So I read through the next 7 pages of this thread this morning and I'm being asked what I wanted to see for a Trek film and why this doesn't feel like Star Trek to me. Well, part of it is this film feels like 100 trailers we've seen so many times in the last few years with the booming music, explosions, and that Battle: LA tone. I mean seriously, how many times have we seen trailers like this, where you get the whole "Boom" (Dialoge) "Boom" (More dialog and even extra special effects), and then add more "Booms" for good measure.
Because I feel like I've seen this trailer 100's of times, it lacks heart. If there was one thing Star Trek has always prided itself on, it's heart. It's being able to make me think about it for days on in after I watch it. With this trailer, yeah today is an exciting day because we get are first glimpse into the new movie, but ask me how I feel about it a week from now and I'll probably be like "Oh, that trailer? It was ok, I guess".
Now granted it is only a teaser, and they are trying to get the mainstream fan into this movie, but I almost get the sense of either/or, and that's why I'm getting a "Star Trek in Name Only". They attach Star Trek to a generic teaser that we've seen 100s of times pandering to the mainstream audience and wanting to get the fans just because it's called "Star Trek".
Maybe I'm just tired of the whole vengeance theme and all the "kool 'splosions" I mean there wasn't even any space travel in this teaser, and it looks like most of the movie is taking place on or near earth.
As for Star Trek changing, I'm fine with Star Trek changing, as long as it knows where it came from and where it decides to go. I don't want to see Star Trek just be a "generic" thriller just to excite the masses. It's a lot more than that, and has 50 years of history to back that up.
Again, with all this being said, this was just a teaser. Hopefully the next few trailers will make me feel like this is a worthy Star Trek movie and we still have 6 months to go before the release date. A lot can happen in those 6 months. Hell, I remember the last teaser to trailer for Star Trek (2009) and the two were really different. I expect something similar to happen here.