***The Star Trek Episode Clash!*** The Results!

[Eddie Roth]

Re: May 20 Results (Round 71)

Posted by tomalak301:

Posted by Temis the Vorta:


Sorry, the results simply reflect reality. I've seen all five Trek series and VOY is bringing up the tail end in terms of quality (for a while there, ENT was just as bad but there has been a definite turnaround in the last half of S3, I guess the Beebs finally realized that they needed to institute plot arcs to keep the episodes from repeating what they've done before).

Ah yes, the old and overrated plot arc argument. Only one problem with it. TNG and Star Trek don't have plot arcs and they seem to be doing fine.

Yes, I have to agree with tomalak here. I don't think plot arcs have anything to do with quality. If anything, they make a series superficially more exciting. Superficially. DS9's arc was good, but ENT's has not had me especially riveted. And I personally think that this show has only marginally improved, much less so than VGR improved between its second and third seasons. The writing on ENT is still lousy.

As for VGR having won only 5 times so far, I have this to say. Everybody's right here. I've recently come to enjoy VGR a great deal again, which is why I'm disappointed too looking at the list of winners. But the truth is: Even when VGR has had a good episode - there are still four competitors. It had to face two excellent TOS seasons, DS9 shows like The Circle Trilogy, Duet, Necessary Evil etc, as well as several TNG classics - tough ones to beat even with a great entry. That's the name of the game: May the best one win. Remember: Even a classic like "Amok Time" didn't make the list because it lost out to another classic, "The Measure of a Man".

There's one thing I regret deeply, however, and that is that the initial enthusiasm for ENT (among other things, of course) prevented "Caretaker" from being voted best pilot. 'Cause it is.

 

[Eddie Roth]

May 27 Results (Round 72)

'Best' is best

Not surprisingly, TNG'S The Best of Both Worlds won Round 72 today. 40 votes were more than enough for Trek's most famous cliffhanger episode to surpass its competitors. On the ranks:

2. The Way of the Warrior, Part II (14)
3. The Council (13)
4. The Raven (2)
5. The Lights of Zetar (1)

By the way: Thank you for the high participation. 70 votes is a new record!

Standings in The Battle of the Shows! after 73 finished fights.

Championship Ranking (percentage of fights won) (wins/losses)

1. DS9 31.5% (-0.4%)
2. TOS 26.0% (-0.4%)
3. TNG 20.5% (+1.1%)
4. ENT 15.1% (-0.2%)
5. VGR 6.8% (-0.1%)

Fights won

23... DS9
22...
21...
20...
19... TOS
18...
17...
16...
15... TNG
14...
13...
12...
11... ENT
10...
9....
8....
7....
6....
5.... VGR
4....
3....
2....
1....
0....

The winners

Round 000 (Ep. #PIL): ENT Broken Bow
Round 001 (Ep. #003): TOS The Corbomite Maneuver
Round 002 (Ep. #004): ENT Strange New World
Round 003 (Ep. #005): TOS The Enemy Within
Round 004 (Ep. #006): TNG Where No One Has Gone Before
Round 005 (Ep. #007): ENT The Andorian Incident
Round 006 (Ep. #008): DS9 Dax
Round 007 (Ep. #009): TOS Balance of Terror
Round 008 (Ep. #010): VGR Prime Factors
Round 009 (Ep. #011): ENT Cold Front
Round 010 (Ep. #012): TNG The Big Goodbye
Round 011 (Ep. #013): ENT Dear Doctor
Round 012 (Ep. #014): TOS The Galileo Seven
Round 013 (Ep. #015): TNG 11001001
Round 014 (Ep. #016): ENT Shuttlepod One
Round 015 (Ep. #017): TOS The Menagerie Part 2
Round 016 (Ep. #018): TOS Shore Leave
Round 017 (Ep. #019): DS9 Duet
Round 018 (Ep. #020): DS9 In the Hands of the Prophets
Round 019 (Ep. #021): DS9 The Homecoming
Round 020 (Ep. #022): DS9 The Circle
Round 021 (Ep. #023): DS9 The Siege
Round 022 (Ep. #024): TOS A Taste of Armageddon
Round 023 (Ep. #025): TOS Space Seed
Round 024 (Ep. #026): TNG The Neutral Zone
Round 025 (Ep. #027): TOS The Devil in the Dark
Round 026 (Ep. #028): DS9 Necessary Evil
Round 027 (Ep. #029): TOS The City on the Edge of Forever
Round 028 (Ep. #030): ENT Dead Stop
Round 029 (Ep. #031): DS9 Rivals
Round 030 (Ep. #032): TOS Metamorphosis
Round 031 (Ep. #033): DS9 Armageddon Game
Round 032 (Ep. #034): VGR Death Wish
Round 033 (Ep. #035): TNG The Measure of a Man
Round 034 (Ep. #036): TOS The Doomsday Machine
Round 035 (Ep. #037): TNG Contagion
Round 036 (Ep. #038): ENT The Catwalk
Round 037 (Ep. #039): TNG Time Squared
Round 038 (Ep. #040): TOS Mirror, Mirror
Round 039 (Ep. #041): DS9 The Maquis, Part II
Round 040 (Ep. #042): TNG Q Who?
Round 041 (Ep. #043): TOS The Trouble With Tribbles
Round 042 (Ep. #044): TOS Bread and Circuses
Round 043 (Ep. #045): TOS Journey To Babel
Round 044 (Ep. #046): DS9 The Jem`Hadar
Round 045 (Ep. #047): TNG Peak Performance
Round 046 (Ep. #048): ENT Cogenitor
Round 047 (Ep. #049): DS9 The House of Quark
Round 048 (Ep. #050): VGR Future`s End, Part I
Round 049 (Ep. #051): TNG The Survivors
Round 050 (Ep. #052): TNG Who Watches The Watchers
Round 051 (Ep. #053): DS9 Civil Defense
Round 052 (Ep. #054): TOS The Ultimate Computer
Round 053 (Ep. #055): DS9 Defiant
Round 054 (Ep. #056): TOS Assignment: Earth
Round 055 (Ep. #057): DS9 Past Tense, Part I
Round 056 (Ep. #058): DS9 Past Tense, Part II
Round 057 (Ep. #059): DS9 Life Support
Round 058 (Ep. #060): TOS The Enterprise Incident
Round 059 (Ep. #061): DS9 Destiny
Round 060 (Ep. #062): ENT Similitude
Round 061 (Ep. #063): TNG Yesterday`s Enterprise
Round 062 (Ep. #064): TNG The Offspring
Round 063 (Ep. #065): DS9 Through The Looking Glass
Round 064 (Ep. #066): DS9 Improbable Cause
Round 065 (Ep. #067): DS9 The Die Is Cast
Round 066 (Ep. #068): VGR Scorpion
Round 067 (Ep. #069): VGR Scorpion, Part II
Round 068 (Ep. #070): ENT Azati Prime
Round 069 (Ep. #071): TNG Sarek
Round 070 (Ep. #072): DS9 The Adversary
Round 071 (Ep. #073): DS9 The Way of the Warrior, Part I
Round 072 (Ep. #074): TNG The Best of Both Worlds

