek 4 to be?

[ISS Enterprise]

What I meant was that the Enterprise wouldn't beat up on an inferior ship. Using another ship as a punching bag is kind of against what we are shown Starfleet to be.

Was just being tongue

 

[ISS Enterprise]

And cheek. Phone cut me off lol

 

[saddestmoon]

What I meant was that the Enterprise wouldn't beat up on an inferior ship. Using another ship as a punching bag is kind of against what we are shown Starfleet to be.

I didn't say anything about the enterprise attacking an inferior ship?

Adversary starship = bad guys/villian/antagonist (not inferior in comparison to the Ent-A).

Ent-A showcasing why it's the most advanced Fed starship.

Nothing inherently anti-Trek in that.

For example: Ent-A going 'hammer n tongs' at a stronger non-Fed starship, who is threatening planetary destruction, etc, etc - to show exactly why the Ent-A is the most advanced Federation vessel (as eluded to in Beyond).


But yeah - the Ent-A using an inferior starship as a punch bag, and unleashing on it, in the manner you are inferring, would be anti-Trek (but it's not what I was inferring).

Edit: re-read my post again please...

 

[M'Sharak]

and right wing populists

Or left wing extremists, breaking windows, starting fires and shouting down anyone they personally don't agree with.

Kirk: "Set phaser banks on wide area stun."

@Tenacity , I shouldn't need to remind you that this is not the appropriate forum for bringing out real-world political axes to grind, but consider yourself reminded anyway.

If something can be reasonably discussed within the context of an actual or hypothetical Star Trek story, then there's room for it here. If it's going to be straight-up Whatabout-style clapback, with no regard whatsoever to Trek, then there are places where you can do that, and none of them are this forum.

 

[M-Red]

Why wasn't that warning directed at both posters instead of just @Tenacity?

The person he quoted was the first poster to grind a political axe.

Hold everyone accountable in the same way according to the rules and not your personal bias.

 

[M-Red]

To the topic --

Kirk, Klingons and the Doomsday Machine

 

[M'Sharak]

Why wasn't that warning directed at both posters instead of just @Tenacity?

The person he quoted was the first poster to grind a political axe.

Hold everyone accountable in the same way according to the rules and not your personal bias.

Comments re: that to PM, please. You know the procedure.

 

[ISS Enterprise]

Why wasn't that warning directed at both posters instead of just @Tenacity?

The person he quoted was the first poster to grind a political axe.

Hold everyone accountable in the same way according to the rules .

Agree 100%

I read Hythlodeus post as political and found Tenacity's response funny

 

[Tenacity]

@Tenacity

Understood.

 

[CorporalClegg]

What I've always wanted:

An Alien style horror/suspense film where Enterprise comes across a derelict cube the slowly "comes online" over the course of the whole film. But never becomes fully operational.

Or maybe to break up the film a little, I have the cube discovered in the neutral zone, and the first part of the film is sort of a 'chase' with the Rommies. The second half of the film would leave Spock, Sulu and Uhura on the E to "negotiate" with the Rommies, while Kirk, Scotty, and Jaylah are aboard the cube fighting off awoken drones.

 

[M'Sharak]

Agree 100%

I read Hythlodeus post as political and found Tenacity's response funny

But this isn't a comment to PM. Please try to do better.

 

[Nerys Myk]

Romulans and a time jump to 2265.

 

[donners22]

Unfortunately the writer The City on the edge of forever owns the rights to tge guardian and not sure how much he would be rent for a movie lol.....

He actually offered to be involved in the writing of one of the new films a few years back, as he has great respect for Abrams.

 

[Borg King]

A film where war with the Klingons is about to erupt. After Into Darkness a war seemed inevitable. Maybe bring in Kelvin versions of Kor, Koloth and Kang and bring in Rand and Chapel as well

 

[Dales]

The borg.

I would also like for the film to feel very intense.

As much as I loved beyond. it did not have the intense atmosphere of the first two films.

 

[psCargile]

Star Trek: Just Jayla.

 

[CorporalClegg]

A film where war with the Klingons is about to erupt. After Into Darkness a war seemed inevitable. Maybe bring in Kelvin versions of Kor, Koloth and Kang and bring in Rand and Chapel as well

Since it's pretty clear Discovery is going to heavily involve Klingons, I suspect the films will look somewhere else.

 

[dahj]

Since it's pretty clear Discovery is going to heavily involve Klingons, I suspect the films will look somewhere else.

Different looking Klingons?

 

[BillJ]

Since it's pretty clear Discovery is going to heavily involve Klingons, I suspect the films will look somewhere else.

I have a feeling this version of the film franchise is dead.

 

[pst]

I have a feeling this version of the film franchise is dead.

i think that notion has been throughly debated here and the verdict is:

prolly.