• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Travis deserved more?

  • Thread starter Laura Cynthia Chambers
  • Start date

Laura Cynthia Chambers

Vice Admiral
Admiral

Travis was what they called a "boomer," which is to say he was born in space, and was raised on a cargo vessel by his pilot parents. Because he had spent so much time in space, he was technically more experienced as an explorer than all of his superior officers, including the Enterprise's captain, Jonathan Archer (Scott Bakula).

This might have made for an interesting power dynamic on the bridge, with Travis Mayweather actively second-guessing all of his captain's orders, and the captain having to begrudgingly admit that Travis is right about everything. Instead, Travis' role on the crew was to ... just sort of smile and be gentle and not get into any trouble. Travis was sweet and well-behaved, and underwritten to the point of almost being a nonentity. This was not actor Anthony Montgomery's fault, of course. He played the part as written, like a true professional. But the writers never figured out what sort of relationship he had with the other crew members.

Ensign Mayweather had one notable story all to himself, and while it tried to do justice to the character, it ended up being kind of forgettable. The episode was called "Horizon," and it involved the USS Enterprise coming upon the ECS Horizon, the ship that Mayweather was raised on...You'll notice that the plot of "Horizon" is more about the character development of Paul than of Travis. Travis reconciles with his brother, but learns no real lessons. It's also worth noting that the B-plot of "Horizon" involves Trip Tucker arranging a movie night back on the Enterprise. Even when Mayweather got his own episode, he was robbed of screen time by a screening of "Frankenstein." Mayweather had little personality, sub-par dialogue, and no real character arc to speak of.

What would you have done differently with him?
 
I wouldn't have Voyagered him.

Voyager and Enterprise both set things up that never paid off. The fact that Travis had more knowledge and experience of being out in space than anyone on the ship except T'Pol almost instantly became less important than the Maquis backstory was in Voyager.

But Enterprise didn't do well by Reed or Sato, either. It quickly became the Archer/T'Pol/Tucker show with the occasional bit of Phlox. As much as I liked Kellie Waymire as Cutler and would have liked to see more if she'd lived, it kind of felt like someone was trying to find an interesting new character because a few episodes into the first season they'd already given up on half of their regulars.
 
^^^ You said everything I would have.

Dude got a 12/10 backstory and made him more Harry Kim than even Harry Kim himself every was
 
In all honesty, Mayweather was probably the character Enterprise should have killed off relatively early in its run. Not because he was expendable, but because he was one of the few characters with a genuinely unique perspective.

Travis wasn't just one of the many Starfleet officers who'd spent their life on Earth and dabbled a bit in space. He was effectively a space trucker. He'd grown up out there. He knew the routes, the cultures, the dangers and the realities of life beyond Earth's comfort zone better than almost anyone else aboard Enterprise.

If he had been killed by some unknown threat, it would have immediately established the central premise of the show: humanity was heading into a frontier far more wonderful, but dangerous, than it ever realised. This wasn't just another mission. It was a leap into a vast and unpredictable galaxy that even the most experienced spacers didn't fully understand. They should have made him a little rougher, a little wilder - someone who is a little cocky, but also very experienced, that this novice space crew lean on just a little too much because he knows what he's doing... until he doesn't.

Narratively, it would have raised the stakes enormously. The audience would have understood that if the one person who already knew deep space could die, nobody was safe.

The problem, of course, is that it's much easier to say this from a storytelling perspective than from a real-world one. Mayweather was also one of the only Black main characters in the cast, and television has a long history of sidelining or killing minority characters while using their deaths to develop everyone else's story.

So while the idea makes sense dramatically, it would have walked straight into some uncomfortable and entirely understandable criticisms.

The real tragedy is that the writers didn't do either. They didn't kill Mayweather, but they also never really used him. He was central, always there... just not doing anything. Harry mark 2. A character with one of the most interesting backstories really unique to the premise of ENT in the ST universe became very quickly the most underwritten, which feels like a much bigger missed opportunity. Injecting him with a certain roguish quality, making him a bit prickly and cocky but with a strong sense of protecting his crew and someone needed on the ship because he knows what he's doing would have added a real extra texture to the crew dynamic.

At least his only character development wasn't "I fly the ship"...
 
Last edited:
I think a lot, if not most, of some dialogue that should have been Mayweather's went to T'Pol. She became the more experienced space traveler, making Mayweather pretty much redundant from the start and relegated to mainly just saying "Yes, sir" or "Aye, sir." I've seen Anthony Montgomery in other things where he brought a lot to the table, but he really didn't have a lot to work with in ENT.
 
I think a lot, if not most, of some dialogue that should have been Mayweather's went to T'Pol. She became the more experienced space traveler, making Mayweather pretty much redundant from the start and relegated to mainly just saying "Yes, sir" or "Aye, sir." I've seen Anthony Montgomery in other things where he brought a lot to the table, but he really didn't have a lot to work with in ENT.
Tpol is older and Vulcans would have a lot more knowledge of space than a Boomer doing cargo runs at warp 1.3
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top