• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

The Twilight Zone — Episode-by-Episode Review Thread

There was a lot of studio/producer loyalty. You'll see a lot of the same people working for the same production companies. Desilu had a key role in getting Twilight Zone on tv.

This show is going to be a special feature on the Twilight Zone Season 1 Blu-ray.

I liked Mr. Denton on Doomsday a lot. I can see the point you're making about free will but I still think it works. It's bolstered by the performance of Dan Duryea, who really does look like he's down on his luck. Also features an appearance by a very young Martain Landau.

I do love the fact that TZ takes place in various genres and locations like the Old West.
 
I liked the original Twillight Zone, however I also liked some episodes of the mid-eighties Twillight Zone. For example, the episode called "Shelter Skelter" was a great episode with Joe Mantegna.
 
You should keep a score of the number of actors who've been in Star Trek.

Trekkies love that shit! :bolian:
You know, I really should. But that would require me to pay even more attention to the credits than I already do. Let's see if I'll have the ambition. :shifty:

I do love the fact that TZ takes place in various genres and locations like the Old West.
Yeah, one episode it's an adventure out in space, next one's a western. I love that, too! :)


"The Sixteen-Millimeter Shrine" (1x04)

Synopsis: An aging film star lives a life of seclusion in her private screening room watching her old movies over and over.

Review: After three rather satisfying episodes this is the first clunker. As far as I'm concerned, only the performance of Martin Balsam as the loyal agend and last friend of Ida Lupino's aging actress kept the episode from being a complete failure. The episode's subject matter isn't an uninteresting one at that: One's mortality is a deeply existential and human theme; I love meditations on it. But the episode makes the mistake to present this theme in the most removed way possible. Hardly anyone should be able to relate to an aging actress who can't handle her fainting fame. But then again, maybe it's just me.

I don't know if it is my familiarity with the structure of the show, but I knew at least ten minutes before it actually happened, that Ida Lupino's character was going to end up in her own movie (= her gloryfied dream world). I don't know, it just felt like there should have been something more than that. I mean, we knew from the first minute that the character was living in the past – in a fantasy world created by her own. A more in depth examination of such a closed-minded perspective and its consequences might have been a more rewarding experience.

25hzpqt.png
mlryuc.png
mlryuc.png
mlryuc.png
mlryuc.png
 
I wasn't a fan of that episode either. I found it to be uninteresting.

Ida Lupino would later return to The Twilight Zone, later as a director for the fifth season episode The Masks.
 
Always reminds me of Sunset Boulevard, for obvious reasons. I like it, though.

I wrote a short paper on that for class--gotta love a major that allows the class "Film as Literature." There were so many internal references to real Hollywood everywhere in that movie, just total intertextualizing.

That film is now on my top 10 favorites list. And I need to find the book I used as my major reference--just too interesting.
 
Boy, I'm glad I'm not the only one who felt somewhat underwhelmed by "The Sixteen-Millimeter Shrine". :)

That is a great list! I was looking for something like that. Thanks. :)



"Walking Distance" (1x05)

Synopsis: While middle-aged businessman Martin Sloan visits his hometown, he suddenly finds himself in the past.

Review: "Walking Distance" is a brilliant episode and represents the high point of the series thus far. Everything is in place: the casting, the dialog, the direction, the music – yet the episode seems to be even larger than the sum of its parts, mainly because of its fascinating topic, which – although similiar to "The Sixteen-Millimeter Shrine" in some respects – permits a very easy identification due to how it is presented. Most people should be familiar with the longing for the simplicity of their carefree childhood in the confusing everyday life of adulthood. "Walking Distance" manages to deals with this topic on a reduced, simplified and yet marvelously deep level.

The tools with which this is managed are numerous, but the episode owes much of its effectiveness to Bernard Herrmann's legendary score, which – contrary to many other episodes – was especially composed for "Walking Distance". The music is able to communicate the sweet feeling of innocence which inherits the childhood of the protagonist while at the same time it conveys the emotional force to which he sees himself exposed when confronted with his past.

Additionally, the creative direction of the episode is quite impressive for a television production. The moment when Martin Sloan unknowingly starts to walk into the past and the camera follows him in the reflection of a mirror is particularly well done. Also, there are many moments throughout the episode when the direction subtly brings the fact to the viewer's attention that we are in a dream world.

While Gig Young marvelously portrays the busy melancholic, it is primarily Frank Overton's performance as Martin's father which draws attention to it. Trek fans might remember him as Elias Sandoval from the classic "This Side of Paradise". Although much briefer, his performance is far more impressive here.

The message of the episode is conceivably simple and yet very profound: Our past cannot be brought back. And he who cannot let go of it will never be able to become happy here and now.

25hzpqt.png
25hzpqt.png
25hzpqt.png
25hzpqt.png
25hzpqt.png
 
A good actor makes or brakes an episode like this; an episode where the attention of the viewer has to be maintained by a single performance. Fortunately, Earl Holliman is such an actor and Rod Serling's fine script succeeds in making him a likeable character which the audience can easily realte to. That this is done in so little time is very impressive.
If I recall correctly from Mark Scott Zicree's TZ Companion, there was a little bit of concern about all the praise Holliman got considering he wouldn't be in the next episode.