Now on to another exciting Round with some first-rate episodes!

 

[Eddie Roth]

June 3 Results (Round 73)

A 'Visit' To The Top

Not surprisingly, DS9's "The Visitor" is the clear winner in Round 73 with 57% of the vote (and 39 votes total). Also faring reasonably well were TNG and ENT. On the ranks:

2. The Best of Both Worlds Part II (15)
3. Countdown (13)
4. Scientific Method (1)
5. The Cloud Minders (-)

Standings in The Battle of the Shows! after 74 finished fights.

Championship Ranking (percentage of fights won) (wins/losses)

1. DS9 32.4% (+0.9%)
2. TOS 25.7% (-0.3%)
3. TNG 20.3% (-0.2%)
4. ENT 14.8% (-0.3%)
5. VGR 6.7% (-0.1%)

Fights won

24... DS9
23...
22...
21...
20...
19... TOS
18...
17...
16...
15... TNG
14...
13...
12...
11... ENT
10...
9....
8....
7....
6....
5.... VGR
4....
3....
2....
1....
0....

The winners

Round 000 (Ep. #PIL): ENT Broken Bow
Round 001 (Ep. #003): TOS The Corbomite Maneuver
Round 002 (Ep. #004): ENT Strange New World
Round 003 (Ep. #005): TOS The Enemy Within
Round 004 (Ep. #006): TNG Where No One Has Gone Before
Round 005 (Ep. #007): ENT The Andorian Incident
Round 006 (Ep. #008): DS9 Dax
Round 007 (Ep. #009): TOS Balance of Terror
Round 008 (Ep. #010): VGR Prime Factors
Round 009 (Ep. #011): ENT Cold Front
Round 010 (Ep. #012): TNG The Big Goodbye
Round 011 (Ep. #013): ENT Dear Doctor
Round 012 (Ep. #014): TOS The Galileo Seven
Round 013 (Ep. #015): TNG 11001001
Round 014 (Ep. #016): ENT Shuttlepod One
Round 015 (Ep. #017): TOS The Menagerie Part 2
Round 016 (Ep. #018): TOS Shore Leave
Round 017 (Ep. #019): DS9 Duet
Round 018 (Ep. #020): DS9 In the Hands of the Prophets
Round 019 (Ep. #021): DS9 The Homecoming
Round 020 (Ep. #022): DS9 The Circle
Round 021 (Ep. #023): DS9 The Siege
Round 022 (Ep. #024): TOS A Taste of Armageddon
Round 023 (Ep. #025): TOS Space Seed
Round 024 (Ep. #026): TNG The Neutral Zone
Round 025 (Ep. #027): TOS The Devil in the Dark
Round 026 (Ep. #028): DS9 Necessary Evil
Round 027 (Ep. #029): TOS The City on the Edge of Forever
Round 028 (Ep. #030): ENT Dead Stop
Round 029 (Ep. #031): DS9 Rivals
Round 030 (Ep. #032): TOS Metamorphosis
Round 031 (Ep. #033): DS9 Armageddon Game
Round 032 (Ep. #034): VGR Death Wish
Round 033 (Ep. #035): TNG The Measure of a Man
Round 034 (Ep. #036): TOS The Doomsday Machine
Round 035 (Ep. #037): TNG Contagion
Round 036 (Ep. #038): ENT The Catwalk
Round 037 (Ep. #039): TNG Time Squared
Round 038 (Ep. #040): TOS Mirror, Mirror
Round 039 (Ep. #041): DS9 The Maquis, Part II
Round 040 (Ep. #042): TNG Q Who?
Round 041 (Ep. #043): TOS The Trouble With Tribbles
Round 042 (Ep. #044): TOS Bread and Circuses
Round 043 (Ep. #045): TOS Journey To Babel
Round 044 (Ep. #046): DS9 The Jem`Hadar
Round 045 (Ep. #047): TNG Peak Performance
Round 046 (Ep. #048): ENT Cogenitor
Round 047 (Ep. #049): DS9 The House of Quark
Round 048 (Ep. #050): VGR Future`s End, Part I
Round 049 (Ep. #051): TNG The Survivors
Round 050 (Ep. #052): TNG Who Watches The Watchers
Round 051 (Ep. #053): DS9 Civil Defense
Round 052 (Ep. #054): TOS The Ultimate Computer
Round 053 (Ep. #055): DS9 Defiant
Round 054 (Ep. #056): TOS Assignment: Earth
Round 055 (Ep. #057): DS9 Past Tense, Part I
Round 056 (Ep. #058): DS9 Past Tense, Part II
Round 057 (Ep. #059): DS9 Life Support
Round 058 (Ep. #060): TOS The Enterprise Incident
Round 059 (Ep. #061): DS9 Destiny
Round 060 (Ep. #062): ENT Similitude
Round 061 (Ep. #063): TNG Yesterday`s Enterprise
Round 062 (Ep. #064): TNG The Offspring
Round 063 (Ep. #065): DS9 Through The Looking Glass
Round 064 (Ep. #066): DS9 Improbable Cause
Round 065 (Ep. #067): DS9 The Die Is Cast
Round 066 (Ep. #068): VGR Scorpion
Round 067 (Ep. #069): VGR Scorpion, Part II
Round 068 (Ep. #070): ENT Azati Prime
Round 069 (Ep. #071): TNG Sarek
Round 070 (Ep. #072): DS9 The Adversary
Round 071 (Ep. #073): DS9 The Way of the Warrior, Part I
Round 072 (Ep. #074): TNG The Best of Both Worlds
Round 073 (Ep. #075): DS9 The Visitor

And now on to the last Episode Clash of the Season...

