Re: New photos from the Enterprise replica
To be fair, (and this is not a direct response/contrary argument to what you're saying, Cary, because I know you're talking about the TMP refit) I don't think they've yet said that the old one always looked like this. I may be wrong. It's not really a prequel. Different time-line and whatnot. It just (presumably) always looked like this in the reboot universe.
Now, you can easily argue that they made a bad stylistic choice, which I think a lot of people are saying. I personally don't like a lot of the interior choices way way more than the exterior, but I'm still not 100% sold on the exterior either. I'm just 'comforted' by the fact that we will hopefully be provided with a reason why it looks different, or enough that we can come up with a reason of our own (it was built later using more advanced tech, for example.)
I just can't see the 'it looks different' argument working anymore when this is a reboot set in a different timeline and there are easy fixes for this.
To be fair, (and this is not a direct response/contrary argument to what you're saying, Cary, because I know you're talking about the TMP refit) I don't think they've yet said that the old one always looked like this. I may be wrong. It's not really a prequel. Different time-line and whatnot. It just (presumably) always looked like this in the reboot universe.
Now, you can easily argue that they made a bad stylistic choice, which I think a lot of people are saying. I personally don't like a lot of the interior choices way way more than the exterior, but I'm still not 100% sold on the exterior either. I'm just 'comforted' by the fact that we will hopefully be provided with a reason why it looks different, or enough that we can come up with a reason of our own (it was built later using more advanced tech, for example.)
I just can't see the 'it looks different' argument working anymore when this is a reboot set in a different timeline and there are easy fixes for this.























Or is that overhead lights doing that to the model with the light being bent and refracted by the case?


















Your tough to please aren't ya!