I just wish Rod Serling had incorporated the second twist he later wrote for a short story adaptation of the episode, where in the end Holliman's character finds a movie ticket in his pocket.
Actually that twist was in the original pilot, it was even filmed. It's a special feature on the definitive edition set.
I don't think that's correct. I own the Definitive Set, and I don't remember that on there. I do remember a Serling audio track on the set where Serling says he wrote that for a book called something like "Stories from the Twilight Zone," which were short story versions of TZ episodes, but I don't think this was filmed or was even thought up yet for the pilot script.

My favorite part of the pilot is when Holliman is stuck inside the phone booth, starts banging on it and yelling, only to realize you have to pull the door to open it, not push it. This actually happened to Rod Serling at, I believe, an airport. He went into a phone booth, thought he was stuck and started screaming for help. A guy came and kicked the door, and it came right open, and, as Serling said, he nearly died of embarrassment.

I remember reading (again, from "The Twilight Zone Companion"--but it's been years--I love that book) that the casting of Ed Wynn was considered a mistake because of how he spoke. This guy was supposed to be a salesman and it was thought that Ed Wynn's slower speech was just not a good fit. Now, his son (Keenan Wynn) could probably have pulled it off--he was usually a bit bombastic--but then he might't've fit with the rest of the character.
Ed Wynn himself told Serling he didn't think he could play the part, but Wynn was the guy Serling wanted. In the end, it's pretty plain that Wynn was right, but I think I like the heart he puts into the character.
 
Review: "Walking Distance" is a brilliant episode and represents the high point of the series thus far. Everything is in place: the casting, the dialog, the direction, the music – yet the episode seems to be even larger than the sum of its parts, mainly because of its fascinating topic, which – although similiar to "The Sixteen-Millimeter Shrine" in some respects – permits a very easy identification due to how it is presented.
I couldn't disagree more.

I thought the writing was terrible. How often do you meet some schmuck at a gas station you yelled at, only to just blurt out exposition: "Sorry I yelled at you, but you see... I'm a city man in search of myself. I've come back to my hometown to find a piece of my childhood. Maybe I'll find that it was here with me... all along." Please. Serling himself was embarrassed by the dialog years later and flat-out called it stupid writing. I have to agree.

Not that there were some nice moments, but the dialog is horrid.
 
If I recall correctly from Mark Scott Zicree's TZ Companion, there was a little bit of concern about all the praise Holliman got considering he wouldn't be in the next episode.
I just looked it up and as I understand it, they were not specifically worried about the praise Holliman got, but the fact that the show had no recurring elements altogether (other than the concept).

I couldn't disagree more.

I thought the writing was terrible. How often do you meet some schmuck at a gas station you yelled at, only to just blurt out exposition: "Sorry I yelled at you, but you see... I'm a city man in search of myself. I've come back to my hometown to find a piece of my childhood. Maybe I'll find that it was here with me... all along." Please. Serling himself was embarrassed by the dialog years later and flat-out called it stupid writing. I have to agree.

Not that there were some nice moments, but the dialog is horrid.
Yeah, the opening bit did feel somewhat unnatural and I think it wouldn't be all that cumbersome had they incorporated all the expository stuff in Serling's monolog, but I guess it just didn't bother me all that much. There are moments later on when the dialog may have been a little stilted, too, but I put that down to it being a fantasy/dream world.
 
Looking forward to the reviews!

One of my favorite shows that still have a few episodes that are chilling to this day...(i.e. The Howling Man, The Jungle, and others)...
 
That is a great list! I was looking for something like that. Thanks. :)

I didn't know IMDb could do that.

Except it shows that, as always, IMDb is prone to mistakes. It lists Richard Kiel as appearing in TOS: "What Are Little Girls Made Of," which is erroneous; they're confusing him with Ted Cassidy.




I thought the writing was terrible. How often do you meet some schmuck at a gas station you yelled at, only to just blurt out exposition: "Sorry I yelled at you, but you see... I'm a city man in search of myself. I've come back to my hometown to find a piece of my childhood. Maybe I'll find that it was here with me... all along." Please. Serling himself was embarrassed by the dialog years later and flat-out called it stupid writing. I have to agree.

Not that there were some nice moments, but the dialog is horrid.

Not all dialogue is meant to be naturalistic. You think that people in Shakespeare's time really talked in iambic pentameter? Some writers have a style that's more about poetry than naturalism. Ray Bradbury is one; his prose is gorgeous to read, but rarely sounds plausible when spoken aloud as dialogue. Rod Serling was another.
 
Except it shows that, as always, IMDb is prone to mistakes. It lists Richard Kiel as appearing in TOS: "What Are Little Girls Made Of," which is erroneous; they're confusing him with Ted Cassidy.

They also erroneously credit Mark Richman with appearing in "Mirror, Mirror". Richman appeared in TNG, but not TOS.
 
Except it shows that, as always, IMDb is prone to mistakes. It lists Richard Kiel as appearing in TOS: "What Are Little Girls Made Of," which is erroneous; they're confusing him with Ted Cassidy.

They also erroneously credit Mark Richman with appearing in "Mirror, Mirror". Richman appeared in TNG, but not TOS.

I thought Peter Mark Richman was Garth of Izar? That actor was also in one of my favorite Outer Limits episodes. I don't remember the title, it was the one with the kids and the spaceship built for them.
 
I don't think that's correct. I own the Definitive Set, and I don't remember that on there. I do remember a Serling audio track on the set where Serling says he wrote that for a book called something like "Stories from the Twilight Zone," which were short story versions of TZ episodes, but I don't think this was filmed or was even thought up yet for the pilot script.
Weird. I could have sworn I saw it. Maybe I just read about it and have a very good imagination. ;)
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top