 

[Computer Voice]

Re: May 20 Results (Round 71)

Posted by Eddie Roth:
As for VGR having won only 5 times so far, I have this to say. Everybody's right here. I've recently come to enjoy VGR a great deal again, which is why I'm disappointed too looking at the list of winners. But the truth is: Even when VGR has had a good episode - there are still four competitors. It had to face two excellent TOS seasons, DS9 shows like The Circle Trilogy, Duet, Necessary Evil etc, as well as several TNG classics - tough ones to beat even with a great entry. That's the name of the game: May the best one win. Remember: Even a classic like "Amok Time" didn't make the list because it lost out to another classic, "The Measure of a Man".

One way around that might be to have say 100 points available per round, and each series gets points equivalent to their perecntage of the votes in that round. It's more complex, but it means that if a series consistently comes second, it has a chance to build up points.

It would be interesting to see what difference that would make when compared to the current rankings.

 

[Eddie Roth]

Re: May 20 Results (Round 71)

^^^Yes, that's a good idea. It would get me around all this stupid calculating of percentages, too. Because I've always wondered: How would the results change

Maybe we can try that one day, starting from the top. You know, in the early days, we had very little participation and a Clash would be decided by a total of 20 voters or so. Now that we're up to 70 each round, it might make results more accurate if we redid them. That is, if people are interested... Let's try it during our hiatus starting next week, just to see how that would look...

 

[Eddie Roth]

June 10 Results (Round 74)

A Good 'Year' for VGR

It wasn't the easiest victory ever, but "Year of Hell" nevertheless emerged on top in the last Episode Clash until the fall. Support by 34 voters locked the win. Runner-up honors went to ENT's "Zero Hour" (24 votes). On the ranks:

3. Family (13)
3. Hippocratic Oath (13)
5. The Way To Eden (1)

A big thank you note: There were 85 votes overall this week, meaning that again, the Clash has set a new participation record. Cool. When we come back in the fall, I hope we really get that big 100!

Standings in The Battle of the Shows! after 75 finished fights.

Championship Ranking (percentage of fights won) (wins/losses)

1. DS9 32.0% (-0.4%)
2. TOS 25.3% (-0.4%)
3. TNG 20.0% (-0.3%)
4. ENT 14.7% (-0.1%)
5. VGR 8.0% (+1.3%)

Fights won

24... DS9
23...
22...
21...
20...
19... TOS
18...
17...
16...
15... TNG
14...
13...
12...
11... ENT
10...
9....
8....
7....
6.... VGR
5....
4....
3....
2....
1....
0....

The winners

Round 000 (Ep. #PIL): ENT Broken Bow
Round 001 (Ep. #003): TOS The Corbomite Maneuver
Round 002 (Ep. #004): ENT Strange New World
Round 003 (Ep. #005): TOS The Enemy Within
Round 004 (Ep. #006): TNG Where No One Has Gone Before
Round 005 (Ep. #007): ENT The Andorian Incident
Round 006 (Ep. #008): DS9 Dax
Round 007 (Ep. #009): TOS Balance of Terror
Round 008 (Ep. #010): VGR Prime Factors
Round 009 (Ep. #011): ENT Cold Front
Round 010 (Ep. #012): TNG The Big Goodbye
Round 011 (Ep. #013): ENT Dear Doctor
Round 012 (Ep. #014): TOS The Galileo Seven
Round 013 (Ep. #015): TNG 11001001
Round 014 (Ep. #016): ENT Shuttlepod One
Round 015 (Ep. #017): TOS The Menagerie Part 2
Round 016 (Ep. #018): TOS Shore Leave
Round 017 (Ep. #019): DS9 Duet
Round 018 (Ep. #020): DS9 In the Hands of the Prophets
Round 019 (Ep. #021): DS9 The Homecoming
Round 020 (Ep. #022): DS9 The Circle
Round 021 (Ep. #023): DS9 The Siege
Round 022 (Ep. #024): TOS A Taste of Armageddon
Round 023 (Ep. #025): TOS Space Seed
Round 024 (Ep. #026): TNG The Neutral Zone
Round 025 (Ep. #027): TOS The Devil in the Dark
Round 026 (Ep. #028): DS9 Necessary Evil
Round 027 (Ep. #029): TOS The City on the Edge of Forever
Round 028 (Ep. #030): ENT Dead Stop
Round 029 (Ep. #031): DS9 Rivals
Round 030 (Ep. #032): TOS Metamorphosis
Round 031 (Ep. #033): DS9 Armageddon Game
Round 032 (Ep. #034): VGR Death Wish
Round 033 (Ep. #035): TNG The Measure of a Man
Round 034 (Ep. #036): TOS The Doomsday Machine
Round 035 (Ep. #037): TNG Contagion
Round 036 (Ep. #038): ENT The Catwalk
Round 037 (Ep. #039): TNG Time Squared
Round 038 (Ep. #040): TOS Mirror, Mirror
Round 039 (Ep. #041): DS9 The Maquis, Part II
Round 040 (Ep. #042): TNG Q Who?
Round 041 (Ep. #043): TOS The Trouble With Tribbles
Round 042 (Ep. #044): TOS Bread and Circuses
Round 043 (Ep. #045): TOS Journey To Babel
Round 044 (Ep. #046): DS9 The Jem`Hadar
Round 045 (Ep. #047): TNG Peak Performance
Round 046 (Ep. #048): ENT Cogenitor
Round 047 (Ep. #049): DS9 The House of Quark
Round 048 (Ep. #050): VGR Future`s End, Part I
Round 049 (Ep. #051): TNG The Survivors
Round 050 (Ep. #052): TNG Who Watches The Watchers
Round 051 (Ep. #053): DS9 Civil Defense
Round 052 (Ep. #054): TOS The Ultimate Computer
Round 053 (Ep. #055): DS9 Defiant
Round 054 (Ep. #056): TOS Assignment: Earth
Round 055 (Ep. #057): DS9 Past Tense, Part I
Round 056 (Ep. #058): DS9 Past Tense, Part II
Round 057 (Ep. #059): DS9 Life Support
Round 058 (Ep. #060): TOS The Enterprise Incident
Round 059 (Ep. #061): DS9 Destiny
Round 060 (Ep. #062): ENT Similitude
Round 061 (Ep. #063): TNG Yesterday`s Enterprise
Round 062 (Ep. #064): TNG The Offspring
Round 063 (Ep. #065): DS9 Through The Looking Glass
Round 064 (Ep. #066): DS9 Improbable Cause
Round 065 (Ep. #067): DS9 The Die Is Cast
Round 066 (Ep. #068): VGR Scorpion
Round 067 (Ep. #069): VGR Scorpion, Part II
Round 068 (Ep. #070): ENT Azati Prime
Round 069 (Ep. #071): TNG Sarek
Round 070 (Ep. #072): DS9 The Adversary
Round 071 (Ep. #073): DS9 The Way of the Warrior, Part I
Round 072 (Ep. #074): TNG The Best of Both Worlds
Round 073 (Ep. #075): DS9 The Visitor
Round 074 (Ep. #076): VGR Year of Hell, Part I

