If they can't kill the walker themselves, the dog could still slow it down enough for the person to take it out.A dog is not going to kill a walker. All it can do is bite body parts, but never kill the brain, so using dogs in that regard would be wasted effort / placing dogs in harm's way for no reason.
The dogs could always be let go to fend for themselves....and when the humans are low on food or themselves (from any source), how are dogs going to get regular meals? Where is it coming from? Hunting? If the humans are suffering from a lack of food, I would imagine some of the same food sources (the kind a Daryl would hunt for) would as scare for dogs.
Police and military dogs do OK in those kinds of situations.Dogs would not go very far against a Saviors type of threat, where a few or a large group are armed with guns. A dog is not going to know to leap to take cover during a fight, or retreat until a better window of opportunity comes around. It would just end with a lot of dead dogs.
I wouldn't call it a weakness, it's simply a creative choice that he made. Just because a writer chooses not to address something doesn't mean they're a bad writer. If he did address it, and the reason why was bad, then Kirkman would be a bad writer.One does not need to be a "religious fanatic" to consider that a global plague raising the dead as cannibals--something with no historical/biological precedent--might be final judgement of some kind. My point is whatever the cause--whether biological or theological in nature--has been kicked out of all WD dialogue because Kirkman is too cowardly to even hint at a cause. That's his monumental weakness as a writer, when others were not afraid to explore the "why" at the same time as telling a horror survival tale. For the best example, take Richard Matheson, who actually created theories and medical reasons for the vampire plague of his seminal masterpiece I Am Legend; he didn't shy away from it, or have Neville conveniently stop thinking about the one thing threatening his life and future. That was a brilliant way of mixing real human behavior with survival horror, yet under the same circumstances, Kirkman, et al, ran away screaming from Darabont initially taking the series in that logical direction.