• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

What would you change about this series?

1. Wipe the slate clean. A complete reboot. No "alternate timelines" or anything.
2. Do what ever the hell you want with the show.
3. Watch the Internet burn.

Fuck yeah.

I'd do a total reboot the prime timeline would have no impact or relevance, neither would any of the canon. This wouldn't be some alternate timeline, it would be THE timeline. I'd keep the Vulcans, Klingons, Romulans and established races and keep or change stuff as i saw fit. I'd keep it set in 2265 and I'd keep it on the Enterprise.

The Premise would be that it is the year 2265, The Federation has begun exploration and colonisation of the Tethys Expanse. It's vast, thousands of star systems, thousands of worlds and alien cultures and unknown dangers lying in wait. The Enterprise has been assigned to the region on an ongoing mission of exploration and to provide support to the fledgling federation colonies in the region. However the Romulans and The Klingons have also entered the Tethys Expanse and begun colonisation efforts of their own. Conflict with both cultures is common and the Federation is a hairs breadth away from war with both. There is also rumours of something else out there, an ancient yet advanced race called the Tholians, who are thought to be a myth. They have slept for centuries but the encroachment into their territory awakens them and what they find happening to their space does not make them happy. It would be dark yet hopeful. The characters would not be perfect and wouldn't always make the right choice. For the most part though they would always try to do their best and represent the ideals of the federation.

The Enterprise will explore, protect and go where no one has gone before.

Crew:

- I'd make Kirk a woman who would have the sex with a dude every time they went to a planet. Lady Kirk would still be able to throw styrofoam rocks at Gorn and judo flip, judo chop and judo kick the bad guy of the week
- Spock would still be a dude, first officer and science officer
- Uhura would be the tactical/security officer
- Sulu would still be helmsman I'd make him gay as a shout out to takei
- Scotty would still be scotty
- McCoy would still be McCoy but I'd make him older and maybe a bit more of a paternal figure
- Chekov would get replaced by Lt. Arex

USS Enterprise

I'd stick with her being a 20 year old ship. The old girl has seen a lot, been on plenty of adventures and been in plenty of battles. The design would be updated to 2017 standards, but she would not be anywhere near as flashy or overpowered as the Enterprise from 2009 Trek. This Enterprise is an old workhorse. The interiors would probably be similar to those we see on discovery but with a slightly brighter but still mellow colour palatte. The interiors would probably also be a little 'unpolished' as to depict the notion that the ship is aged. The Enterprise would not be the flagship but she would be one of the most famous ships in Starfleet. The constitution class is pretty revered but is slowly making way for the new Ulysses Class battleships and ShirKahr class explorers.

The Klingons

They'd have ridges, be bald, probably similar to the discovery Klingons in terms of look, the makeup wouldn't be as restrictive as that used for the Discovery Klingons. In terms of culture they are a warrior culture but much more introspective. Honor is still highly important to them. They believe that war and and aggressive action toward other cultures is a favour. If the Klingons declare war on you, it's because they think you are worthy and deserve to die at the hands of a klingon. They would still hate romulans.

The Romulans

Basically North Korea. Paranoid and isolationist but a powderkeg waiting to go off.

I'd write more but this post is too long already. Long story short I'd do some more stuff that would probably piss off purists. I would then sit back and nourish myself on the rage, hate and salty tears that would no doubt ensue from the butthurt
 
Last edited:
Start over by making all these episodes a dream sequence. Going back to the series opener on that arid planet. They get hit by the storm and have been unconscious, and this has all been a dream/premonition.
Once recovered off the surface, they begin new adventures, without stupid mushroom drive, inappropriate hairless Klingons, lower the tech to fall in line with the time setting, or move the whole thing forward in time and keep all the new tech.
I'm sure the real writers of the show have already figured out how they're going to get out of this crazy story arc, without using unemployment benefits.
I'm looking forward to seeing this story work it's way out. Im just glad to have the option to watch it.
 
Last edited:
Each season is a new arc. So we may get something completely different for the second season. Maybe 20 years later where everything changed.
 
Better writing and concepts.

yes, please be more specific. What kind of better writing and concept you're talking about?