Alright then, Clashers, new battles in the fall! Until then, I have thought of something new to entertain us...

 

[Mallory]

Re: May 20 Results (Round 71)

Before we adjourn for the summer, I'd just like to take a minute to thank you Eddie for diligently running this for the last couple of years. It's been a lot of fun (for me anyway) and I'm sure a lot of us here appreciate to hard work and effort you've put into it.

And I'd also like to thank everyone who participated. It was really great to have a thread comparing the episodes week by week that didn't degenerate into some "my series is better than your series" event. Well done to all of you as well.

Have a great summer everyone, see you back here when The Clash begins again in the fall.

 

[Eddie Roth]

Re: May 20 Results (Round 71)

^^^Thanks, Mallory. Much appreciated. As I said before, I have to thank everybody for the increased participation. I don't know if it's because the pair-ups in the Clashes have become more interesting or because we now have the poll function, but participation has increased by more than 200% on average this season. This shows me that I'm not doing this for nothing and that's great. So thank you!

As always, I encourage all Clash voters to use the results page to discuss some of the choices that were made. Maybe I'll start something later.

 

[Pegaritaville]

Re: May 20 Results (Round 71)

Great job: Thanks for another season of the Episode Clash. Looking forward to next season's Clash. In the meantime, it'll be interesting to see if some of the results change in the rematches.

 

[Computer Voice]

Re: May 20 Results (Round 71)

Yes, Eddie Roth certainly deserves thanks for his time and effort in compiling The Clash. I always look forward to my weekly dose of The Clash.

 

[StolenThunder]

Re: May 20 Results (Round 71)

I'd like to echo the comments of the others - I've been here since the first clash and they've provided superb entertainment.

(Though I'm disappointed that Family wasn't closer, if not the winner, this time around)

 

[Eddie Roth]

Results Rematch #1

Old pilots, new winner

This is interesting. The rematch idea was to see if our newly increased voter base would've changed the outcome of earlier clashes had they all been there in the beginning. And apparently, that is the case. While the original winner Broken Bow still fared well - getting even more votes in total than the first time, as far as I recall - but the new winner is Emissary with 23 out of 60 votes. Not a totally clear-cut victory, but it shows that more votes mean more accurate results. Thanks.

1. Emissary (23)
2. Broken Bow (13)
3. Where No Man Has Gone Before (11)
3. Caretaker (11)
5. Encounter At Farpoint (2)

There was another poll question this week: Should TAS replace TOS after it's run its course? The answer was clear: 75% of you voted against it, mostly on the grounds that few people had even seen TAS, let alone liked it so much that it could win a round. I kinda agree - it might just be an exercise in futility. So therefore you have decided: TAS is not going to be a part of the Clash.

Standings in The Battle of the Shows! after 75 finished fights.

Championship Ranking (percentage of fights won) (wins/losses)

1. DS9 33.3% (+1.3%)
2. TOS 25.3% (-0.0%)
3. TNG 20.0% (-0.0%)
4. ENT 13.4% (-1.3%)
5. VGR 8.0% (-0.0%)

Fights won

25... DS9
24...
23...
22...
21...
20...
19... TOS
18...
17...
16...
15... TNG
14...
13...
12...
11...
10... ENT
9....
8....
7....
6.... VGR
5....
4....
3....
2....
1....
0....

