• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

What was "The Burn" and what caused it?

I can see the connections, but you'd want to keep the government as far away from this sort of system as possible or you risk creating a dystopia. I'm thinking this would be a positive only system, no "downvotes", like we see in that Orville episode.
Certainly so. It's just a classic "Skinner box" type society, using rewards to facilitate socially building behavior to allow for access.
 
If members of a society choose to better themselves and/or others, that's a good thing.

If people are judged, and therefore required, to do so, watch the hell out. That smacks of dictatorship. (Then again, that's exactly what China is, so I guess there's no surprise there.)

People should better others because they want to, not because they're being forced to by the State.
 
If members of a society choose to better themselves and/or others, that's a good thing.

If people are judged, and therefore required, to do so, watch the hell out.
We've never been shown what happens if someone decides to be a slacker. However, one of the founding members of the Fed already has been shown to be dictatorial. Vulcan. Tuvok goes a bit crazy over a girl, and rather than get proper counseling he's sent to have all emotion eradicated. Sybok wants to embrace emotion, and is made an outcast. If the Fed tolerates this...
 
We've never been shown what happens if someone decides to be a slacker. However, one of the founding members of the Fed already has been shown to be dictatorial. Vulcan. Tuvok goes a bit crazy over a girl, and rather than get proper counseling he's sent to have all emotion eradicated. Sybok wants to embrace emotion, and is made an outcast. If the Fed tolerates this...

Yeah we did, in Picard. Raffi was high achieving, then left Starfleet and set up a nice little house, in a nice little area, the fuck away from everyone where she can just smoke space weed every day.
 
We've never been shown what happens if someone decides to be a slacker. However, one of the founding members of the Fed already has been shown to be dictatorial. Vulcan. Tuvok goes a bit crazy over a girl, and rather than get proper counseling he's sent to have all emotion eradicated. Sybok wants to embrace emotion, and is made an outcast. If the Fed tolerates this...
IDIC as it were.
 
Those puns only work in English. Or is it Federation standard? But they don't work in Klingon. And the Fed wonders why the Klingons won't join. ChugDah hegh! Volcha va! :klingon:

Is there a Klingon translation for Preparation-H? Maybe a galactic sized suppository is all they need.

Dr. Evil Preparation H 3b.jpg
 
And from Picard, although it wasn't outright stated, it does feel that the claims of "eradicating poverty" amount to nothing more than ensuring everyone has a replicator for food and clothing and a roof to live under, even if that home is trailer sized.

But it's the "future" so her trailer probably has anti gravs and sublight engines under it.



Maybe its like social currency that China is experimenting with?

same thing in The Orville. Money has been replaced by replicators and reputation
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top