It is not like "the Orville" isn't it? Because I don't see that "The Orville" has better writing and concept if compared to Discovery. I don't say that it's bad, it's good at it's own. But to call it has better concept and writing than Discovery? Nah.
 
"Context is for Kings" is the perfect TOS title. I even liked Lorca's speech . Don't like "The Butcher blah blah SAVE RIPPER" it's way too long.

One thing I would change. Get your fact straight STD. Why is Burnham BLAMED for the war. She FAILED to fire. The Klingon's fired first. In fact there should be more people like Lorca who admire that she was willing to strike first to prevent a war and that she ultimately killed T'Kumva which probably disorganized the Klingons. I suspect there was an original draft where Michael did strike first and then the battle started. For some reason they changed it.

She did a subordination by "Punching" her own captain.

T'Kuvma isn't Trump though. And certainly the "torchbearer" isn't either. T'Kuvma reminds me more of Sybok and his Galactic Army of Light. T'Kuvma is a religious right wing conservative, messiah-claimant, and charismatic martial cult leader. There is little similar to Trump: a rich, powerful, celebrity and lifelong Rockefeller Republican who appeals to nationalism and populism to gain popular support. That latter part is where I think they mean to channel the MAGA phenomenon. But T'Kuvma is more like a wannabe Caliph who wants to make the Caliphate great again, than a rich, non-religious, non ideological, vain, egomaniacal, womanizing billionaire.

Maybe T'Kuvma is Osama?
 
Last edited:
I would make it so that every time someone who claims not to like the show watches it in spite of that, a subliminal implant makes them lose control of their bowels for the next 4 hours.

That's what I would change.
 
1. Wipe the slate clean. A complete reboot. No "alternate timelines" or anything.
2. Do what ever the hell you want with the show.
3. Watch the Internet burn.

Agree. Complete reboot. So they don't have to worry about the previous series canon. Just do whatever they want. They want Kirk die before he become a captain, alright. They want Spock as an Idiot? Okay with me. They want The Enterprise destroyed midway when lead by captain April? Why not. Just do whatever they want with the show. Ignore the previous series canon, and go full reboot.

What would you change about this series?

yodawide.jpg


"EVERYTHING."
Can those Everything attract more audience?
 
nothing.they are off to a good start. compelling characters and good writing. its well in its way.

maybe a little more levity.
 
Make Burnham more tolerable, read: less annoying. I'd like it if she was more like ep. 6 Burnham rather than ep. 1-5 Burnham.

The Klingons. I hate that they look more like amphibians or lizards rather than Klingons. Also, the less makeup, the better. Disco Klingons sound like they all have a speech impediment.
 
Just add hair to the Klingons. And pay better attention to what their starships look like, so they belong in a universe just a few years before Kirk.
 
Cancel it. There's no reason there has to be a new Star Trek show. The franchise is old and worn out. Time to put the old dog to sleep.
 
We had one chance and they're fu.. never mind.

The writing isn't good. It's messy. So we have no mission statement, fine. Instead we begin our journey three episodes in before we even see Discovery, instead we get one-dimensional Klingons, chanting and complaining in guttural gurgles that require subtitles. Of course the production values are so dark it's a bloody miracle we can read the subtitles. Just as we a forming a connection with characters, they die. Mind you given how amoral some of them are - who cares. When USS Discovery and Michael's new home is established there's all this implausible suspension of belief you have to swallow. A mutineer and a damaged Captain who killed his last crew are firmly being set up to save the universe by using a spore absorbing giant bug that makes a space ship.. er.. jump.. to some other.. er.. place and or er.. time. A bug and spores, right?

Meanwhile Michael is doing mental forward rolls and catching up with the Daddy of all Vulcans and non-Vulcans and half Vulcans but not the mean Vulcan who was so extreme he turned all red and imploded.

The acting is good though.
 
We had one chance and they're fu.. never mind.

Lol that rant=)

I would change it so that No one had any skills at all ... everytime they got out of trouble or fixed the warpdrive or something it was based on randomized events that resulted in a pure luck outcome.
Also... i would delete the ship and make the show into a ds9 version of fawlty towers.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top