The winners

Round 000 (Ep. #PIL): DS9 Emissary (R)
Round 001 (Ep. #003): TOS The Corbomite Maneuver
Round 002 (Ep. #004): ENT Strange New World
Round 003 (Ep. #005): TOS The Enemy Within
Round 004 (Ep. #006): TNG Where No One Has Gone Before
Round 005 (Ep. #007): ENT The Andorian Incident
Round 006 (Ep. #008): DS9 Dax
Round 007 (Ep. #009): TOS Balance of Terror
Round 008 (Ep. #010): VGR Prime Factors
Round 009 (Ep. #011): ENT Cold Front
Round 010 (Ep. #012): TNG The Big Goodbye
Round 011 (Ep. #013): ENT Dear Doctor
Round 012 (Ep. #014): TOS The Galileo Seven
Round 013 (Ep. #015): TNG 11001001
Round 014 (Ep. #016): ENT Shuttlepod One
Round 015 (Ep. #017): TOS The Menagerie Part 2
Round 016 (Ep. #018): TOS Shore Leave
Round 017 (Ep. #019): DS9 Duet
Round 018 (Ep. #020): DS9 In the Hands of the Prophets
Round 019 (Ep. #021): DS9 The Homecoming
Round 020 (Ep. #022): DS9 The Circle
Round 021 (Ep. #023): DS9 The Siege
Round 022 (Ep. #024): TOS A Taste of Armageddon
Round 023 (Ep. #025): TOS Space Seed
Round 024 (Ep. #026): TNG The Neutral Zone
Round 025 (Ep. #027): TOS The Devil in the Dark
Round 026 (Ep. #028): DS9 Necessary Evil
Round 027 (Ep. #029): TOS The City on the Edge of Forever
Round 028 (Ep. #030): ENT Dead Stop
Round 029 (Ep. #031): DS9 Rivals
Round 030 (Ep. #032): TOS Metamorphosis
Round 031 (Ep. #033): DS9 Armageddon Game
Round 032 (Ep. #034): VGR Death Wish
Round 033 (Ep. #035): TNG The Measure of a Man
Round 034 (Ep. #036): TOS The Doomsday Machine
Round 035 (Ep. #037): TNG Contagion
Round 036 (Ep. #038): ENT The Catwalk
Round 037 (Ep. #039): TNG Time Squared
Round 038 (Ep. #040): TOS Mirror, Mirror
Round 039 (Ep. #041): DS9 The Maquis, Part II
Round 040 (Ep. #042): TNG Q Who?
Round 041 (Ep. #043): TOS The Trouble With Tribbles
Round 042 (Ep. #044): TOS Bread and Circuses
Round 043 (Ep. #045): TOS Journey To Babel
Round 044 (Ep. #046): DS9 The Jem`Hadar
Round 045 (Ep. #047): TNG Peak Performance
Round 046 (Ep. #048): ENT Cogenitor
Round 047 (Ep. #049): DS9 The House of Quark
Round 048 (Ep. #050): VGR Future`s End, Part I
Round 049 (Ep. #051): TNG The Survivors
Round 050 (Ep. #052): TNG Who Watches The Watchers
Round 051 (Ep. #053): DS9 Civil Defense
Round 052 (Ep. #054): TOS The Ultimate Computer
Round 053 (Ep. #055): DS9 Defiant
Round 054 (Ep. #056): TOS Assignment: Earth
Round 055 (Ep. #057): DS9 Past Tense, Part I
Round 056 (Ep. #058): DS9 Past Tense, Part II
Round 057 (Ep. #059): DS9 Life Support
Round 058 (Ep. #060): TOS The Enterprise Incident
Round 059 (Ep. #061): DS9 Destiny
Round 060 (Ep. #062): ENT Similitude
Round 061 (Ep. #063): TNG Yesterday`s Enterprise
Round 062 (Ep. #064): TNG The Offspring
Round 063 (Ep. #065): DS9 Through The Looking Glass
Round 064 (Ep. #066): DS9 Improbable Cause
Round 065 (Ep. #067): DS9 The Die Is Cast
Round 066 (Ep. #068): VGR Scorpion
Round 067 (Ep. #069): VGR Scorpion, Part II
Round 068 (Ep. #070): ENT Azati Prime
Round 069 (Ep. #071): TNG Sarek
Round 070 (Ep. #072): DS9 The Adversary
Round 071 (Ep. #073): DS9 The Way of the Warrior, Part I
Round 072 (Ep. #074): TNG The Best of Both Worlds
Round 073 (Ep. #075): DS9 The Visitor
Round 074 (Ep. #076): VGR Year of Hell, Part I

Just to show that we don't want to rewrite history, rematch winners get a (R) behind them on the list.

 

[StolenThunder]

Re: Results Rematch #1

If we do have the re-match results incorporated, is it possible to have the episode they replaced listed on the same line as well? I'd hate to see history erased, as it were.

 

[joe40001]

Re: Results Rematch #1

Posted by StolenThunder:
If we do have the re-match results incorporated, is it possible to have the episode they replaced listed on the same line as well? I'd hate to see history erased, as it were.

I strongly agree. I felt that Enterprise fought hard for it's best pilot title. It really doesn't deserve to be dethroned.

 

[Eddie Roth]

June 24 Results (Rematch #2)

All winners confirmed

The Corbomite Maneuver, Strange New World and The Enemy Within stay the winners of Rounds 1, 2 & 3 of the Clash, even after the latest rematch that at least doubled the participation.

Here are the full results:

1. The Corbomite Maneuver (26 votes)
2. Fight or Flight (15)
3. Past Prologue (12)
4. The Naked Now (8)
5. Parallax (5)

1. Strange New World (21)
2. Mudd's Women (14)
3. A Man Alone (13)
3. Time and Again (13)
5. Code of Honor (4)

1. The Enemy Within (25)
2. Unexpected (15)
3. Babel (10)
4. The Last Outpost (9)
5. Phage (7)

Standings in The Battle of the Shows! after 75 finished fights and 4 rematches.

Championship Ranking (percentage of fights won) (wins/losses)

1. DS9 33.3% (-0.0%)
2. TOS 25.3% (-0.0%)
3. TNG 20.0% (-0.0%)
4. ENT 13.4% (-0.0%)
5. VGR 8.0% (-0.0%)

Fights won

25... DS9
24...
23...
22...
21...
20...
19... TOS
18...
17...
16...
15... TNG
14...
13...
12...
11...
10... ENT
9....
8....
7....
6.... VGR
5....
4....
3....
2....
1....
0....

