• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

what ever happened to of gods and men?

Re: DVD burn

Crewman47 said:
Just watched the first part there and I thought it was brilliant.
Brilliant! Why thanks so much!

Crewman47 said:
One other thing, not sure if we're allowed to nitpick already but when Charlie went through the Guardian shouldn't Harriman, Uhura and Checkov have stayed on the Planet as the planet is shielded against changes in the timeline instead of being integrated (I assume that's what happened to them) into there present alternate selves? I thought that was established when McCoy accidentley changed the timeeline back in the episode City on the Edge of Forever.

AJBryant said:
Yeah, I agree. That "small detail" frankly ruins the whole thing for me, as it totally changes the previously established "rules" for the thing.

Damn. I really wanted to like this, but such a basic ignorance of canon is a major annoyance.
As has been mentioned, Charlie was "running" the Guardian, so things worked a little differently. Different circumstances, different "rules". As you might have caught, Harriman and Uhura both have kind of an "alternate reality hangover". Wonder what THAT will lead to? Hrmmmm...

Crewman47 said:
Also why was the new Constitution Class Enterprise (in the oriinal timeline) designated as the Enterprise-M when, if it's only 2306, the Enterprise-B should still be around?
The 1701-B is not only still around, but it's one of the first shots of the movie. It's the ship that drops Harriman off at the 1701-M. And then promptly gets called to rescue orphans (along with all of the ships that AREN'T the museum). Hungry, cute orphans. (That's my story, and I stick to it like a tiberian bat.)

As for the -M designation, some "one megabyte should be enough for anyone" bureaucrat probably thought that -M was so far off from -B that they'd never really need it. So by the time they blow up the 1701-L (F - L all go within WEEKS of each other. Starfleet command is amazed!) they'll have to designate the next ship the 1701-Mmmmmmmmm.
 
Re: DVD burn

Crewman47 said:
One other thing, not sure if we're allowed to nitpick already but when Charlie went through the Guardian shouldn't Harriman, Uhura and Checkov have stayed on the Planet as the planet is shielded against changes in the timeline instead of being integrated (I assume that's what happened to them) into there present alternate selves? I thought that was established when McCoy accidentley changed the timeeline back in the episode City on the Edge of Forever.

Huh? :confused: If they weren't protected from the change, then they would have disappeared the moment Charlie stepped through the Guardian. But they did not. They were still on the planet after the timeline changed.
 
Re: 1701-M

I figured the M stands for museum and my other theory was that they got intergrated because it was a smaller change and they could be intergrated unlike before when it was a huge change which denied them the chance of being intergated into the timeline or maybe i should just get out more :-)
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top