The Only Major Star Trek Character Who Never Got A Good Story Of Their Own - SlashFilm
Star Trek generally did a decent job of showcasing its ensemble casts, but there was one character in Star Trek: Enterprise who was just sort of ... there.
Travis was what they called a "boomer," which is to say he was born in space, and was raised on a cargo vessel by his pilot parents. Because he had spent so much time in space, he was technically more experienced as an explorer than all of his superior officers, including the Enterprise's captain, Jonathan Archer (Scott Bakula).
This might have made for an interesting power dynamic on the bridge, with Travis Mayweather actively second-guessing all of his captain's orders, and the captain having to begrudgingly admit that Travis is right about everything. Instead, Travis' role on the crew was to ... just sort of smile and be gentle and not get into any trouble. Travis was sweet and well-behaved, and underwritten to the point of almost being a nonentity. This was not actor Anthony Montgomery's fault, of course. He played the part as written, like a true professional. But the writers never figured out what sort of relationship he had with the other crew members.
Ensign Mayweather had one notable story all to himself, and while it tried to do justice to the character, it ended up being kind of forgettable. The episode was called "Horizon," and it involved the USS Enterprise coming upon the ECS Horizon, the ship that Mayweather was raised on...You'll notice that the plot of "Horizon" is more about the character development of Paul than of Travis. Travis reconciles with his brother, but learns no real lessons. It's also worth noting that the B-plot of "Horizon" involves Trip Tucker arranging a movie night back on the Enterprise. Even when Mayweather got his own episode, he was robbed of screen time by a screening of "Frankenstein." Mayweather had little personality, sub-par dialogue, and no real character arc to speak of.
What would you have done differently with him?