The winners

Round 000 (Ep. #PIL): DS9 Emissary (R)
Round 001 (Ep. #003): TOS The Corbomite Maneuver
Round 002 (Ep. #004): ENT Strange New World
Round 003 (Ep. #005): TOS The Enemy Within
Round 004 (Ep. #006): TNG Where No One Has Gone Before
Round 005 (Ep. #007): ENT The Andorian Incident
Round 006 (Ep. #008): DS9 Dax
Round 007 (Ep. #009): TOS Balance of Terror
Round 008 (Ep. #010): VGR Prime Factors
Round 009 (Ep. #011): ENT Cold Front
Round 010 (Ep. #012): TNG The Big Goodbye
Round 011 (Ep. #013): ENT Dear Doctor
Round 012 (Ep. #014): TOS The Galileo Seven
Round 013 (Ep. #015): TNG 11001001
Round 014 (Ep. #016): ENT Shuttlepod One
Round 015 (Ep. #017): TOS The Menagerie Part 2
Round 016 (Ep. #018): TOS Shore Leave
Round 017 (Ep. #019): DS9 Duet
Round 018 (Ep. #020): DS9 In the Hands of the Prophets
Round 019 (Ep. #021): DS9 The Homecoming
Round 020 (Ep. #022): DS9 The Circle
Round 021 (Ep. #023): DS9 The Siege
Round 022 (Ep. #024): TOS A Taste of Armageddon
Round 023 (Ep. #025): TOS Space Seed
Round 024 (Ep. #026): TNG The Neutral Zone
Round 025 (Ep. #027): TOS The Devil in the Dark
Round 026 (Ep. #028): DS9 Necessary Evil
Round 027 (Ep. #029): TOS The City on the Edge of Forever
Round 028 (Ep. #030): ENT Dead Stop
Round 029 (Ep. #031): DS9 Rivals
Round 030 (Ep. #032): TOS Metamorphosis
Round 031 (Ep. #033): DS9 Armageddon Game
Round 032 (Ep. #034): VGR Death Wish
Round 033 (Ep. #035): TNG The Measure of a Man
Round 034 (Ep. #036): TOS The Doomsday Machine
Round 035 (Ep. #037): TNG Contagion
Round 036 (Ep. #038): ENT The Catwalk
Round 037 (Ep. #039): TNG Time Squared
Round 038 (Ep. #040): TOS Mirror, Mirror
Round 039 (Ep. #041): DS9 The Maquis, Part II
Round 040 (Ep. #042): TNG Q Who?
Round 041 (Ep. #043): TOS The Trouble With Tribbles
Round 042 (Ep. #044): TOS Bread and Circuses
Round 043 (Ep. #045): TOS Journey To Babel
Round 044 (Ep. #046): DS9 The Jem`Hadar
Round 045 (Ep. #047): TNG Peak Performance
Round 046 (Ep. #048): ENT Cogenitor
Round 047 (Ep. #049): DS9 The House of Quark
Round 048 (Ep. #050): VGR Future`s End, Part I
Round 049 (Ep. #051): TNG The Survivors
Round 050 (Ep. #052): TNG Who Watches The Watchers
Round 051 (Ep. #053): DS9 Civil Defense
Round 052 (Ep. #054): TOS The Ultimate Computer
Round 053 (Ep. #055): DS9 Defiant
Round 054 (Ep. #056): TOS Assignment: Earth
Round 055 (Ep. #057): DS9 Past Tense, Part I
Round 056 (Ep. #058): DS9 Past Tense, Part II
Round 057 (Ep. #059): DS9 Life Support
Round 058 (Ep. #060): TOS The Enterprise Incident
Round 059 (Ep. #061): DS9 Destiny
Round 060 (Ep. #062): ENT Similitude
Round 061 (Ep. #063): TNG Yesterday`s Enterprise
Round 062 (Ep. #064): TNG The Offspring
Round 063 (Ep. #065): DS9 Through The Looking Glass
Round 064 (Ep. #066): DS9 Improbable Cause
Round 065 (Ep. #067): DS9 The Die Is Cast
Round 066 (Ep. #068): VGR Scorpion
Round 067 (Ep. #069): VGR Scorpion, Part II
Round 068 (Ep. #070): ENT Azati Prime
Round 069 (Ep. #071): TNG Sarek
Round 070 (Ep. #072): DS9 The Adversary
Round 071 (Ep. #073): DS9 The Way of the Warrior, Part I
Round 072 (Ep. #074): TNG The Best of Both Worlds
Round 073 (Ep. #075): DS9 The Visitor
Round 074 (Ep. #076): VGR Year of Hell, Part I

Original winners
Round 000 (Ep. #PIL): ENT Broken Bow

EDIT: Added link.

 

[Eddie Roth]

Re: Results Rematch #1

Posted by joe40001:

Posted by StolenThunder:
If we do have the re-match results incorporated, is it possible to have the episode they replaced listed on the same line as well? I'd hate to see history erased, as it were.

I strongly agree. I felt that Enterprise fought hard for it's best pilot title. It really doesn't deserve to be dethroned.

I added a list of "Original Winners" to the results page, so everybody can see which show won the first time. History will not be erased.

I'm also working on a new ranking system for the championship that will take into account every result, so that e.g. good second places in a round will also be reflected in the current standings.

 

[Eddie Roth]

Results Rematch #3

33% surprises

Original winners The Andorian Incident (ENT) and Dax (DS9) were confirmed in Rematch #3, but in the redone Round 004, there was a surprise: The Man Trap (TOS) is the new winner! Who would've thought? It was close, though:

1. The Man Trap (19)
2. Where No One Has Gone Before (17)
3. Captive Pursuit (10)
4. Terra Nova (7)
5. The Cloud (3)

Round 5

1. The Andorian Incident (24)
2. The Naked Time (15)
3. Eye of the Needle (9)
4. Q-less (6)
5. Lonely Among Us (4)

Round 6

1. Dax (23)
2. Breaking the Ice (16)
3. Charlie X (11)
4. Justice (3)
5. Ex Post Facto (2)

Standings in The Battle of the Shows! after 75 finished fights and 7 rematches.

Championship Ranking (percentage of fights won) (wins/losses)

1. DS9 33.3% (-0.0%)
2. TOS 26.7% (+1.4%)
3. TNG 18.6% (-1.4%)
4. ENT 13.4% (-0.0%)
5. VGR 8.0% (-0.0%)

Fights won

25... DS9
24...
23...
22...
21...
20... TOS
19...
18...
17...
16...
15...
14... TNG
13...
12...
11...
10... ENT
9....
8....
7....
6.... VGR
5....
4....
3....
2....
1....
0....

