What are your controversial Star Trek opinions?

[Timofnine]

I have thought about this topic very long and hard, and I probably do not have any controversial Star Trek opinions?

 

[Nyotarules]

I might change the title of this thread to 1001001’s Nyotarules True and Correct Star Trek Facts…

Fixed that for ya!

 

[Jayson1]

The catsuits are the worst costuming choice in the history and of Star Trek, beaten only perhaps by the Gorgon's outfit in "And the Children Shall Lead."

Not once they gave them color. Troi's bunny outfit looked silly and T'pol and Kira's catsuits were suppose to be military uniforms but they didn't work. The silver catsuit was sexy of course but also silly and something you can't take a character serious wearing something like that. Once they gave Seven and later T'Pol outfits that had color to them though they looked better. The high heels though was I think were a worst choice than even catsuits.

As for the worst outfit in Trek that would likely be any civilian clothes on TNG. Civilians wore some of the most absurd "futuristic" things possible, Not to mention the season 1 shirt they had Wesley Crusher wearing.

 

[Jayson1]

TOS Season 3 is better than any season of PIC and at least two seasons of DSC.

As much as I like Picard season 3 I would agree. But then again TOS is the best Trek show of them all, and that is because nothing will ever top OG KIrk,Spock and Bones.

 

[Shawnster]

I might change the title of this thread to 1001001’s True and Correct Star Trek Opinions…

Well, it is true and correct that these are your opinions

 

[Timofnine]

Well, it is true and correct that these are your opinions

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

Accept third party cookies

 

[Ovation]

Just rewatched Where No Man Has Gone Before. By far the best pilot episode of Trek, above all other series and among the ten best episodes, again across all series.

 

[Ray Hardgrit]

Now you've got to rewatch all the others just to make sure.

 

[Farscape One]

BEY is better than two and possibly three of the TNG films and both of the other Kelvin Timeline movies.

Yes, it is.

 

[TheAdmiralty]

Not once they gave them color. Troi's bunny outfit looked silly and T'pol and Kira's catsuits were suppose to be military uniforms but they didn't work. The silver catsuit was sexy of course but also silly and something you can't take a character serious wearing something like that. Once they gave Seven and later T'Pol outfits that had color to them though they looked better. The high heels though was I think were a worst choice than even catsuits.

As for the worst outfit in Trek that would likely be any civilian clothes on TNG. Civilians wore some of the most absurd "futuristic" things possible, Not to mention the season 1 shirt they had Wesley Crusher wearing.

I would say the opposite. The silver catsuit worked as a meta thing where it was clear they were going for some kind of Metropolis type robot girl aesthetic. Trying to make it look like regular clothes just begs the question of why it's that tight.

The first one was also better for T'Pol's. IF a Vulcan was going to wear something like that it would at least be dull and austere, not in bright colors. Taking that pretense away from it just made it even more ridiculous that she'd be dressed like that on that on the bridge, plus it was a deep v neck.

 

[fireproof78]

Not once they gave them color

Oof...no, no, not for me. Color isn't going to make it better.