The winners

Round 000 (Ep. #PIL): DS9 Emissary (R)
Round 001 (Ep. #003): TOS The Corbomite Maneuver
Round 002 (Ep. #004): ENT Strange New World
Round 003 (Ep. #005): TOS The Enemy Within
Round 004 (Ep. #006): TOS The Man Trap (R)
Round 005 (Ep. #007): ENT The Andorian Incident
Round 006 (Ep. #008): DS9 Dax
Round 007 (Ep. #009): TOS Balance of Terror
Round 008 (Ep. #010): VGR Prime Factors
Round 009 (Ep. #011): ENT Cold Front
Round 010 (Ep. #012): TNG The Big Goodbye
Round 011 (Ep. #013): ENT Dear Doctor
Round 012 (Ep. #014): TOS The Galileo Seven
Round 013 (Ep. #015): TNG 11001001
Round 014 (Ep. #016): ENT Shuttlepod One
Round 015 (Ep. #017): TOS The Menagerie Part 2
Round 016 (Ep. #018): TOS Shore Leave
Round 017 (Ep. #019): DS9 Duet
Round 018 (Ep. #020): DS9 In the Hands of the Prophets
Round 019 (Ep. #021): DS9 The Homecoming
Round 020 (Ep. #022): DS9 The Circle
Round 021 (Ep. #023): DS9 The Siege
Round 022 (Ep. #024): TOS A Taste of Armageddon
Round 023 (Ep. #025): TOS Space Seed
Round 024 (Ep. #026): TNG The Neutral Zone
Round 025 (Ep. #027): TOS The Devil in the Dark
Round 026 (Ep. #028): DS9 Necessary Evil
Round 027 (Ep. #029): TOS The City on the Edge of Forever
Round 028 (Ep. #030): ENT Dead Stop
Round 029 (Ep. #031): DS9 Rivals
Round 030 (Ep. #032): TOS Metamorphosis
Round 031 (Ep. #033): DS9 Armageddon Game
Round 032 (Ep. #034): VGR Death Wish
Round 033 (Ep. #035): TNG The Measure of a Man
Round 034 (Ep. #036): TOS The Doomsday Machine
Round 035 (Ep. #037): TNG Contagion
Round 036 (Ep. #038): ENT The Catwalk
Round 037 (Ep. #039): TNG Time Squared
Round 038 (Ep. #040): TOS Mirror, Mirror
Round 039 (Ep. #041): DS9 The Maquis, Part II
Round 040 (Ep. #042): TNG Q Who?
Round 041 (Ep. #043): TOS The Trouble With Tribbles
Round 042 (Ep. #044): TOS Bread and Circuses
Round 043 (Ep. #045): TOS Journey To Babel
Round 044 (Ep. #046): DS9 The Jem`Hadar
Round 045 (Ep. #047): TNG Peak Performance
Round 046 (Ep. #048): ENT Cogenitor
Round 047 (Ep. #049): DS9 The House of Quark
Round 048 (Ep. #050): VGR Future`s End, Part I
Round 049 (Ep. #051): TNG The Survivors
Round 050 (Ep. #052): TNG Who Watches The Watchers
Round 051 (Ep. #053): DS9 Civil Defense
Round 052 (Ep. #054): TOS The Ultimate Computer
Round 053 (Ep. #055): DS9 Defiant
Round 054 (Ep. #056): TOS Assignment: Earth
Round 055 (Ep. #057): DS9 Past Tense, Part I
Round 056 (Ep. #058): DS9 Past Tense, Part II
Round 057 (Ep. #059): DS9 Life Support
Round 058 (Ep. #060): TOS The Enterprise Incident
Round 059 (Ep. #061): DS9 Destiny
Round 060 (Ep. #062): ENT Similitude
Round 061 (Ep. #063): TNG Yesterday`s Enterprise
Round 062 (Ep. #064): TNG The Offspring
Round 063 (Ep. #065): DS9 Through The Looking Glass
Round 064 (Ep. #066): DS9 Improbable Cause
Round 065 (Ep. #067): DS9 The Die Is Cast
Round 066 (Ep. #068): VGR Scorpion
Round 067 (Ep. #069): VGR Scorpion, Part II
Round 068 (Ep. #070): ENT Azati Prime
Round 069 (Ep. #071): TNG Sarek
Round 070 (Ep. #072): DS9 The Adversary
Round 071 (Ep. #073): DS9 The Way of the Warrior, Part I
Round 072 (Ep. #074): TNG The Best of Both Worlds
Round 073 (Ep. #075): DS9 The Visitor
Round 074 (Ep. #076): VGR Year of Hell, Part I

Original Winners
Round 000 (Ep. #PIL): ENT Broken Bow
Round 004 (Ep. #006): TNG Where No One Has Gone Before

And here's something new: A new ranking system for the championship that includes not just won rounds, but every rank any episode made. I added the percentages of votes that the episodes made in their rounds. This is the first number. The second is the average of vote percentages a show got.

This is, IMO, a more accurate way of gauging a series' performance, because, as you see, e.g. ENT has accumulated few wins, but has often fared relatively well, regularly receiving support in the 20-30% range in recent rounds. So even if an episode didn't win, the support it got should be reflected here. This is going to be the one and only championship ranking once TOS has ended and the rematches are done.

This statistic covers all rounds were the required data was available and that will not be redone, i.e. the Rematches and Rounds 59+

Show performance

TOS 306 (13.30% average)
TNG 478 (20.78% average)
DS9 700 (30.43% average)
VGR 244 (10.60% average)
ENT 486 (21.13% average)

 

[Computer Voice]

Re: Results Rematch #3

I like the new scoring system, Eddie Roth.

Its interesting to see that ENT is second, where as with the old system it was fourth.

 

[Peak]

Re: Results Rematch #3

Probably have to do with the fact that Ent have a lot of second places.

 

[Eddie Roth]

July 8 Results (Rematch #4)

Another new winner

TNG ups its number of wins with Hide & Q securing the top rank in Round 8's rematch. Original winner Prime Factors (VGR) only comes in in fourth place.

In Rounds 7 and 9, the old winners are the new ones: Balance of Terror (TOS) and Cold Front (ENT).

1. Balance of Terror (42 votes)
2. The Battle (5)
2. Civilization (5)
4. The Passenger (2)
5. Emanations (1)

1. Hide & Q (20)
2. What Are Little Girls Made Of? (11)
3. Fortunate Son (8)
4. Move Along Home (7)
4. Prime Factors (7)

1. Cold Front (24)
2. Dagger of the Mind (15)
3. The Nagus (11)
4. State of Flux (3)
5. Haven (2)

Standings in The Battle of the Shows! after 75 finished fights and 10 rematches.

Championship Ranking (percentage of fights won) (wins/losses)

1. DS9 33.3% (-0.0%)
2. TOS 26.7% (-0.0%)
3. TNG 20.0% (+1.4%)
4. ENT 13.4% (-0.0%)
5. VGR 6.6% (-1.4%)

Fights won

25... DS9
24...
23...
22...
21...
20... TOS
19...
18...
17...
16...
15... TNG
14...
13...
12...
11...
10... ENT
9....
8....
7....
6....
5.... VGR
4....
3....
2....
1....
0....

The winners

Round 000 (Ep. #PIL): DS9 Emissary (R)
Round 001 (Ep. #003): TOS The Corbomite Maneuver
Round 002 (Ep. #004): ENT Strange New World
Round 003 (Ep. #005): TOS The Enemy Within
Round 004 (Ep. #006): TOS The Man Trap (R)
Round 005 (Ep. #007): ENT The Andorian Incident
Round 006 (Ep. #008): DS9 Dax
Round 007 (Ep. #009): TOS Balance of Terror
Round 008 (Ep. #010): TNG Hide & Q (R)
Round 009 (Ep. #011): ENT Cold Front
Round 010 (Ep. #012): TNG The Big Goodbye
Round 011 (Ep. #013): ENT Dear Doctor
Round 012 (Ep. #014): TOS The Galileo Seven
Round 013 (Ep. #015): TNG 11001001
Round 014 (Ep. #016): ENT Shuttlepod One
Round 015 (Ep. #017): TOS The Menagerie Part 2
Round 016 (Ep. #018): TOS Shore Leave
Round 017 (Ep. #019): DS9 Duet
Round 018 (Ep. #020): DS9 In the Hands of the Prophets
Round 019 (Ep. #021): DS9 The Homecoming
Round 020 (Ep. #022): DS9 The Circle
Round 021 (Ep. #023): DS9 The Siege
Round 022 (Ep. #024): TOS A Taste of Armageddon
Round 023 (Ep. #025): TOS Space Seed
Round 024 (Ep. #026): TNG The Neutral Zone
Round 025 (Ep. #027): TOS The Devil in the Dark
Round 026 (Ep. #028): DS9 Necessary Evil
Round 027 (Ep. #029): TOS The City on the Edge of Forever
Round 028 (Ep. #030): ENT Dead Stop
Round 029 (Ep. #031): DS9 Rivals
Round 030 (Ep. #032): TOS Metamorphosis
Round 031 (Ep. #033): DS9 Armageddon Game
Round 032 (Ep. #034): VGR Death Wish
Round 033 (Ep. #035): TNG The Measure of a Man
Round 034 (Ep. #036): TOS The Doomsday Machine
Round 035 (Ep. #037): TNG Contagion
Round 036 (Ep. #038): ENT The Catwalk
Round 037 (Ep. #039): TNG Time Squared
Round 038 (Ep. #040): TOS Mirror, Mirror
Round 039 (Ep. #041): DS9 The Maquis, Part II
Round 040 (Ep. #042): TNG Q Who?
Round 041 (Ep. #043): TOS The Trouble With Tribbles
Round 042 (Ep. #044): TOS Bread and Circuses
Round 043 (Ep. #045): TOS Journey To Babel
Round 044 (Ep. #046): DS9 The Jem`Hadar
Round 045 (Ep. #047): TNG Peak Performance
Round 046 (Ep. #048): ENT Cogenitor
Round 047 (Ep. #049): DS9 The House of Quark
Round 048 (Ep. #050): VGR Future`s End, Part I
Round 049 (Ep. #051): TNG The Survivors
Round 050 (Ep. #052): TNG Who Watches The Watchers
Round 051 (Ep. #053): DS9 Civil Defense
Round 052 (Ep. #054): TOS The Ultimate Computer
Round 053 (Ep. #055): DS9 Defiant
Round 054 (Ep. #056): TOS Assignment: Earth
Round 055 (Ep. #057): DS9 Past Tense, Part I
Round 056 (Ep. #058): DS9 Past Tense, Part II
Round 057 (Ep. #059): DS9 Life Support
Round 058 (Ep. #060): TOS The Enterprise Incident
Round 059 (Ep. #061): DS9 Destiny
Round 060 (Ep. #062): ENT Similitude
Round 061 (Ep. #063): TNG Yesterday`s Enterprise
Round 062 (Ep. #064): TNG The Offspring
Round 063 (Ep. #065): DS9 Through The Looking Glass
Round 064 (Ep. #066): DS9 Improbable Cause
Round 065 (Ep. #067): DS9 The Die Is Cast
Round 066 (Ep. #068): VGR Scorpion
Round 067 (Ep. #069): VGR Scorpion, Part II
Round 068 (Ep. #070): ENT Azati Prime
Round 069 (Ep. #071): TNG Sarek
Round 070 (Ep. #072): DS9 The Adversary
Round 071 (Ep. #073): DS9 The Way of the Warrior, Part I
Round 072 (Ep. #074): TNG The Best of Both Worlds
Round 073 (Ep. #075): DS9 The Visitor
Round 074 (Ep. #076): VGR Year of Hell, Part I

Original Winners
Round 000 (Ep. #PIL): ENT Broken Bow
Round 004 (Ep. #006): TNG Where No One Has Gone Before
Round 008 (Ep. #010): VGR Prime Factors

Rounds 000-009; 059-074
TOS 429 points (16.5% average)
TNG 527 points (20.26%)
DS9 736 points (28.3%)
VGR 263 points (10.12%)
ENT 553 points (21.27%)